The Eagles walked into Chicago as road favorites against a third-string quarterback and left with a mess that was hard to explain away. Philadelphia fell 27-7 to Case Keenum and the Bears on Monday night at Soldier Field, with the whole thing airing on ESPN’s “Monday Night Football.”
Keenum, 38 and making his first start since 2023, looked comfortable all night. He finished 24 of 34 for 247 yards and a 110.8 passer rating, while the Eagles kept shooting themselves in the foot with three turnovers and 10 penalties. That combination turned a game Philadelphia was supposed to control into a lopsided upset.
There were a few bright spots for the Eagles, but not nearly enough to cover the damage. DeVonta Smith delivered one of the night’s best plays with a 30-yard contested catch that helped spark the touchdown drive to close the first half.
Saquon Barkley, back after leaving last week’s game with a stinger, also gave Philadelphia life on the ground. He ran for 82 yards on 15 carries and averaged 5.5 yards per attempt, even if a couple of his longer runs disappeared because of penalties.
After the offense had mostly been stuck in the mud through two games, the run game finally showed some force.
Quinyon Mitchell was another clear bright spot. Chicago tried to scheme around him, but that was a risky plan.
Mitchell broke up a fourth-and-goal pass in the first half and later knocked away a third-and-5 throw in Philadelphia territory. Both plays came on out routes, and both were clean defensive wins.
He was excellent. The rest of the unit, not so much.
That’s where the trouble started for Philadelphia. Marcus Epps had a rough night after already needing to steady his starting job following a shaky Week 2 against the Titans.
He missed two tackles on Chicago’s 66-yard touchdown drive to open the game and later found himself rotating with Michael Carter II. The Eagles’ decision to sign Kenny Moore suddenly looks a lot more understandable.
The problems didn’t stop there. Vic Fangio’s defense never really settled in, with Drew Mukuba and Jihaad Campbell also struggling and the pass rush failing to get enough pressure on Keenum.
The Bears quarterback was able to work through the Eagles with easy throws and open crossers, and Ben Johnson’s play-calling again had Fangio chasing the game. Last year it was Chicago’s run game that bullied Philadelphia on Black Friday.
This time, it was the passing game.
The offensive side had its own ugly moments. Makai Lemon showed some flashes and made a couple of nice catches, but the way Sean Mannion has used him through three weeks has not worked. The side-to-side swing passes have gone nowhere, and the article’s verdict on them was blunt: they should have been retired yesterday.
Then there was Andy Dalton, who entered after Jalen Hurts went into concussion protocol and immediately delivered one of the night’s worst throws. On a third-and-goal from the 2-yard line, Dalton’s lone pass attempt became an interception, a moment that underscored just how bad the Eagles’ QB2 situation looked in the game’s context.
And the final blow came from Nick Sirianni’s decision-making. Trailing by 13 late in the fourth quarter, Philadelphia faced fourth-and-1 at the Bears’ 49-yard line and punted.
Before that, the Eagles tried to draw Chicago offside, took a delay of game penalty, and still chose to kick it away. Down two scores, needing one yard to keep a drive alive, they gave the ball back.
It was, by the numbers and by the moment, a hard call to defend.
In Other News...
Braves Roster Choice Just Changed This Phillies Wild Card Matchup
The Braves made their Wild Card Series roster move with the kind of caution that usually comes with October baseball, adding Luke Williams and Rowdy Tellez from Gwinnett while carrying 11 pitchers into the short series. It is a setup that says plenty about how Atlanta expects to play this round, with a roster built around starting pitching and selective use of the bench rather than a long, rolling relief plan.
For the Phillies, the opponents roster construction matters because it shapes how the matchup may unfold from the first game on. Atlanta is also expected to be without Martin Perez and Lane Thomas because of injuries, which trims some of the depth the Braves would normally lean on in a tight playoff series. The result is a familiar October tension for Philadelphia, one where the numbers on the roster card may matter almost as much as the names in the lineup. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Face Immediate Pressure After Game 1 Gamble Backfires
Jess Luzardo gave the Phillies a chance to settle in, working well enough to keep the opener tight against Atlanta before the game turned on a sequence the club cant afford to relive. Don Mattingly chose to lean hard on Jhoan Duran in Game 1 of the Wild Card Round, asking the closer to cover multiple innings in a high-stakes spot, and the decision looked viable until the game unraveled around a defensive misplay by Trea Turner and the hits that followed.
Austin Rileys game-winning home run finished the Braves comeback and left Philadelphia with an urgent problem as the series shifts forward. Now the Phillies have to win two straight to keep moving, and they may have to do it with Duran either unavailable or not fully right for Game 2, which puts even more pressure on a roster that already spent its best late-game weapon in a night that got away. [Read more 🡒]
Walt Weiss Sends A Clear Message Before Braves Phillies Showdown
The Braves finally locked up the NL East and punched their ticket to the postseason, then celebrated the division win after beating the Astros. It was a familiar kind of finish for a club that has spent the summer chasing another first-place finish, and it sets up a quick turnaround as the Wild Card Series opens Tuesday afternoon.
For Philadelphia, the timing adds another layer to a rivalry that already carries plenty of October weight. Walt Weiss made clear his team is not interested in worrying about the start time or the opponent, only about being ready when the next round begins. However the bracket settles, the Braves have put themselves in position to keep playing, and the Phillies now know the path ahead includes a division rival that sounds prepared for anything. [Read more 🡒]