Joe Milton III is about to get his first real shot with the Eagles, and the first thing Philadelphia fans will want to know is simple: can he give this offense something it has been missing?
Milton is set to make his first NFL start in Week 9 against the New York Giants in his seventh regular season appearance. The Eagles have turned to him after naming him the starter over Tanner McKee, who started the last three games in place of the injured Jalen Hurts and went 0-3.
Fans have already seen Milton in brief glimpses during his two-year NFL career with the New England Patriots and the Dallas Cowboys, but this is different. This is the first time he’s been asked to carry a meaningful role in a meaningful game. If he wants to earn trust as a future backup, there are three things he has to show.
The biggest one is whether he can push the ball downfield. Since McKee took over, the passing game has lost its juice.
Explosive plays have dried up, and McKee rarely challenged defenses deep. His longest pass over the last three games was a 34-yard completion to rookie tight end Eli Stowers, though that play was really more of a short-to-intermediate throw that Stowers turned into extra yardage on his own.
Milton brings a different profile. He has a reputation from practice this week for having serious arm strength and the ability to throw it longer than 60 yards. For an Eagles offense that could use a spark, that kind of vertical threat would matter right away.
He also needs to show he can use his legs. Milton ran a 4.62-second 40-yard dash and has enough mobility to create plays on the ground. In his six-game NFL career, he has rushed for 66 yards on 15 carries and scored a touchdown.
That matters for an Eagles offense line that has allowed the third-most sacks in the league, with 21. It also matters because the running game has not been especially efficient. Among the five running backs who have carried the ball for Philly, they are averaging 3.4 yards per carry, while the team as a whole is at 3.8.
Philadelphia has missed the scrambling element Jalen Hurts brings, along with the threat of RPO looks. McKee, for all his steadiness, is more of a pocket passer and doesn’t offer the same kind of movement. Milton could add a layer this offense has lacked, helping open things up for the backs and giving the unit a little more creativity.
And then there’s the ball security piece, which may be the most important of all. The Eagles have been bad overall this season, but they have protected the football reasonably well, with only eight turnovers, tied for the sixth-fewest in the NFL.
Milton’s own turnover history is a little shakier. In 53 pass attempts, he has thrown two interceptions, and he has also fumbled twice in his six NFL games.
That’s the part that could make fans nervous. Turnovers happen, but Milton can’t afford to give the Giants extra chances.
If he puts the ball in harm’s way at least twice, Philadelphia is not going to win this. The path to building trust starts with limiting those mistakes and pairing that with the kind of explosive plays this offense has been missing.
In Other News...
Eagles Make Another QB Change As Season Starts Slipping Away
With the season slipping further off course at 2-6, the Eagles are turning again to a new face under center for Week 9 against the Giants. Joe Mixon, signed from the Cowboys practice squad three weeks ago, has been named the starter, giving Philadelphia another reset as it tries to find some stability on offense after a rough stretch.
Mixon takes over for Tanner McKee, who was recently benched, and the move adds another layer to a quarterback situation that has changed quickly as the losses have piled up. Nick Sirianni said he believes Mixons athleticism can help lift the offense, and now the Eagles will see whether this latest switch can offer more than just another temporary fix. [Read more 🡒]
Eagles May Be Heading For A Deadline Selloff After This Loss
The latest loss to the Giants only sharpened the sense that the Eagles are at a crossroads, with their playoff path slipping further out of reach and the front office staring at a difficult decision. In that kind of season, Howie Roseman has never been shy about thinking ahead, and the looming trade deadline now looks like a chance to turn a disappointing year into a longer-term reset by collecting future draft capital.
Philadelphia has a handful of players who could draw calls from around the league, and the list speaks to how many moving parts this roster still has. Cornerback Riq Woolen, tight end Dallas Goedert, defensive tackle Moro Ojomo, offensive lineman Matt Dickerson and edge rusher Nolan Smith all sit in the conversation as Roseman weighs whether to keep patching holes or start reshaping the roster more aggressively before the deadline passes. [Read more 🡒]
Giants QB Situation Just Took Another Alarming Turn With JJ McCarthy
The Giants quarterback picture got even murkier against the Eagles when JJ McCarthy exited early in the third quarter with a throwing shoulder injury. McCarthy had been moving the offense reasonably well before leaving, completing 9 of 13 passes for 101 yards, but the injury came while he was scrambling and immediately forced New York to turn to Jameis Winston.
For a team already trying to navigate life without Jaxson Dart, who is out for the rest of the 2026 regular season with a severe left knee injury, losing another quarterback only deepens the concern. Philadelphia has seen plenty of NFC East chaos over the years, but this one leaves the Giants with a battered depth chart and a lot of unanswered questions about how theyll piece together the position moving forward. [Read more 🡒]