Matt Campbell’s loyalty to Rocco Becht is about to be put under a brighter spotlight than ever.
After Penn State’s 34-13 loss to Northwestern at Ryan Field on Friday night, the conversation around the fourth-year starting quarterback shifted fast. Becht finished 26 of 41 for 243 yards with a touchdown and two interceptions, and it was another rough outing in a stretch that has turned ugly in a hurry. It marked his second straight week with more interceptions than touchdowns, his second straight week averaging fewer than six yards per dropback, and another game in which tipped passes at the line of scrimmage and missed throws downfield were part of the problem.
There were moments when Becht didn’t have much to work with. He didn’t see many open receivers. But when the chances were there, he didn’t cash them in often enough.
That led to the obvious postgame question: why is Becht still the guy, and was there any thought of turning to backup Alex Manske, another Iowa State transfer? Campbell’s answer was exactly what you’d expect from a coach standing by a quarterback he trusts.
“To be honest with you, Rocco’s worked through hard before, and he’s proven he’s got the great ability to do it. And, you know, the fact of the matter is Rocco’s a winner.
He’s won a lot of football games. He’s had to work through really hard situations, and we’re kind of in one of those right now.
Matt Campbell on why he thinks Rocco Becht is the right quarterback for the team
He never considered putting Alex Manske in pic.twitter.com/lABk3OBxut
- Andrew Mercer (@amerc0115) October 3, 2026
Campbell made clear that Manske never truly entered the equation.
That stance is going to be hard for some fans to swallow, especially with Penn State already two games into Big Ten play and the offense still searching for answers. Becht has been willing to own his struggles.
After the loss, he listed off several areas where he knows he can be better. Campbell, by contrast, kept the support public and firm.
Penn State quarterback Rocco Becht provides a laundry list of areas where he thinks he can improve after losing 2x to in 6 days to Big Ten opponents. WATCH: pic.twitter.com/2gnMaHmTXv
- Mike Poorman (@PSUPoorman) October 3, 2026
That disconnect is where the pressure starts to build. Becht is not playing well, but Campbell’s refusal to say that plainly will only sharpen the criticism from a fan base that already appears to be cooling on him just five games into the job. Questions about whether Campbell is simply waiting for the tape, or whether his loyalty to his former Cyclones is clouding the picture, are only going to get louder.
Still, pulling Becht now would be a drastic move. With Penn State down two games and missing its No. 1 wide receiver - the only dynamic Big Ten-caliber playmaker on the offense - there’s an argument that Becht has earned a longer runway than most. Even with the recent struggles, he may still be the best shot to beat USC in the White Out next week and Michigan in Ann Arbor the week after.
If he wins one of those games, the job probably stays his for the rest of the season. If he wins both, the debate ends. But that feels like a tough path to imagine, and those matchups would also be a brutal first assignment for a redshirt freshman like Manske.
That’s why the calendar matters here. Penn State hosts Purdue after a Week 9 bye, and that game looks like the first realistic opening for Manske to make his first start.
At that point, the test changes. It won’t be about whether Campbell can stay loyal to Becht.
It will be about whether he’s willing to make the same kind of call with Manske.
And the bigger issue goes beyond one quarterback battle. The College Football Playoff is gone now.
It was a long shot before, and it’s off the table after this start. Penn State is heading toward what could be one of its worst seasons in years, likely worse than anything James Franklin ever produced, and Campbell and general manager Derek Hoodjer need an answer by the end of 2026.
They have to know whether Manske can be the Big Ten starter in 2027, or whether they need to go shopping in the transfer portal. They’ve been high on him for a while, even calling him a top four quarterback in the 2025 class that included Bryce Underwood and Keelon Russell.
Maybe that evaluation proves right. Maybe it doesn’t.
But if Campbell lets loyalty from his Iowa State days override the need to find out, Penn State could lose another year while still not knowing what it has at the most important position on the field.
In Other News...
Penn State Fans Have Another Saquon Barkley Reason To Be Miserable
Saquon Barkleys latest exit from a game with the Rams was the kind of sight that makes Penn State fans wince, because it came with an apparent hamstring injury and no return to action after the first quarter. For a player whose career has already included a major ACL tear in 2020, any lower-body issue carries extra weight, especially when it involves a part of the body that can linger for weeks before a running back is truly back to full speed.
For Penn State, the timing only adds to the unease. The Nittany Lions are already staring at a difficult stretch ahead with USC and Michigan on the schedule, and recent losses have left the seasons outlook cloudy. Losing even the conversation around one of the programs most recognizable stars to another injury scare is the sort of development that keeps the mood around State College uneasy, even before the next kickoff arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Already Has A Problem Fans Didn't Expect
Penn States early-season picture has changed fast, and not in the way fans expected when a new era began under Matt Campbell. By Week 5, the Nittany Lions were already dealing with back-to-back losses, a jarring turn for a program that entered the fall with far more optimism than this.
The setback lands in a week packed with head-turning college football moments elsewhere, from South Carolinas collapse against Kentucky to Michigans offensive trouble after losing to Iowa. Even the broader sport has been in motion, with Foxs Big Noon Kickoff and Barstool Sports parting ways, but for Penn State the focus is closer to home now, where the pressure is already building and the questions around this team are starting to pile up. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Suddenly Has A Credibility Problem Fans Can't Ignore
Penn States rough stretch has turned what looked like a promising season into a much tougher sell. The 34-13 loss to Northwestern sent the Nittany Lions out of the Coaches Poll entirely, a sharp fall for a program that opened the year ranked and expected to stay in the national picture under new coach Matt Campbell.
The schedule does not offer much time to linger on the setback. USC and Michigan are next, and those matchups will give Penn State a chance to reestablish itself against high-profile opponents and climb back toward the top 25, but only if the Nittany Lions start looking like a different team than the one that just slipped against Northwestern. [Read more 🡒]