Penn State’s Big Ten opener brings a simple question into Beaver Stadium on Saturday: can the Nittany Lions keep rolling without Koby Howard, and can that defense keep doing what it has done all season - keep people out of the end zone?
That’s the backdrop for a matchup against Wisconsin that also comes with a noisy home setting, a Peacock-only stream, and plenty of confidence around Penn State’s side of the ball. The Penn State on SI staff split its predictions, but the theme was clear: the Nittany Lions have the edge.
The biggest reason is Penn State’s defense. Chase Fisher pointed to a unit that ranks third nationally in scoring defense at 7.3 points per game and said Wisconsin’s road issues should continue after the Badgers went 0-5 away from home last season. He also noted Wisconsin managed only 13 points against Notre Dame, then picked Penn State 24, Wisconsin 16.
Will Horstman saw the opener as a chance for Penn State to move to 1-0 in Big Ten play after getting through its non-conference schedule cleanly. He highlighted Wisconsin’s 2-7 conference mark last season and its inability to win a road game since Oct. 19, 2024, then projected a 31-17 Penn State win in an evening game at Beaver Stadium.
Mark Wogenrich was a little closer on the scoreboard, but he still leaned Penn State. He said Howard’s injury shouldn’t trigger a full panic because the offense has other playmakers, though he added that Howard had been the team’s best overall offensive threat and that offensive coordinator Taylor Mouser had built the attack around him. Wogenrich picked Penn State 27, Wisconsin 19, with Rocco Becht and the defense doing the heavy lifting.
Becht kept coming up as a key figure in the discussion. Fisher said the quarterback - “the most experienced at his position in college football” - could be the difference simply by protecting the ball. Becht has not thrown an interception or lost a fumble in three games, and Fisher expects that streak to continue in what he thinks will be a low-scoring game.
The run game also drew attention, especially after Quinton Martin Jr. went for 100 yards on 10 carries in the win over Buffalo. Horstman suggested that performance should earn Martin more work, while Fisher and Wogenrich both weighed Penn State’s backs against Wisconsin’s ground defense.
Fisher leaned toward Abu Sama III, saying the workloads should tilt in his favor, while Horstman said Sama should see more volume than Carson Hansen. Wogenrich made the same pick and added that Sama, Wisconsin’s No. 1 back, says he is healthy after missing last week against Eastern Illinois.
There was similar focus on individual defenders. Wogenrich singled out linebacker Kooper Ebel as Penn State’s best Iowa State transfer so far, praising his discipline and tackling.
He said Wisconsin quarterback Colton Joseph and running back Abu Sama III will try to pull him out of position, but Ebel won’t bite and will be the defensive star. Wogenrich also pointed to defensive end Caleb Bacon as an unsung hero, noting his team-high four tackles for loss and a forced fumble through three games.
On offense, the uncertainty around Howard shaped a lot of the conversation. Fisher said the passing game might still be fine, even if it won’t be pretty, because Becht can spread the ball to Chase Sowell, Brett Eskildsen and Zay Robinson, with tight end Ben Brahmer able to carry a heavy load after his five-catch, 79-yard, two-touchdown game against Temple in Week 2. Fisher also suggested kicker Ryan Barker could be busy, predicting several stalled drives and field goals of at least 40 yards.
Horstman liked Eskildsen as a potential breakout option after the receiver said he is “fully back” following a limited role against Buffalo. With Howard out for an “extended period of time,” Horstman said Penn State may lean more heavily on Eskildsen through the air.
Penn State climbed five spots to No. 13 in the AP Top 25 after beating three under-powered non-conference opponents, and Horstman noted that a win Saturday would make the Nittany Lions 4-0. But he also said the first real test of the season comes next week at Northwestern, even if Wisconsin is one of the more favorable Big Ten openers Penn State could have asked for.
Wogenrich closed by looking ahead to the bigger question hanging over the offense: how long Koby Howard will be out, whether he’ll be back for the USC game, and whether Penn State can get a road win at Northwestern without him.
In Other News...
Former Penn State Transfer Miss Is Getting A Real Jets Chance
Malik McClains football path has taken another turn, and this one gives the former Penn State wide receiver a real chance to stick in the NFL. After a college career that never fully took off and a disappointing season in Happy Valley in 2023, McClain signed with the New York Jets and worked his way from the practice squad to the 53-man active roster.
For a player whose college production never matched the early promise, this is the kind of opening that can keep a career moving. McClains path now appears to run primarily through special teams, where roster spots are earned by doing the little things well and making himself useful on game day, a role that could finally give him a foothold at the next level. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Fans Have A New Reason To Dread Wisconsin Week
Penn States Big Ten opener against Wisconsin already had the feel of an early barometer game, and now there is a viewing wrinkle on top of it. The matchup is slated to stream on Peacock, which means fans who want to watch it will need a subscription rather than a standard TV broadcast, adding another layer of inconvenience to a week that already carries plenty of attention in State College.
The timing is notable because Penn State has not exactly been surrounded by marquee television treatment this season, and the first few home crowds have shown some softness for nonconference games, including the Buffalo matchup that drew the smallest attendance at Beaver Stadium since 2019. An NBC broadcast is coming in week six, but before that arrives, Wisconsin week has turned into the kind of date Penn State supporters may already be bracing for. [Read more 🡒]
Penn States First Big Ten Lineup Under Matt Campbell Comes Into Focus
Matt Campbell is sticking with a familiar routine in Happy Valley, declining to release an official weekly depth chart as Penn State moves through the 2026 season. The approach mirrors what the previous coaching staff did, leaving Lions247 to piece together a projected lineup from practice observations and information coming out of the program.
That unofficial chart is expected to stay fluid from week to week, with updates coming as roles and availability change. Under Big Ten rules, player availability designations will still be attached each week, giving fans at least a clearer picture of who is in and who is out even if the full pecking order remains an internal matter. [Read more 🡒]