The Phillies’ bullpen needs have become impossible to ignore, and Jeff Hoffman’s name is suddenly back in the conversation.
That’s the kind of twist that makes this deadline season interesting. Philadelphia already made a move to shore up the late innings by signing Brad Keller, but that plan took a major hit when Keller was diagnosed with a torn UCL last week. The injury will wipe out the rest of his season and keep him out for a significant stretch of 2027, leaving the Phillies with another opening to fill behind Jhoan Duran.
Bob Nightengale of USA Today recently pointed in that direction, writing, “[The Phillies] are in desperate need of a late-inning reliever, and would love to bring back Jeff Hoffman of the Toronto Blue Jays.”
Hoffman’s path back to Philadelphia would be a familiar one. He joined the Phillies on a minor-league deal in 2023 and got off to a rough start with the IronPigs, giving up seven earned runs in nine innings during his first month.
Then came the moment that changed everything: on April 21, Hoffman threw live batting practice to Bryce Harper as Harper worked his way back from Tommy John surgery. Harper liked what he saw, and two weeks later the Phillies selected and recalled Hoffman from Triple-A.
From there, Hoffman turned into one of the most effective relievers in baseball over two seasons in Philadelphia. Among qualified relievers, he finished in the top 10 in ERA (2.28), FIP (2.54), SIERA (2.65), WHIP (0.94), strikeout percentage (33.4), batting average against (.178), and fWAR (3.6). He also earned his first All-Star selection in 2024.
Toronto signed Hoffman to a three-year deal the next offseason, but the results haven’t matched the expectation. His ERA has climbed above four, even though the underlying numbers still point to a pitcher with plenty left in the tank.
His standing as the Blue Jays’ closer also took a hit after he blew a crucial save in Game 7 of the World Series. With Toronto sitting in the basement of the AL East and trying to figure out what comes next, a deal makes sense on paper.
The Blue Jays’ offense has been one of the biggest problems. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has posted a 95 wRC+, George Springer sits at 98 wRC+, and Toronto is averaging just 3.9 runs per game, the lowest mark in MLB. If the organization wants to position itself for a better run next season, moving a valuable trade chip like Hoffman could be part of that reset.
The challenge, of course, is price.
The Phillies and Blue Jays have until August 3 to work out a framework, and Mitch Bannon of The Athletic floated a deal that would send Hoffman back to Philadelphia. The centerpiece from the Phillies’ side would be Justin Crawford, a rookie outfielder who has hit .257/.304/.344 with 13 stolen bases in 93 games.
Scouts have had concerns about his offensive approach and his work in center field, and those issues have made his debut season mildly disappointing. Philadelphia isn’t eager to move him, especially with five more years of team control, but the front office should at least listen.
Bannon’s proposal also includes Daulton Varsho, whose bat doesn’t solve Philadelphia’s need for a right-handed hitter but whose overall value is hard to miss. He’s been a plus baserunner and elite defender throughout his career, won a Gold Glove in 2024, and has three 20-homer seasons on his résumé.
He’s also had a down year against right-handed pitching, posting a .664 OPS, and he could fit as a platoon partner for Derek Hill in center field. The question is whether his impending free agency helps or hurts Toronto in talks.
For the Phillies, the appeal is straightforward: they’d be betting that a return to familiar surroundings helps Hoffman get back to the All-Star level he showed in Philadelphia. Even with the inflated ERA, he still owns elite strikeout, whiff, and chase rates, and those numbers have started to show up in the run prevention too. Over his last 16 relief appearances, Hoffman has posted a 1.15 ERA.
If Philadelphia wants to avoid paying top-of-the-market prices for a bullpen arm like Mason Miller, this is the kind of move that deserves real consideration. The Phillies don’t need to empty the system for relief help, but they do need answers. In that context, a Hoffman reunion - even at a steep cost - starts to look like a deal worth serious thought.
In Other News...
Phillies May Be Closing In On The Veteran Arm They Need
The Phillies are already built around a strong front end of the rotation, but the conversation around their 2026 trade deadline plans is starting to sound familiar: if they want to make a deep October run, they may need another veteran arm to take some pressure off the top three. ESPNs Jesse Rogers pointed to a pair of experienced starters as possible fits, the kind of pitchers who could slide into a No. 4 role and give the club more stability when the games get bigger.
Philadelphias need is less about star power than balance. Zack Wheeler, Cristopher Sanchez and Jesus Luzardo give the Phillies a solid foundation, but the rotation has questions once you get past that group, with Aaron Nola still searching for consistency and the fifth spot unsettled. If the front office decides the answer has to come from outside the organization, this is the sort of market that could shape how far the Phillies think they can go next fall. [Read more 🡒]
Andrew Painter Is Creating A Phillies Rotation Dilemma Again
Andrew Painters latest step forward at Triple-A Lehigh Valley gave the Phillies another reminder of why his name keeps hanging over the rotation conversation. In his most recent outing, he worked six innings and allowed one run, part of a stretch that has made his recent starts look more and more like the version of Painter the organization has been waiting for.
For now, though, Philadelphia is still choosing patience while it sorts out the short-term rotation picture. Brian Keller appears to be the likely fifth starter in the near term, and the club is also expected to keep looking for help at the trade deadline, which leaves Painter as both a future answer and a current source of pressure on how the Phillies handle the rest of the season. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Deadline Search Just Got Awkward In A Hurry
The Phillies search for pitching help at the deadline has taken on a familiar kind of awkwardness, with Foster Griffin suddenly surfacing as a name to watch. Scouts from Philadelphia and Tampa Bay were both at his recent start, a sign that the left-hander is drawing real attention as Washington weighs whether to listen on a pitcher who has been effective this season.
For Philadelphia, the fit is easy to understand. The back end of the rotation has been an area to monitor, and Griffins performance has made him a plausible target if the Nationals decide to move him. The complication is just as obvious, though, because this is the kind of deal that can get tangled fast when a division club is involved and more than one contender is circling. [Read more 🡒]