The Phillies have reached the point where the winter has to mean more than just tinkering. After another Wild Card Series exit - their fifth straight postseason step backward - the front office is staring at a roster that still needs real help, and a projected arbitration bill could force some hard choices.
That’s where Brandon Marsh and Bryson Stott enter the conversation.
According to MLB Trade Rumors’ Matt Swartz, the Phillies’ nine-player arbitration class includes a few names that barely move the financial needle, but Duran, Marsh and Stott are projected at $10.9 million, $8.3 million and $9.2 million, respectively. That’s nearly $30 million tied up in three players. The rest of the group - Garrett Stubbs, Derek Hill, Tanner Banks, Rafael Marchán, Bryan De La Cruz and Orion Kerkering - are all projected to land below $2 million, making them much easier decisions.
Jhoan Duran is the easy call. The Phillies gave up two high-quality prospects to get him last summer, and he’s the only truly dependable arm in the bullpen. He’s not the one at risk here.
Marsh and Stott are a different story.
Both are heading into their final year of team control and would hit free agency after next season unless they sign extensions. Given how uneven both players have been, the Phillies may decide that a long-term commitment isn’t the best play. Keeping them for one more season is one path, but using them as trade chips could be more valuable.
That’s especially true because moving one or both would create breathing room for the Phillies’ winter shopping. Shedding close to $10 million for each player would give Dave Dombrowski more room to attack the areas that still need work: the outfield, the bullpen, and second and third base. Dombrowski has built a Hall of Fame résumé by spending big on free agents, and if this roster is going to be reshaped, that’s probably where he’ll go again.
There’s also the return to consider.
Marsh wouldn’t bring back a massive haul after his rough second half, but he still flashed enough earlier in the year that a team could see him as a worthwhile gamble. A decent reliever or a few lottery-ticket prospects could be enough to get a deal done.
Stott would draw a different kind of attention. At 29, he has given the Phillies steady defense at second base, third base and shortstop, and he posted a .736 OPS in 2026.
He also brings value on the bases, going 27-for-27 in stolen base attempts this year. That kind of all-around profile would appeal to a club looking for infield help.
Moving Stott would hurt, but it could also open the door for Philadelphia to chase a bat-first second baseman like Brandon Lowe this winter. A team in need of an infielder might be willing to send back well-regarded prospects or even major league-ready talent. It’s a gamble either way, but the kind the Phillies may need to make.
In Other News...
Red Sox Trade Speculation Keeps Raising One Massive Offseason Question
The Red Sox have never been shy about trying to upgrade through a trade, and that history has helped turn Bryce Harper into a recurring offseason talking point. For the Phillies, that alone is enough to make people pause, because Harper remains one of the most recognizable names in the sport and a central part of what Philadelphia has built around him.
Any talk like this quickly runs into the practical realities that matter most, though. Harpers no-trade protection gives him control over where a discussion even goes, and the money attached to a move would be a major hurdle for any team trying to make it work. For now, the idea lives in the same category as so many winter rumors, a mock proposal more than a roadmap, but it still underscores how closely rival clubs are watching the Phillies core. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Could Be Headed For An Offseason Shakeup Off The Field
The Phillies may be staring at a front-office change before the offseason really gets moving. The Philadelphia Athletics are reportedly weighing Sam Fuld, Philadelphias president of business operations and a former general manager, for their top executive job, putting one of the organizations more visible off-field leaders in the middle of a potentially important hiring cycle.
A decision from the Athletics is expected soon, and the ripple effect could be felt in Philadelphia if Fuld gets the nod. His departure would leave a vacancy in the Phillies front office and add another layer of uncertainty to an organization that could soon be navigating more than just roster questions as it heads into the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Trea Turner Has Become The Phillies' Toughest Offseason Debate
The Phillies are heading into an offseason that figures to be more restless than routine, and Trea Turner sits right in the middle of it. After a disappointing year, the front office has reason to examine almost every part of the roster, and Turners name is already surfacing in the kind of conversations that tend to follow a season that falls short of expectations. His contract alone makes any discussion complicated, and the fact that he is still a high-profile piece only raises the stakes for what comes next.
Even so, a trade feels like the sort of idea that gets talked through more than acted on. Turners age and recent struggles only add to the uncertainty, and the more immediate issue may be whether the Phillies decide he belongs somewhere other than shortstop. A move like that would not solve everything, but it would say a lot about how the club plans to balance its present with its future. [Read more 🡒]