As spring training winds down and Opening Day looms, the Phillies are finalizing their roster. With a few players out of options and unable to be sent down without clearing waivers, some tough decisions are on the horizon. Let’s dive into the status of five key Phillies players and their chances of making the Opening Day roster.
Zach Pop - Out
Zach Pop’s journey to the Phillies’ roster has been anything but straightforward. Despite a rocky 2025 season, where he posted a 14.85 ERA over just 6.2 innings with the Mets and Mariners, Pop landed a major league deal in December. The Phillies saw potential, offering him a split contract worth $900,000 for his time in the majors.
However, spring training hasn’t gone as planned for Pop. New acquisitions Chase Shugart and Kyle Backhus have outshone him, particularly Backhus.
With no options left, Pop’s path to the bullpen looks blocked unless he finds a new MLB opportunity soon. If he clears waivers, the $250,000 minor league salary might convince him to accept an assignment.
Garrett Stubbs - Out
Garrett Stubbs faces an uphill battle to secure a roster spot. Competing with Rafael Marchán for the backup catcher role, Stubbs’ best shot might be as an extra left-handed bat against right-handed pitchers. Though his spring stats are underwhelming, he’s shown some promise against righties with a .267/.353/.467 line in limited at-bats.
The departure of super-utility player Dylan Moore opens a bench spot, but Stubbs’ limited versatility makes him a less appealing option outside of catcher. It seems Stubbs’ time with the Phillies might be coming to an end.
Jonathan Bowlan - Safe
Acquired in the Matt Strahm trade, Jonathan Bowlan is set to be a key piece in the Phillies’ bullpen. Despite an uneven spring, Bowlan’s ability to eat innings and his sub-four ERA in 34 games last season make him a reliable option. He’ll provide depth alongside Jhoan Duran, José Alvarado, Brad Keller, and Orion Kerkering.
Rafael Marchán - Under Review
Rafael Marchán finds himself in a familiar spot, vying for the backup catcher role. While his performance hasn’t been standout, it’s been enough to keep him in the mix.
Marchán’s potential upside gives him an edge over Stubbs, but the Phillies could still consider outside options if a better bat with comparable defense becomes available. Keep an eye on names like Elias Díaz and Christian Vázquez, who are having strong springs.
As the Phillies navigate these roster decisions, the mix of strategy and opportunity will shape their Opening Day lineup. Each player's fate hangs in the balance, and the final days of spring training will be crucial in determining who makes the cut.