J.T. Realmuto has been one of baseball’s steadiest catchers for years, but the Phillies are ready to lighten the load.
At Thursday’s year-end press conference, president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said Realmuto will not be asked to catch as often in 2027. Dombrowski said he had already spoken with Realmuto about the plan.
“ I said, ‘I don’t know if I can accomplish this, but I don’t want you to hear about it from the press conference, ” Dombrowski said of his conversation with Realmuto. “ ’My goal is to try to reduce the number of games you catch.’ ”
According to Dombrowski, Realmuto feels physically fine and is open to getting more days off behind the plate, with first base possibly becoming part of the mix.
The move comes after a rough offensive year for Realmuto following his three-year, $45MM deal signed in January. In 467 plate appearances, he hit .205/.283/.331 with 11 home runs and a 68 wRC+.
That was a career-low mark and well below the league average for catchers, who posted a 91 wRC+ in 2026. He did trim his strikeout rate to 21.4% and raised his walk rate to 7.9%, but those were about the only bright spots at the plate.
He managed a 130 wRC+ in July, yet every other month was below average.
Some of that damage may have been driven by poor luck on balls in play. Realmuto had never finished a season with a BABIP below .285, but he sat at .239 this year.
His .205 average and .331 slugging percentage also lagged behind his expected numbers, which checked in at a .249 xBA and .387 xSLG. Even so, his quality of contact slipped too.
His hard-hit rate dropped from 45.4% to 40.0%, and his barrel rate fell by 3.2%.
Behind the plate, Realmuto remained useful, even if he wasn’t quite at the peak level he showed in his late 20s and early 30s. Defensive Runs Saved had him at -5, while Fielding Run Value graded him at 0.
Statcast still viewed him as elite at throwing out runners and especially at pop time, where he landed in the 98th percentile. Blocking wasn’t a strength, but he handled the ABS challenge system well, successfully overturning 70 of 86 calls for an 81.4% success rate.
The Phillies’ intent here is less about punishing Realmuto’s defense and more about keeping him fresh and giving his bat a chance to rebound. The depth chart behind him, though, doesn’t make the job easy.
Rafael Marchán and Garrett Stubbs are the other catchers on the 40-man roster. Marchán has 334 plate appearances and a 58 wRC+ since 2020, while Stubbs owns a 47 wRC+ in the Majors since 2023.
Both bring defensive value, but both would be stretched thin if they’re asked to take on too much offense.
If Philadelphia looks outside the organization for help, the financial room may not be especially generous. MLBTR’s Payroll Tracker has the Phillies at $262.8MM in cash payroll for 2027, and that climbs to $298.8MM once their projected $36MM arbitration class is included, per MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz.
Non-tenders could trim that figure, and a backup catcher won’t break the bank in free agency. Even so, the Phillies are likely headed toward a payroll that tops their 2026 cash figure of $291.8MM.
In Other News...
Phillies May Have Pulled Off Another Pitching Bargain With Jess Luzardo
Jess Luzardo arrived in Philadelphia in a trade that cost the Phillies Emaarion Boyd and Starlyn Caba, and the early return has only strengthened the idea that the club may have found another pitching bargain. After landing him, the Phillies moved quickly to lock him in, agreeing to a five-year, $135 million deal that begins in 2027 and includes a sixth-year team option.
Luzardo backed up the investment with a strong 2026 season, posting a 2.86 ERA across 179.2 innings and giving the rotation the kind of stability Philadelphia covets. Inside the organization, the belief is that the coaching staff played a major role in helping him tap into that level, which is exactly why this move already feels like more than just a trade acquisition. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Face A Costly Jhoan Duran Decision Sooner Than Expected
Jhoan Duran has given the Phillies something they value as much as anything in October stakes: a closer they can trust late and a pitcher who could become expensive quickly. With just one year of team control left before free agency after the 2027 season, the front office is already staring at a decision that rarely gets easier with time. His performance puts him in the same conversation as the sports highest-paid relievers, the kind of company that includes recent contracts for Edwin Daz and Josh Hader.
For Philadelphia, the question is not whether Duran fits, but how high the price might climb if they want to keep him from ever getting to the open market. An extension has not been announced, and the timing matters because upcoming collective bargaining agreement negotiations could reshape future contract structures. The Phillies may decide sooner rather than later whether they want to chase a record-setting deal for a closer, or risk letting one of their most important arms become a much bigger issue down the road. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Still Have One Roster Problem Before Resting Their Vets
Dave Dombrowski spent part of the offseason talking through where the Phillies still need help, and the answer was pretty familiar for a team that expects to contend again: more pitching depth. The president of baseball operations pointed to both the bullpen and the rotation as areas where Philadelphia could use added support, while also acknowledging that the club will keep looking for ways to build in more flexibility across the roster.
The bigger picture is that the Phillies are trying to balance immediate needs with a longer runway, especially with several players headed toward free agency and veteran workloads something the front office wants to manage more carefully by 2027. There is also some lineup tinkering in the mix, with Bryce Harper expected to stay at first base and Kyle Schwarber a candidate for time there as well as designated hitter, leaving the club with one more roster question to solve before the veteran plan really settles into place. [Read more 🡒]