The Philadelphia 76ers made waves in the 2025 NBA Draft by selecting VJ Edgecombe, a player who’s quickly proving to be a cornerstone with his energetic, two-way play. Now, looking back, would the Sixers make the same choice if Dylan Harper had been available?
The 2025 rookie class, featuring standout names like Cooper Flagg, Dylan Harper, Edgecombe, and Kon Knueppel, has been nothing short of spectacular. Each player has shown the potential to become an All-Star, making this draft class one for the ages.
VJ Edgecombe Shines Bright
The 76ers have little reason for regret, even with Knueppel lighting it up for the Charlotte Hornets, likely on his way to winning Rookie of the Year. Edgecombe’s performance has been stellar, stepping into the starting lineup for 67 games on a playoff team, and averaging 16.1 points, 5.7 rebounds, and four assists per game. His defensive prowess is evident with 1.4 steals per game, leading his class.
Edgecombe and his dynamic play are central to the Sixers’ backcourt future. Philadelphia didn’t miss with their pick, especially considering past struggles with No. 3 picks, like the Jahlil Okafor era.
But would they choose differently if given the chance? Knueppel’s shooting is tempting, but what if the choice was between Edgecombe and the 6'6" point guard Dylan Harper?
The Re-Draft Scenario
In a hypothetical re-draft, Cooper Flagg remains the top pick for the Dallas Mavericks, while Kon Knueppel goes second to the San Antonio Spurs. This leaves the 76ers with a choice between Edgecombe and Harper, now armed with the hindsight of their rookie performances.
Edgecombe has taken on a significant role for the Sixers, while Harper has been a key rotation player for a Spurs team poised to win 60 games, despite coming off the bench behind stars like De'Aaron Fox. Harper’s contributions are notable, averaging 11.5 points, 3.4 rebounds, and 3.9 assists per game, though his shooting lags behind Edgecombe’s.
Harper’s real magic lies in his ability to attack the basket. Over half of his shots come from within 10 feet, and he converts 66% of those at the rim-a stat typically reserved for big men. His aggressive drives not only yield high-percentage shots but also create opportunities for teammates on the perimeter.
Philadelphia's Hypothetical Choice
In this alternate draft scenario, the 76ers opt for Harper, valuing his size and playmaking alongside Tyrese Maxey, who could then shift to his natural shooting guard spot. While both players offer unique advantages, Harper’s fit and potential slightly edge out in this hypothetical choice.
However, this remains a "what if," as the organization is thrilled with Edgecombe’s impact. It’s easy to see why Philly might stick with their original selection.
The real story here is the incredible talent of these young guards. Their early careers suggest a future filled with All-Star appearances and intense competition for All-NBA honors. The 76ers, along with fans, can look forward to watching these stars shine for years to come.