The Eagles’ edge-rush logjam could force a tough decision next offseason, and ESPN’s Seth Walder thinks one of the names in the middle of it will be moved.
Philadelphia has spent the last half-decade stacking its defense through the draft, landing cornerstone talents like Jordan Davis, Jalen Carter, Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean. That kind of success comes with a price tag, though, and Howie Roseman is now staring at the kind of roster squeeze that usually leads to hard choices.
Walder’s prediction is straightforward: the Eagles will trade Jalyx Hunt or Nolan Smith Jr. before the 2027 season. In his view, the addition of Jonathan Greenard changes the math.
"The Eagles will trade Jalyx hunt of Nolan Smith Jr. ahead of the 2027 season," Walder predicts. "They will be entering the final year of their deals and are the second- or third-best pass rusher on the Eagles, in some order, with Greenard aboard."
Philadelphia already made a major move this offseason by sending multiple late Day 2 picks to the Minnesota Vikings for Greenard. Roseman then gave him a $100 million contract, a clear sign the team plans to lean on him heavily up front. With that deal on the books, keeping both Smith and Hunt long term starts to look unrealistic.
That’s why the idea of moving one of them next offseason makes sense. It would give the Eagles a chance to grab draft compensation while avoiding a more difficult contract situation down the line.
The two edge rushers are nearly the same age - both 25, with Smith 54 days older than Hunt - and both were part of the Super Bowl run. They’re also set to hit free agency at the same time. But the details around their recent seasons make the picture a little more interesting.
Hunt just posted a breakout year, piling up 6.5 sacks, 52 tackles, nine tackles for loss, 24 quarterback hits, two forced fumbles, one fumble recovery and three interceptions in 17 games. One of those picks was a pick-six of Carson Wentz.
Smith’s season was quieter and shortened by injury. He played in 12 games and finished with one forced fumble, 3.0 sacks, 31 tackles, one tackle for loss and 11 quarterback hits.
If the Eagles do choose between them, Hunt may be the one they prefer to keep. His upside appears higher after that strong 2025 season in Vic Fangio’s defense, and he is still learning the position after switching in college. Smith, meanwhile, would also bring back more financial relief in a trade next offseason because he’ll be on his fifth-year option, while Hunt will still be on the final year of his rookie deal.
Walder’s call points to a future decision Philadelphia may have to make sooner rather than later. For now, though, the Eagles have one more season to sort through the rotation - and fans may be watching the 2026 campaign with the sense that it could be the last with one of those 25-year-old edge rushers still in green.
In Other News...
Za'Darius Smith Just Reopened A Frustration Eagles Fans Know Well
ZaDarius Smith is back in the news, and for Eagles fans it brings a familiar mix of what-ifs and unfinished business. After spending last season in Philadelphia and appearing in five games before retiring, the veteran edge rusher had been tied to a potential return to Cleveland, where he previously worked with Kevin Stefanski, only for his next step to shift in a different direction after a workout.
Now the Falcons are the team making the move, a sign of how quickly the edge-rush market can change when injuries and suspensions start thinning a depth chart. For the Eagles, it is another reminder of how brief Smiths stint in Philly was and how often his career seems to send him back into the spotlight just when one landing spot looks settled. [Read more 🡒]
Eagles Rookie Battle Is Suddenly Separating Roster Locks From Bubble Names
The Eagles rookie class has already started to sort itself into two clear groups as camp moves along, with the early draft picks looking far more secure than the rest of the first-year crowd. Philadelphia has spent the summer evaluating 15 rookies across different spots on the roster, and the picture is becoming clearer by the day as some players push toward opening-week roles while others are fighting just to stay in the conversation for the 53-man roster or practice squad.
Jalen Lemons path has been slowed by a hamstring injury that has kept him out since Aug. 4, though he is close to getting back on the field, while the tight end picture also carries some real intrigue with Stowers trending toward a healthy scratch as the TE3 for Week 1. Elsewhere, Bell, Payton, Morris, Wisniewski, Bernard and James-Newby are all being judged not just on talent, but on how quickly they can turn their development into something the Eagles can actually use once roster cuts arrive. [Read more 🡒]
Eagles Camp Picture Is Getting Clearer At Wide Receiver
The Eagles twelfth training camp practice offered another look at a receiver room that is slowly starting to take shape, even as the injury report continues to do a lot of the heavy lifting. Makai Lemon, Tank Bigsby and Johnny Wilson were all sidelined, while DeVonta Smith and safety Cole Wisniewski were among the players working on a limited basis as Philadelphia keeps sorting through who can stack full practices ahead of the 2026 season.
Smith was back in a helmet and getting in some position work after the hamstring issue that had slowed him, a small but encouraging step for a passing game that still needs its top targets available and sharp. Lemon, meanwhile, stayed out of the full session but kept moving on the side field, running routes and going through the catch circuit as the Eagles continue to monitor a camp picture at wide receiver that is becoming clearer even if it is not settled yet. [Read more 🡒]