The trade deadline brought its share of fireworks, but for a few contenders, the bigger story was what didn’t happen.
Around the league, clubs swung major deals, including the Tarik Skubal blockbuster between the Tigers and Dodgers and the Red Sox-Orioles swap for Adley Rutschman. But while some teams solved problems, others came up short on the exact needs they were trying to patch.
Philadelphia is the clearest example. The Phillies did land Luis Arraez, one of baseball’s best pure hitters, but they still left the deadline without the starting pitcher and outfielder they were chasing.
The Arraez move also triggers a major defensive shuffle for a club that already sits as the worst defensive team in the league. Bryson Stott is moving to third base, Alec Bohm is shifting to first, and Bryce Harper is going back to the outfield for the first time since 2022.
The rotation remains a real concern, too. Behind Cristopher Sanchez, Zack Wheeler and Jesus Luzardo, the Phillies have not gotten much help.
Aaron Nola has a 5.55 ERA and has allowed 28 home runs in 23 starts, a steep drop from the Cy Young-caliber version of him from his prime. Andrew Painter hasn’t been sharp in his first MLB season either.
For a team trying to hold its ground in a crowded National League wild-card race, that’s a risky hole to leave open.
Atlanta had its own missed chance. The Braves were in the market for a shortstop and pitching help, and they did add Tyler Mahle, but he reads more like depth than a difference-maker.
Reports said the Braves checked in on Jacob deGrom, though the former Cy Young winner made it clear he didn’t want to leave the Rangers. In the end, Atlanta didn’t land a meaningful upgrade for a rotation that has been hammered by injuries.
Shortstop was supposed to be another fix, but the market never really lined up. The Braves are expected to stick with Jim Jarvis and Ha-Seong Kim, who was just activated from the injured list.
Jarvis, 25, has held his own since being called up in June, posting a .701 OPS with one home run and 10 RBIs in 26 games. Kim, on the other hand, has been rough: five hits in 27 games, a .068 batting average and a .239 OPS.
For a team with World Series hopes, that’s a painfully familiar problem since Dansby Swanson left.
The Yankees also walked away with a hole still staring them in the face. They added a pair of hitters to help a lineup that has sagged since Aaron Judge went on the IL, but they never solved their biggest need: catcher.
New York was reportedly in the mix for Adley Rutschman, but didn’t want to push into the kind of massive package Boston used to get him. Hunter Goodman would have required a hefty price, and Brian Cashman apparently wasn’t eager to pay it.
Ryan Jeffers was another name the Yankees looked at, but Minnesota ended up buying instead. Tyler Stephenson fit as well, though it’s unclear how far those talks ever got.
So the Yankees are left leaning on Austin Wells, who has been steady behind the plate but has been one of the least productive hitters in the majors. Heliot Ramos and Luis Garcia Jr. were brought in to help the offense, but New York still has to make do with the production it’s getting from Wells, J.C. Escarra and Ali Sanchez.
Milwaukee’s deadline was quieter in the wrong places, too. The Brewers did come away with starting pitcher Dustin May and reliever JoJo Romero in a deal with the Cardinals, but their bigger need was a power bat, and they never found one. No team in MLB has fewer home runs than Milwaukee’s 101, and while the Brewers have still scored runs at a high clip, ranking fifth in the league, the lack of a true slugger stands out.
That matters even more in October, when one swing can change everything. The Brewers had a chance to add that kind of threat and couldn’t get it done.
They also fell short in their pursuit of Tarik Skubal, choosing to protect their farm system rather than make a bigger push. In the end, they improved only a little while watching the Dodgers get substantially better.
In Other News...
Phillies Fans May Hate What Dombrowski Just Paid At The Deadline
The Phillies went shopping hard before the deadline, and Dave Dombrowski filled multiple needs with a series of moves aimed at sharpening both the offense and the bullpen. Philadelphia came away with Luis Arraez and Caleb Kilian from the Giants, Brooks Raley from the Mets, and Colby Thomas from the As, giving the roster a noticeably different look for the stretch run.
Of course, deadline upgrades come with a price, and the Phillies paid it in prospects and young depth pieces. Ramon Marquez, Marty Gair, John Spikerman, Luke Gabrysh and Seth Johnson all headed out in the various deals, which is the part of the equation fans usually feel later, once the immediate buzz of adding help wears off. The real question now is whether the talent coming back is enough to justify what Philadelphia gave up to get it. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Still Face One October Rotation Question After Deadline
The Phillies checked off one need before the deadline by landing Luis Arraez, but the more obvious summer question still lingered when the dust settled: the rotation. Philadelphia was widely expected to add another starting pitcher, yet it passed without making that move, leaving the club to keep sorting through how it wants to line up for October and beyond.
Clay Holmes was among the names viewed as a possible match for that role, especially given his track record of working both as a starter and out of the bullpen in the majors. Instead, he ended up with the Cubs, and with his return from a fractured fibula expected soon, the deadline now leaves the Phillies looking back at a pitching market that offered one more fit they did not land. [Read more 🡒]
LeBrons First Philly Mural Is Feeding One Local Fan Obsession
Philadelphia has a new basketball mural to talk about, and this one is already drawing the kind of attention that comes with any LeBron James image in a city that takes its sports art seriously. It is his first Philadelphia mural as a member of the Sixers, joining a visual landscape that already includes plenty of familiar local faces, from Jalen Hurts to Bryce Harper, and that makes the placement matter almost as much as the player on the wall.
For some fans, the bigger question is where it landed, because one Philadelphia mural spot in particular has built a reputation for featuring athletes who then struggle. This LeBron piece is not at the Garage Fishtown wall, the location that has become its own minor sports superstition, and that alone will probably keep the conversation going among the kind of fans who watch everything from roster moves to street art for a sign of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]