The Phillies came away with just one National League Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger finalist, and it belongs to Kyle Schwarber. That alone says plenty about how the season looked in Philadelphia, especially with the club finishing with the worst OPS+ in Major League Baseball. But the bigger sting is Bryce Harper getting left out entirely.
Schwarber’s path to the award got a lot more interesting this time around because Shohei Ohtani, the other NL finalist at designated hitter, didn’t run away with the field. Ohtani has won Silver Slugger honors every year since joining the Los Angeles Dodgers, but his 2026 line - .275/.377/.512 with 30 homers in 618 plate appearances - opens the door for someone else.
Schwarber’s numbers don’t leap off the page in the same way. He hit .232/.354/.503 with 15 home runs, but he also logged 83 more plate appearances than Ohtani. That’s the heart of the debate now: do voters lean on the fuller workload, or do they reward the stronger rate stats?
There’s no clean way to say Schwarber was better than Ohtani when both were on the field. The production gap exists.
It’s not massive, but it’s there. Still, those extra 83 plate appearances matter, and they can’t just be brushed aside.
For Schwarber, this might be the last real shot at a Silver Slugger. Ohtani doesn’t exactly hand out down years often, and Schwarber’s own window at this level won’t last forever. If this is peak Schwarber, the Phillies should hope it sticks around.
Harper’s omission is the one that really jumps off the page. By his standards, he wasn’t at his sharpest, but a .269/.380/.485 slash line is still a strong season. It just wasn’t up to the standard he usually sets, and somehow that was enough to leave him off the first-base finalist list altogether.
The easiest defense of the snub is playing time. Harper finished with 109 games at first base. But that explanation gets shaky fast when Rafael Devers made the cut with only 100 games at first base.
Devers posted the same .865 OPS as Harper, though with an OBP 40 points lower. OBP carries more weight in run production than slugging, and Devers also had 60 fewer plate appearances.
Jake Bauers landed ahead of Harper in the voting as well, and that part at least makes some sense. Bauers had a slightly better OPS and OPS+, but he also had 115 fewer plate appearances. When the production gap is that small, sample size matters a lot.
The most glaring comparisons are Alec Burleson and Matt Olson. Both played in a similar sample to Harper, and all three reached 160 or more games, but Burleson and Olson finished with OPS marks 49 and 42 points lower than Harper’s. Burleson also didn’t match Harper’s home run total.
Nothing outside of RBI really supports the case for Burleson over Harper, and using RBI as the main argument in 2026 feels outdated.
Harper missing out on finalist status, much less being the favorite, is a miss by the voters - MLB managers and coaches. They may not lean on numbers the same way fans do, but this one still lands as a clear slight. And if Harper needed any extra fuel for 2027, he’s got it now.
In Other News...
Phillies Infield Plan May Come Down To One Risky Free Agent
The Phillies offseason infield search could end up circling around a familiar kind of gamble: adding a bat-first second baseman with real upside, but a track record that makes any commitment tricky. Brandon Lowe has been linked as a possible fit, and the appeal is obvious for a club looking to keep its lineup dangerous while sorting out the middle infield. The Athletic even floated a three-year, $63 million projection, a price that suggests there is enough interest to imagine this getting serious.
Lowes offensive production is what makes him stand out in a market where dependable infield help can disappear quickly, but the injury history is the part that keeps the conversation from feeling simple. For the Phillies, the question is whether the payoff is worth the risk if they decide to chase a player who could change the look of their infield depth chart. No agreement has been reported, and for now the idea remains just that, a possibility with enough upside to keep the rumor mill moving. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Have An Odd Voice In Baseballs Most Heated Fight
Garrett Stubbs may no longer be in the Phillies clubhouse, but he still has a seat at one of baseballs biggest tables. The former Philadelphia catcher is serving as the teams player representative in Major League Baseballs ongoing collective bargaining negotiations, keeping him involved in union meetings and votes even after being designated for assignment and moving on from the roster.
Its an unusual arrangement, but one that underscores how the labor fight extends beyond the players currently wearing a uniform. The talks have been especially contentious around the proposed salary cap, which players have pushed back against, and Stubbs role gives Philadelphia an indirect voice in a debate that could shape the sports next labor landscape. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Face A Brandon Marsh Decision That Could Divide Fans
The Phillies are heading into the offseason with the outfield once again under a microscope, and Brandon Marsh sits at the center of it. He gave the club plenty to like in the first half of the 2026 season, enough to remind everyone why he has been such an important part of the roster, but his second-half slide left the front office with a tougher evaluation than anyone wanted going into winter.
Philadelphia is trying to find more offense from its outfield, and that puts Marsh in a complicated spot. He has enough value to draw real interest if the Phillies decide to explore a trade, but moving on from a player with his upside would not sit well with everyone in the fan base. The decision is still ahead of them, and it could end up being one of the more debated calls of the offseason. [Read more 🡒]