The Phillies entered the 2025 postseason riding high-96 wins, an NL East crown, and plenty of swagger. But that momentum hit a wall in the Division Series, where the defending champion Dodgers reminded everyone why they’re still the gold standard. Los Angeles took care of business in four games, ending Philadelphia’s October run earlier than expected and capturing their second straight World Series title in the process.
That sting didn’t last long in the Phillies’ front office. President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski wasted no time getting to work this offseason, starting with a move that was at the top of the priority list: bringing back Kyle Schwarber. The reigning National League home run champ re-upped with Philly on a new five-year deal, keeping one of the game’s most dangerous bats in the heart of the order.
From there, the focus shifted to addressing the roster’s soft spots-and Dombrowski hasn’t been shy about making adjustments. The Phillies added power-hitting outfielder Adolis García to the mix, a move that injects even more pop into an already potent lineup. And with top prospect Justin Crawford turning heads as spring training approaches, there’s a real sense that the outfield could be a position of both strength and surplus.
But that depth comes with decisions. Brandon Marsh figures to slide into left field, García likely takes over in right, and Crawford is pushing for a role in center.
That leaves Nick Castellanos in a bit of limbo. Schwarber could see some time in the outfield, Otto Kemp is in the picture, and the roster is starting to look a little crowded.
Which is why there’s growing buzz that the Phillies are exploring trade options for Castellanos.
Moving Castellanos wouldn’t just clear up the outfield logjam-it could also help address other areas of need. The Phillies are still looking to round out their rotation and reinforce the bullpen. A deal involving Castellanos could bring back a mid-rotation starter, a high-leverage reliever, or even a new everyday center fielder, depending on how the market shakes out.
And with young talent like Crawford and pitcher Andrew Painter expected to take on bigger roles this season, the Phillies are walking a fine line between developing from within and making aggressive win-now moves. Dombrowski has never been one to sit on his hands, and if the right deal presents itself, don’t be surprised to see him pull the trigger.
The rotation already has a strong foundation with Cristopher Sánchez, Aaron Nola, and Jesús Luzardo, and Zack Wheeler is expected to rejoin the staff after recovering from injury. But the departure of Ranger Suárez to Boston in free agency leaves a hole that still needs filling. If the Phillies want to keep pace in a loaded National League, they’ll need to shore up that final rotation spot.
Could they call the Marlins about Sandy Alcantara? It’s a long shot, especially within the division, but Dombrowski has made bolder moves before.
A team like Cincinnati, reportedly in the market for more power, could be a more realistic trade partner. Castellanos’ bat still plays, and there are plenty of teams that could use a veteran slugger with postseason experience.
The Phillies have been knocking on the door for a few years now, and the core of this team is built to win now. Whether it’s Castellanos or another piece, expect Dombrowski to stay aggressive. Every move from here on out is about one thing: getting back to the World Series and finishing the job this time.