Former Penn State guard Josh Reed has taken a major step toward getting another season on the floor after an Ohio judge granted a preliminary injunction in a lawsuit challenging the NCAA’s new eligibility model.
The ruling could open the door for Reed, who was a senior on last season’s Penn State team and had already used up his eligibility under the NCAA’s previous system, to play a fifth season. Reed was one of about two dozen athletes from Ohio involved in the case, which argues the NCAA’s change “violates the covenant of good faith and fair dealing under Ohio law.”
Judge Christopher Wagner sided with the athletes, finding that the NCAA acted in an "arbitrary and capricious" manner by leaving out 2022 high school graduates from the updated 5-in-5 model, according to the Associated Press. The injunction also lets the athletes enter the transfer portal.
A pre-trial conference is set for Aug. 4.
“We hope the NCAA reconsiders its position and allows all other similarly situated athletes from the high school class of 2022 to compete for remaining roster spots in all sports,” plaintiffs' attorney Ryan Downton said in a statement to the Associated Press.
The NCAA pushed back hard, calling Wagner’s ruling "wrong" and saying it "disregarded over a century of precedent and substituted its own judgment, on a limited factual record, for the collective expertise of the nation's leading higher education institutions."
"As disappointing as the ruling itself is the decision by some member schools to support a lawsuit designed to circumvent the rules by which those same schools agreed to be bound," the NCAA said in the statement. "It is fundamentally unfair to the many programs and student-athletes who follow the rules to compete against those who do not.
Integrity in college sports relies on all members abiding by the same standards. While we will seek to overturn this ruling, it is now apparent that Congress must act swiftly to restore stability, uniformity, and fair competition in college athletics."
In a follow-up statement to Yahoo Sports, the NCAA also said Wagner’s ties to Xavier and the University of Cincinnati, where some of the plaintiffs played, were not disclosed.
For Reed, the ruling carries real on-court implications. He started 31 games for Penn State last season, his fourth and what was supposed to be his final year of eligibility. If the decision holds, he can enter the NCAA Transfer Portal and could even return to Penn State next season, a move that would matter a lot for a roster in transition.
Reed, who is from Cincinnati, began his college career at the University of Cincinnati. Last season at Penn State, he posted a career-best 11.5 points and 4.1 rebounds per game. If he does get another year, he would almost certainly be back in the starting five.
Penn State has already been busy reshaping its roster after a 12-20 season. The Nittany Lions signed eight new players this offseason after losing nine to eligibility and the transfer portal, and Reed was one of four starters who moved on.
There’s also another eligibility wrinkle brewing in Happy Valley. Penn State is dealing with an issue involving international players, and two players who competed professionally in Europe have committed but have not yet signed with the Nittany Lions.
In Other News...
James Franklin Just Reopened A Penn State Debate Fans Never Forgot
James Franklins departure from Penn State is still the kind of topic that can pull old frustrations back to the surface, especially now that he is at Virginia Tech and looking back on the end of his run in Happy Valley. The timing is notable too, with Penn State continuing its Beaver Stadium renovation work in Phase II of a $700 million project and another major donation helping keep the overhaul moving forward.
At the same time, the football conversation around the program has not exactly settled down. ESPNs preseason College Football Power Index pegs Penn State 17th, projects nine wins and gives the Nittany Lions a 22 percent shot at the College Football Playoff, a reminder that expectations remain high even as the roster turns over and the program prepares to introduce 55 new players in 2026. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Fans Already Face One Big Matt Campbell Debate
Matt Campbell is about to begin his first season in charge at Penn State, and the early conversation around 2026 is already less about a quick fix than about what a realistic first step looks like. The schedule sets up better than the one the Nittany Lions faced in 2025, and Campbells long runway with the program gives the staff room to build without treating every Saturday like a referendum.
Still, the first-year bar will not be low. Penn State avoids Ohio State, Indiana and Oregon on the 2026 slate, which opens the door to a solid jump if the transition goes smoothly, and a 9-3 finish feels like a fair target rather than a dream scenario. A College Football Playoff berth would be the ceiling in year one, but the bigger question is how quickly Campbell can turn that cleaner schedule and fresh start into the kind of baseline that makes the next step feel inevitable. [Read more 🡒]