Kalani Sitake stayed home for a massive payday when Penn State came calling, but a few months later he’s making the case for exactly the kind of resources Pat Kraft was prepared to put in front of him.
Sitake, the BYU head coach who had been a Penn State target before pulling out of the mix, used that opening to land a major raise. His salary jumped from $4 million a year to $10 million, putting him behind only Colorado’s Deion Sanders among Big 12 coaches. BYU also bumped up the salary pool for his assistants and increased roster spending.
Even with those upgrades, Sitake now says the Cougars are still trying to keep up.
"We’ve been given the challenge of doing the most with the least,” Sitake told Benjamin Criddle, who covers BYU sports for ESPN radio. “This is very simple demands of people that our opponents have in the conference - and not even Texas Tech.
The others, right? So if we can get an even playing field with that stuff, then I should be able to do more."
That complaint lands in a college football landscape where the spending gap keeps stretching. BYU reached the top of the Big 12 under Sitake, winning 11 games in 2024 and 12 games in 2025.
But the 2025 roster reportedly cost $10 million, while the sport’s biggest spenders were operating at a completely different level. Texas Tech, the eventual Big 12 champion, was pushing spending above $40 million, and this season there will be $50 million rosters in college football.
BYU has money. The program’s basketball side landed AJ Dybantsa, who was eventually the No. 1 pick in this summer’s NBA Draft. But the Cougars are still operating in a world where Big Ten and SEC money is hard to match unless a program has something unusual working in its favor, like Texas Tech’s angel investor Cody Campbell.
That reality is why the Penn State opening mattered so much. Kraft had reportedly zeroed in on Sitake before the BYU coach backed out and forced a pivot to Matt Campbell, who ultimately left Iowa State. Penn State didn’t land Sitake, but it did end up with a coach who came at a lower price tag.
And that, in the modern game, matters. If one coach costs $10 million and another comes in for more than a million less, that extra money can go right back into the staff or the roster. Once players can be paid, affordability becomes part of the evaluation.
Sitake’s case also got a full BYU welcome-home treatment when the school tried to keep him in Provo, including conversations with Patti Edwards, widow of legendary BYU coach LaVell Edwards. The effort was described as a “love bomb” from the program and fanbase.
For now, though, the warm feelings have given way to a harder reality. Sitake has turned BYU into a Big 12 force, but he’s also asking for the kind of financial muscle that sits well beyond what most programs outside the Big Ten and SEC can match. Miami and Notre Dame are the only other schools spending on that level, with Miami able to do it because the ACC pays out its entire College Football Playoff bonus to the team that earned it and Notre Dame simply being Notre Dame.
BYU would like to model itself after Notre Dame, and there are similarities. But, as this moment makes plain, there are levels to it.
Penn State may be fine without Sitake. Sitake, though, may not be better off without Penn State.
He may have been the perfect coach for BYU, the kind of proven winner who fits best at his alma mater. But if his aim is a national championship, the move he passed on might have been the one that gave him the clearest path.
In Other News...
Drew Allars Costly Mistakes Still Haunt Penn States Collapse
Penn States 2025 season never really recovered from the kind of moments that can tilt an entire program, and the quarterback play at the center of it keeps looking worse in hindsight. Drew Allars interceptions in big games became part of the story as the Nittany Lions slid from playoff hopes into a stretch of losses that ultimately ended with James Franklins firing after the Week 7 defeat to Northwestern, a result that sent shockwaves through a team built to contend.
The collapse was not about one bad afternoon, but the memory that lingers is how often Penn State found itself undone in the biggest spots. After a 54-day search, the program turned to Matt Campbell as its new head coach, hoping to reset the direction of a team still trying to move past the decisions and missed chances that helped define the end of Franklins run. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Camp Buzz Is Building Around Two Key Position Battles
Penn States 2026 camp is barely underway, but the first 11-on-11 work has already given the staff a clearer look at a few players trying to carve out roles before the opener against Marshall. Among the early standouts are Iowa State transfer receiver Eskildsen, defensive lineman Ikenna Ezeogu, quarterback Alex Manske and versatile option Rappleyea, each of whom has flashed enough in camp to draw attention from coaches as the roster starts to take shape.
The most interesting early camp developments have come in the places where Penn State still needs answers, especially on offense, where receiver depth and quarterback depth are always under the microscope. Eskildsens transition has been one of the louder storylines, while Manskes return after missing spring practice has added another layer to the quarterback picture, and both players are part of a group that appears to be pushing for bigger responsibilities as camp continues. [Read more 🡒]