The New York Giants have added a new name to the NFC East quarterback picture, reportedly landing J.J. McCarthy in a trade with the Minnesota Vikings after Jaxson Dart’s season-ending injury last week.
It’s an acquisition that will draw plenty of eye-rolls, and not without reason. McCarthy’s NFL start has been rough. The No. 10 overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft missed his entire rookie year because of injury, then went on to throw 11 touchdowns against 12 interceptions with a 72.6 passer rating last season.
His place in Minnesota had already faded fast. With the Vikings bringing in Kyler Murray and bringing back Carson Wentz, McCarthy had slipped to third on the quarterback depth chart.
From a pure optics standpoint, it’s easy to see why the move is getting laughed at, especially with the Giants trying to keep their season from slipping away. But the deal doesn’t look especially costly. New York gave up a 2027 fifth-round pick, and the team was already projected to have two picks in that round, so it still keeps one.
McCarthy turns 24 in January, and there’s no guarantee he jumps Jameis Winston on the depth chart. He might not even do that. Still, he’s probably a better option than Jake Haener, who was QB2 in Week 3.
And if the Giants get to a point later this season where they’re officially out of it, there’s not much value in putting Winston out there just to see more of the same. That’s where McCarthy could come in.
The Giants could give him snaps and see whether there’s anything worth holding onto, either as a backup-type option or as a possible offseason trade chip. He’s under contract through the 2027 season.
As for the Eagles, they may not see him right away. Unless Winston gets hurt or falls apart badly, McCarthy probably won’t be on the field when Philadelphia faces the Giants in Week 9. But there’s a chance that changes by Week 18.
In Other News...
Eagles May Need A Real Linebacker Change Fans Saw Coming
Jihaad Campbell has settled in as the Eagles primary inside linebacker this season, and the rookie has done what coaches ask first by showing up around the ball. He leads the team in tackles, which is exactly why his role has become such a useful measuring stick for the defense as a whole. But the tape has also made clear where the growing pains are, especially when opponents force him into pass coverage and test him as the primary defender.
That is where Jeremiah Trotter Jr. keeps creeping back into the conversation. He saw plenty of praise during training camp and the preseason, but his defensive snaps have stayed limited once the games started to matter. With coverage issues hanging over the middle of the field, the Eagles may have a straightforward adjustment staring at them, and it could mean giving Trotter a bigger rotational role sooner rather than later. [Read more 🡒]
Sirianni Just Fueled A Brutal Eagles Debate About This Offense
The late-third-quarter decision against the Bears has kept the Eagles offense in the spotlight, and not just because of the score. With Philadelphia trailing by 13 points on Monday night, Nick Sirianni opted against trying to convert a 4th and 1, a choice that quickly drew criticism as the kind of conservative call that can shrink a comeback window in a hurry. In a game like that, every possession carries extra weight, especially when the offense is already fighting uphill.
Sirianni later said he should have gone for it, which only sharpened the larger debate around how aggressive this group needs to be when the margin is slipping away. For an Eagles offense that has been under a microscope, the moment became less about a single play and more about philosophy, the kind of call that can linger because it speaks to trust, urgency and how much risk the staff is willing to take when the game starts to tilt. [Read more 🡒]
Eagles Fans Have Every Right To Be Furious Over This Jalen Carter No-Call
On a single snap that had Eagles fans shaking their heads, Jalen Carter powered through his blocker with a sharp swim move and looked poised to finish the rush on quarterback Case Keenum. Instead, he was shoved from behind by an offensive lineman behind the line of scrimmage, a contact that appeared to knock him off the play just as he was closing in.
The no-call stood, even though the shove may have kept Carter from a sack, and the sequence only got stranger when Rome Odunze dropped a touchdown pass on the same play. For Philadelphia, it was the kind of moment that leaves plenty of frustration behind, not just because of what Carter did right, but because the flag never came. [Read more 🡒]