Mike Schmidt’s night at the All-Star Game ended with more than a ceremonial toss. It ended with a clear sign that the Phillies great is done taking part in first-pitch duties - unless Philadelphia reaches the World Series.
Schmidt, 76, made his way out slowly on Tuesday night and ultimately chose to throw underhand to the catcher rather than attempt an overhand delivery. According to OnSI’s Jeff Kerr, Schmidt had tried to work through it, but he could not lift his right arm above his shoulder.
Mike Schmidt told me he was thinking of trying overhand for the first pitch, but he can’t lift his arm over his shoulder - so he was going to throw underhand.
Unless the #Phillies make the World Series, he said this is his last first pitch. pic.twitter.com/OsiAc8MYT3
- Jeff Kerr (@JeffKerrPHL) July 15, 2026
That means Schmidt is retiring from ceremonial first-pitch appearances, at least for now. He did leave himself one opening: if the Phillies make a World Series run, he’d consider doing it again.
Schmidt’s most recent first pitch before Tuesday came before Game 1 of the Phillies-Dodgers NLDS last October. That one didn’t go well either, eventually ending up in the air after Teoscar Hernández sent it into orbit after it mutated a few times.
Before that, Schmidt had shown up for a number of first-pitch moments over the years, including a co-appearance with George Brett before a Phillies-Royals game in 2013 and a 2017 spring training game.
For now, though, Tuesday’s underhand toss looks like the end of the line - unless October in Philadelphia gets loud enough to bring him back one more time.
In Other News...
Brandon Marsh Created A Citizens Bank Park Moment Phillies Fans Will Love
Citizens Bank Park got a rare All-Star Game flourish Tuesday night when Major League Baseball turned a mid-inning break into a live version of The Sandlot, sending kids riding bikes onto the field and into the middle of the festivities. For a ballpark that knows how to make noise, it was the kind of scene that felt tailor-made for Philadelphia, with the All-Star stage briefly giving way to something more playful and a lot more memorable.
Brandon Marsh was right in the middle of it, connecting with one young fan in a way that fit the moment and the setting, while Jacob Misiorowski also made time for the children on the field. Even the managers took note afterward, with Dave Roberts and John Schneider reflecting on how much the scene meant for the kids and for baseball, which is exactly why these All-Star extras tend to linger long after the final inning. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Linked To Dream Trade Target Fans Will Instantly Want
The Phillies have steadied themselves since the change from Rob Thomson to Don Mattingly, but the roster still has obvious pressure points as the deadline approaches. Pitching remains a concern, and the outfield picture has only gotten thinner with Adolis Garcia out for the season, leaving Philadelphia in the market for help if it wants to keep pushing in the second half.
That is why any rumor tied to Minnesota center fielder Byron Buxton is going to catch attention in a hurry. He fits the kind of impact profile the Phillies would love to add, but the path from speculation to reality looks awfully steep, and with the trade deadline set for Aug. 3, the clock is already working against any serious pursuit. [Read more 🡒]