Tommy Carr Just Gave Michigan Fans A Real Quarterback Debate

Tommy Carr's second-half heroics breathed new life into Michigan's offense, paving the way for a crucial victory over Penn State and igniting a potential quarterback controversy.

ANN ARBOR, Mich. - Michigan spent two weeks getting ready for a Penn State team that had dropped three straight, and the first half looked nothing like the response the Wolverines needed. The offense never got rolling, Bryce Underwood threw two interceptions, and Michigan managed just 80 yards before halftime.

Then Tommy Carr entered the picture, and the whole game shifted.

The true freshman came on in the second half and gave Michigan exactly the kind of jolt it had been missing. The Wolverines scored two touchdowns after the switch, and Carr kept his composure through the chaos that followed.

Penn State answered with a touchdown of its own, but Michigan’s defense came up with the biggest takeaway of the night when Chris Bracy stripped Rocco Becht late in the fourth quarter. Carr then finished the job with a 12-yard touchdown run as Michigan pulled out a 21-18 win and improved to 4-2.

For a team that had spent the week talking about cleaning things up, the opening half was a rough reminder of how far off track the offense had been. Underwood’s first interception came when he underthrew Andrew Marsh, with the ball hitting Marsh and bouncing off his chest into a Penn State defender’s hands.

The second was a one-handed pick by the Nittany Lions. With Michigan stuck in the mud, Kyle Whittingham made the move to Carr, and the freshman immediately changed the energy.

Michigan’s first drive with Carr ended in a first down and a punt, but the next two drives produced rushing touchdowns. The offense still wasn’t perfect, and it didn’t really settle in until late in the fourth quarter, but Carr looked comfortable enough that it would be a surprise if he wasn’t the starter next week against Indiana.

The run game finally showed life too. Jason Beck had insisted during the week that the Rhino look wasn’t going anywhere and called it the team’s most productive personnel grouping, even though the results had been uneven.

With Underwood at quarterback, Michigan had only 37 rushing yards, and nothing the Wolverines tried on the ground was working. Once Carr took over, Beck leaned into counters and dives between the tackles, and the production followed.

Bryson Kuzdzal broke loose for a 43-yard run, Savion Hiter added a 41-yard scamper, and Jordan Marshall chipped in an 11-yard carry. Michigan finished with 211 rushing yards, its best total of the season.

The defense did not have a clean night, but it kept finding ways to make game-changing plays. Michigan entered Week 7 with the nation’s No. 3 defense, and Penn State pushed it around more than usual.

Becht threw for 267 yards, and Chase Sowell was a major problem, catching 11 passes for 151 yards and a touchdown. Jyaire Hill was on Sowell for most of the night and had a difficult time, and Smith Snowden also struggled when asked to cover him.

Still, the Wolverines’ defense kept the game within reach. Rod Moore grabbed the first interception, though he was injured on the diving play.

Bracy added another pick later, then delivered the strip that created Michigan’s crucial late stop in the red zone. Even on a night when the defense bent plenty, it stayed opportunistic.

Underwood’s night only added to the questions surrounding his place in the offense. He arrived with massive expectations after Michigan flipped him from LSU during Sherrone Moore’s first season, and he was thrown right into the starting job as a true freshman.

The promise has been there at times, including what may have been his best game as a Michigan player in the loss to Iowa, but turnovers and questionable decisions have followed him, too. He now has six interceptions and five passing touchdowns on the season.

Maybe he needed a reset from the sideline. Maybe the game simply fits Carr better right now. Either way, if Carr keeps playing like this, Michigan won’t have much reason to change course.

In Other News...

Penn State Fans Got A Court Decision They Will Have Strong Feelings About

A Centre County judge has declined to ease a parole restriction that keeps Braeden A. Phillips away from Penn State football games and wrestling matches, a decision that will resonate with plenty of fans who have followed the case. Judge Brian Marshall denied Phillips request to loosen the condition, which bars him from attending those events as part of the terms tied to his release.

Phillips pleaded guilty to making violent threats against State College Area High School and must stay at least 100 feet away from Penn State and other schools under his parole conditions. Marshall did leave the door open to a future request for a modification, but for now the restriction remains in place. [Read more 🡒]

Penn State Fans Just Got A New Twist In The Kayne Clary Saga

Kayne Clarys legal fight with Penn State has come to an abrupt halt, at least for now. The former Nittany Lions basketball captain has discontinued his federal defamation and unjust enrichment lawsuit against the university, coach Mike Rhoades and others, ending a case that had accused the program of intimidation, retaliation, slander and illegal use of his Name, Image and Likeness.

The move comes during the discovery stage, before the case had reached a courtroom test of those claims. Clary was suspended and dismissed from the team before moving on to Mississippi State and then Oklahoma State, and the latest development leaves Penn State with one less off-court issue to navigate even as the circumstances around his departure still linger in the background. [Read more 🡒]

Penn State Gets Encouraging Sign Before Tough Michigan Trip

Penn State heads into Ann Arbor with a familiar challenge in front of it, and the latest injury report at least gives both sides a clearer picture of who will be available for a game with real weight. The Nittany Lions are still dealing with several players sidelined, including some season-ending injuries, as they prepare for a matchup at the Big House, where their recent track record has not been kind.

Michigans report adds another layer of uncertainty, with two defensive ends listed as questionable ahead of kickoff. For Penn State, any edge matters on a trip that has not gone well lately, and the availability of a few key players could help shape whether this becomes another tough afternoon in Ann Arbor or a chance to finally change the feel of the series. [Read more 🡒]