Penn State Rekindles An Uncomfortable Debate About How It Honors Its Own

As Penn State navigates the legacy of past and present controversies, the delicate balance between honoring achievements and avoiding turmoil comes to the forefront with the recent sidelining of former head coach James Franklin during celebrations.

Penn State spent part of last week celebrating its 2016 Big Ten championship team, and the school managed to leave out the coach who led it there.

The highlights were all there - Saquon Barkley, the blocked punt against Ohio State, the Big Ten title game against Wisconsin - but there wasn’t a recognizable second of James Franklin in the stadium video. The treatment felt familiar to anyone who remembers how Joe Paterno was handled in 2012 and 2013, when Penn State also chose to keep a former coach out of sight rather than risk putting him on a big screen.

That instinct has been around for a while. A decade or so ago, Penn State pulled even the slighted video glimpse of Paterno from Beaver Stadium on gamedays, and Franklin has gotten a similar version of that this season.

The logic is easy to understand, but the result still feels off. History is history, and there should have been more than a closeup of Franklin’s hands on the conference championship trophy.

Time may change that, just as it has with Paterno, who has been more prominently acknowledged in recent seasons. Franklin deserves that kind of fair treatment at some point too.

Penn State also could have handled last week’s Minnesota situation with a little more communication. The game-day crowd was asked to show up for a party of about 100,000 people, and with Minnesota’s arrival in doubt because of the nationwide FAA ground stop, fans needed clearer updates.

There was one early message Friday evening saying the situation was being monitored, but that wasn’t enough. Minnesota’s travel issues were Minnesota’s story to tell, but Penn State was hosting the game, and a stronger message that things would proceed as normal unless told otherwise would have helped.

On the field, Penn State’s sack total is still climbing for a cause. Through the annual “Sack Hunger” promotion, PA Pork donates 50 pounds of pork to food banks and people facing food insecurity for every sack Penn State records during the football season. Last year’s team finished with 32 sacks, and this year’s group has 14 with two games left - three of those coming against Minnesota.

A few other notes from the week:

Penn State’s home finale against Rutgers is set for 3:30 p.m. Saturday on Fox Sports 1.

It’s the third straight game on FS1 and the fourth of the season, not counting Maryland. The network may not bring all the extras some fans prefer, but last week’s crew of Dan Hellie and Robert Smith did a better job than they did for the Washington game.

The 3:30 p.m. kickoff is also Penn State’s fourth of the season, making it the most common start time for the third year in a row.

The “Military Appreciation” game against Minnesota drew praise for the in-stadium honors and presentation, with former Nittany Lion and current service member Kyle Lucas serving as honorary captain. Mentioning that he was from Bellefonte would have landed even better with the crowd.

The announced attendance of 105,291 was, as usual, more aspirational than actual, but the fans who stayed late earned a shoutout. So did Steve Jones, Brian Tripp and Cailey Thalman, who worked together in their first game as a broadcast team after Tripp moved to analyst because of Jack Ham’s absence. Jones and Tripp are established pros, and Thalman was set up well to succeed.

Thalman already had plenty of broadcasting experience from her Penn State student days, and her family ties run deep as the granddaughter of longtime Penn State Athletics publicist L. Budd Thalman, who handled sports PR for the program in the 1980s and early 1990s.

Penn State also deserves credit for trying to boost the Minnesota crowd with specially priced tickets and some food discounts. That kind of flexibility matters, and as game consumption habits keep changing, marketing like that is likely to matter even more in Happy Valley and beyond.

In Other News...

Penn State Has A Real Shot At An In-State RB Target

Penn States push for in-state running back Julez Chiron-Robinson is still very much alive as the Downingtown East standout works through a crowded recruiting picture. The three-star prospect has drawn attention from a long list of programs, including Cincinnati, Florida State, Kentucky, Maryland, Stanford and Virginia Tech, but Penn State remains near the top as he keeps taking visits and sorting through his options.

Chiron-Robinson has backed up the interest with a big season, piling up 2,119 rushing yards and 31 touchdowns while showing the kind of production that naturally keeps more schools in the mix. He also places a premium on academics and character, two areas that fit neatly with Penn States recruiting approach, which is why this one feels worth watching as the process moves forward. [Read more 🡒]

Penn State Still Has One Problem Campbell Isnt Letting Slide

Penn States 42-14 win over Minnesota offered another reminder that the Nittany Lions are starting to look more complete as the season winds down. The run game produced 229 yards, the defense held Minnesota to 41 on the ground, and the team showed a better ability to keep its footing after halftime than it had in some earlier outings.

Still, there is a standard Matt Campbell is not willing to soften. Even with three straight wins and a 6-4 record heading into Rutgers, he has kept the focus on mental toughness and playing cleanly for all 60 minutes, a message that suggests the latest surge has not erased the bigger issue he sees with this group. [Read more 🡒]

Penn State Faces One Big Concern As Rutgers Comes To Town

Penn State heads into its final home game of the season with the matchup against Rutgers looking like another opportunity to keep a long-running series trend intact. The Nittany Lions have been sharper lately, especially on the ground and with better quarterback play, and that has helped steady a team that has found its rhythm at the right time.

Carson Hansens injury status is the one wrinkle hanging over the afternoon. Penn States recent improvement in the running game has been a key part of its surge, and any uncertainty there adds a little more intrigue to a game the Nittany Lions are otherwise expected to control against a Rutgers team that has struggled this season. [Read more 🡒]