Rafael Marchán’s early surge in the Venezuelan Winter League is not changing the way some Phillies fans feel about him, but it does underline why Philadelphia keeps coming back to him anyway.
Through seven games for Tiburones La Guaira, Marchán is hitting .333/.417/.429. That line looks a lot like the tail end of his impressive 2024 run, when he batted .294 with a .345 OBP and .549 slugging, even if that kind of production was never likely to last.
The larger body of work is still messy. Over the past two years, Marchán has hit .158/.217/.240 in 213 plate appearances, which is why plenty of fans have little patience for him. Even so, the Phillies have kept him around, and president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski has had a clear reason for that: the defense.
StatCast credited Marchán with seven catching runs last year, and he did that in just 34 games. That kind of number comes with a little sample-size weirdness, but it still points to one thing - Marchán remains one of the better defensive backstops in the league.
That’s the catch with this whole debate. Around baseball, backup catcher is usually a compromise. The Phillies can chase a better bat, sure, but the options are limited if they want someone who can handle a lighter workload and only play 40-60 games a season.
James McCann is probably the best free-agent alternative, at least offensively. He slashed .282/.311/.455 in 166 plate appearances last year. But the glove comes with a real cost: StatCast had him at minus-six catching runs in 2026, while also listing his pop time in the 20th percentile and his framing in the 11th percentile.
So no, this is not a case for pretending Marchán is some ideal answer. The point is simpler than that. There really isn’t a clean fix here, which is why Dombrowski will almost certainly give Marchán a chance to hold the job in spring training.
The Phillies will add competition at catcher. They have to.
With J.T. Realmuto aging and more vulnerable to injury, standing pat would be irresponsible.
And that’s why Marchán’s hot start in Venezuela matters, even if it doesn’t change his reputation much in Philadelphia. He’s still in the mix, and he’ll still be there when spring training arrives.
In Other News...
Phillies Bold Infield Idea Could Cost Bryson Stott
The Phillies are already staring at a tricky infield puzzle for 2026, and it starts with the possibility that Alec Bohm and Luis Arraez could be on the way to free agency. If that happens, the front office may have to decide whether to reshuffle the diamond again, including the possibility of Bryce Harper moving back to first base to create a cleaner fit elsewhere. It is the kind of roster planning that can change the entire shape of a lineup before spring even arrives.
One name that keeps surfacing in that conversation is Texas third baseman Josh Jung, a player who could give Philadelphia a more natural long-term answer at the hot corner. But getting him would not be a simple add, because the framework would likely force the Phillies to consider moving Bryson Stott, a decision that would carry real weight for a club trying to keep its infield balanced. Arraez could also factor back into the picture, and the challenge for the Phillies is finding the combination that improves the roster without creating a new hole somewhere else. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Make An Offensive Change Fans Will Definitely Debate
The Phillies are turning to a familiar name in the coaching world as they look for a spark on offense. Philadelphia is reportedly hiring Peter Fatse as its new hitting coach after parting ways with Kevin Long, a move that signals the club is not waiting around to see if last seasons struggles can be fixed without a fresh voice in the box.
Fatse arrives with some major-league experience after previously serving as the Boston Red Sox hitting coach, though his stint there ended in April 2026. For a Phillies team coming off a disappointing 2026 season, the hire is clearly aimed at getting more out of a lineup that never quite found its rhythm, and it figures to draw plenty of debate as fans weigh what changes should matter most. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Are Finally Making An Important Change Behind The Scenes
The Phillies are spending the offseason on more than just the obvious roster questions. After a disappointing offensive year, the organization is also reshaping the way it operates behind the scenes, promoting Dan Aucoin to lead the analytics research and development team and putting a sharper focus on how data flows into pitching, defense and hitting decisions.
Carlos Mendozas addition as infield coach is part of that broader push, with the expectation that he will work closely with the analytics group as the Phillies try to close the gap between information and on-field execution. For a team that knows it needs cleaner production across the board, these kinds of internal changes can matter just as much as the moves fans see on the field. [Read more 🡒]