Andrew Painter’s latest work in Triple-A won’t erase the disappointment of his rough Phillies debut, but it does give Philadelphia something it badly needs right now: a little breathing room.
The 23-year-old right-hander was thrown into a rotation spot coming out of spring training, and the results were brutal. He posted a 7.06 ERA across 14 major league games before the Phillies sent him to Lehigh Valley after a miserable June 17 start against the Miami Marlins. That kind of collapse is hard to ignore, especially for a former top pitching prospect who had already lost plenty of goodwill with fans.
But the early returns since the demotion have been much better. Painter has made just two starts in the three-plus weeks since going down, and both have pointed in the right direction.
In his first outing, he worked four innings of one-run ball and struck out four. Then on Sunday, he followed that up with six more innings of one-run work, striking out six without issuing a walk and showing good life on his fastball.
Andrew Painter made his 2nd start for Lehigh Valley tonight.
6.0 IP, 1 ER, 4 H, 6 K, 0 BB - 69 pitches, 48 strikes
Fastball was at 97 in the 6th and sinker touched 98 in the 1st. #Phillies
- Jeff Kerr (@JeffKerrPHL) July 5, 2026
There’s still a huge gap between dominating Triple-A hitters and getting major league outs, and Painter’s track record at the highest level of the minors last season wasn’t clean either, since he finished with an ERA over 5.00 there. Even so, this looks like a pitcher who may be settling back in after a disastrous stretch.
That matters for a Phillies team staring at a trade deadline problem. The top three in the rotation - Zack Wheeler, Cristopher Sánchez and Jesús Luzardo - are in solid shape.
Beyond that, things get messy fast. Aaron Nola, even after a solid outing on Sunday, has been a mess overall, and the fifth spot is wide open.
Philadelphia may only need four reliable starters in a short playoff series, but the regular season still demands a fifth arm to soak up innings. That means Dave Dombrowski almost certainly has to shop for pitching help before the deadline.
The catch is that the Phillies don’t have much to trade. Their farm system is thin, with top-100 prospect Aidan Miller sidelined all season by a back injury. Outside of last year’s first-round pick Gage Wood, there aren’t many premium pieces available to use in a major deal.
If the Phillies chase a controllable starter such as Joe Ryan or a rental at the level of Tarik Skubal, they’d likely have to include Wood and more, which would strip the upper end of the system. And starting pitching isn’t the only area they need to address; right field and late-inning relief are also on the list. That makes Painter’s progress especially useful, because it could keep the club from overpaying for a rotation fix.
If his stock keeps improving enough that the Phillies believe he can reclaim a full-time rotation role in 2027, then the front office may not need to swing for the fences on a starter. A cheaper stopgap like Drew Anderson could be enough to cover the innings while the team saves its limited prospect capital for other needs.
Painter’s future won’t be decided by a couple of strong minor league starts. He’s still young, and the talent that once made him a prized arm hasn’t disappeared. But if this recent stretch is the start of a real turnaround, it could take some of the pressure off Philadelphia’s biggest deadline headache.
In Other News...
The Schmitter Is Finally Coming Back To Citizens Bank Park
For Phillies fans with a long memory, one of Citizens Bank Parks most beloved ballpark sandwiches is making a comeback. The Schmitter, that hybrid cheesesteak piled with steak, onions, cheese, salami and tomatoes on a Kaiser roll, is set to return for the MLB All-Star Game and then stay on the menu for the rest of the season, giving the park a little extra local flavor at a time when food traditions matter almost as much as the baseball.
The sandwich was a fixture at Citizens Bank Park from 2004 to 2016 before disappearing because the kitchen space could not support making it at the quality the park wanted. Now Aramark says it has been working to bring the Schmitter back and hopes to find a longer-term solution, which at least gives Phillies fans a reason to keep an eye on the concessions line as the summer rolls on. [Read more 🡒]
Zack Wheeler Was Livid After Phillies Fans Saw Another All-Star Snub
Zack Wheelers latest All-Star snub landed with extra sting for Phillies fans because it came in the middle of another dominant season, one that has only reinforced how indispensable he has been on the mound. Since returning in late April from thoracic outlet syndrome surgery, Wheeler has looked like the same top-line starter the Phillies have built around, piling up strikeouts and run prevention that made his omission feel less like a judgment on performance and more like a bureaucratic quirk.
Wheeler was especially irritated by the way the selection process played out, and his frustration made sense after a seven-inning, 14-strikeout start that only sharpened the case for him. With a 2.28 ERA and the kind of workload that usually earns All-Star recognition, he has given the Phillies everything they could ask for, even if the roster rules created a technicality that kept him out of the game. [Read more 🡒]