PHILADELPHIA -- Andrew Painter is forcing the Phillies to take a closer look, but they still aren’t ready to rush him.
After one of the roughest stretches of his pro career earlier this month, Painter has steadied himself at Triple-A Lehigh Valley and put together back-to-back outings that at least reopen the conversation about Philadelphia’s rotation. His latest start Sunday was his fifth since being demoted, and it may have been his most encouraging yet.
Painter worked six innings for the IronPigs and gave up just one run, with the lone damage coming on a sixth-inning homer by Indianapolis Indians second baseman Termarr Johnson. He scattered five hits, struck out six and didn’t issue a walk.
Over his last two starts, Painter has logged 11 innings, allowed three runs, struck out 14 and walked one for a 2.45 ERA. He also made Sunday’s outing on four days’ rest, which matters for a pitcher the Phillies are trying to rebuild carefully.
That patience has been the message from the big club all along.
"When we sent Paint (Painter) down, it was not gonna be something that 'Oh Paint's doing something (good). Now he's ready.'
It was gonna be let Andrew develop, let him pitch. Let's let him work.
Keep getting better. And then when's he's ready, we'll see him again."
The Phillies are not about to treat a couple of sharp starts as a green light. Painter’s trip back to form has been gradual, and the organization has been deliberate about how it handles him.
His last start before Sunday came last Tuesday, when he threw five innings, allowed two runs, struck out eight and walked one. That outing also came on 11 days’ rest, with the All-Star Break giving him extra time between appearances.
Before that, the Phillies needed to help him reset after a brutal July 10 outing, when he gave up seven runs in 2 2/3 innings. That was the low point in a season that went sideways after he opened the year in the majors following spring training.
Painter’s big-league numbers were rough: a 1-8 record, a 7.06 ERA in 14 games, 53 strikeouts, 24 walks and 14 home runs allowed before he was sent down in mid-June.
At Lehigh Valley, the results have been mixed overall, but the signs are better. Painter is 1-2 with a 4.56 ERA in five games for the IronPigs, and the stuff has reportedly looked sharper.
His fastball has more life and spin, and his command has tightened up. He has 25 strikeouts and eight walks in Triple-A.
Still, the Phillies are thinking long-term as much as they are thinking about the next turn through the rotation. There’s a real possibility Painter doesn’t come back this season at all, with the club potentially building him up for the 2027 rotation.
For now, Philadelphia needs help in the fifth spot. The Phillies are looking for a starter at the trade deadline and have not won a game with the No. 5 starter on the mound since May 18, a stretch that has turned into 11 straight losses.
They need someone this week, and Brian Keller appears to be the likely answer. Keller still had a locker in the clubhouse and was working out with the pitchers before Sunday’s series finale against the Yankees. His turn would come Friday in Baltimore, assuming the Phillies don’t go with an opener.
"He's still here, so that gives you some sort of insight on what we're thinking," Mattingly said. "That could change...but I think the fact he's still here. We were going to use him at some point."
In Other News...
Phillies May Be Closing In On The Veteran Arm They Need
The Phillies are already built around a strong front end of the rotation, but the conversation around their 2026 trade deadline plans is starting to sound familiar: if they want to make a deep October run, they may need another veteran arm to take some pressure off the top three. ESPNs Jesse Rogers pointed to a pair of experienced starters as possible fits, the kind of pitchers who could slide into a No. 4 role and give the club more stability when the games get bigger.
Philadelphias need is less about star power than balance. Zack Wheeler, Cristopher Sanchez and Jesus Luzardo give the Phillies a solid foundation, but the rotation has questions once you get past that group, with Aaron Nola still searching for consistency and the fifth spot unsettled. If the front office decides the answer has to come from outside the organization, this is the sort of market that could shape how far the Phillies think they can go next fall. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Deadline Search Just Got Awkward In A Hurry
The Phillies search for pitching help at the deadline has taken on a familiar kind of awkwardness, with Foster Griffin suddenly surfacing as a name to watch. Scouts from Philadelphia and Tampa Bay were both at his recent start, a sign that the left-hander is drawing real attention as Washington weighs whether to listen on a pitcher who has been effective this season.
For Philadelphia, the fit is easy to understand. The back end of the rotation has been an area to monitor, and Griffins performance has made him a plausible target if the Nationals decide to move him. The complication is just as obvious, though, because this is the kind of deal that can get tangled fast when a division club is involved and more than one contender is circling. [Read more 🡒]