ANN ARBOR, Michigan | Penn State left Michigan Stadium with the same problem it has carried for weeks: flashes of competence, then a sequence of mistakes that undo the whole night.
The Nittany Lions fell 21-18 to Michigan on Saturday, a loss defined by three quarterback turnovers, a second-half quarterback switch and a late onside kick that at least kept the game alive for a moment. Penn State is now 3-4 overall and 0-4 in the Big Ten, and coach Matt Campbell once again found himself describing a team that is close, but not close enough.
“I have complete faith in who Rocco Becht is and what he’s about,” Penn State coach Matt Campbell said after the Nittany Lions’ 21-18 loss to Michigan. pic.twitter.com/WjgfOhxeL8
Becht’s day captured the contradictions inside Penn State’s offense. He started hot, completing his first seven passes and going 15-for-19 in the first half, with three completions each to Sowell and Andrew Rappleyea. But all of that early efficiency produced only three points, and once the game tightened, Becht started pressing.
His final stat line came with three turnovers, each one feeding Michigan touchdowns. The first came on a throw to a well-covered Brett Eskildsen, with a safety waiting behind him.
The second was a failed attempt to force a ball to Gabe Burkle, when a lofted pass or even a scramble would have been the better option. Becht acknowledged that he should have run.
The third was a sack-fumble on a safety blitz he never picked up.
Sowell summed up the damage plainly: "The defense did their job today, and we didn’t help them out," Sowell said. "Creating two turnovers is hard in this league, and we just gave it right back to them.
That’s on me. I’ve got to be better in that position and we’ve got to be better for that defense, because they’re playing their butts off."
Even in defeat, Sowell turned in the best game of his Penn State career. He finished with 11 catches for 151 yards, continuing the rise that had been expected when he transferred from Iowa State.
His path has not been easy. He has dealt with multiple injuries, was essentially cut by Deion Sanders at Colorado and rebuilt his career at East Carolina.
The last two weeks have even brought a strange pattern, with Sowell limping off in the second quarter and returning in the third. Now he is starting to look like the NFL draft pick Penn State hoped for.
The run game, on the other hand, went nowhere. Penn State managed just 65 yards on 30 carries, and the backs averaged 3 yards per attempt.
The left side of the offensive line remained a problem. Campbell and the staff had leaned into the idea of putting the ball in Becht’s hands before the game, and that approach was part of the reason the offense never really found balance.
Still, Penn State was a kick away from making things interesting late. An onside kick in the fourth quarter gave the Nittany Lions a chance to force the issue and maybe drag the game into the kind of finish they desperately needed.
The first half was about as sharp as Penn State has looked defensively all season. Michigan was held to 80 yards, Bryce Underwood was intercepted twice and the Wolverines were forced to punt three times.
Penn State also thought it had produced a safety, but the play was whistled dead at the 1-yard line. Campbell said an official later admitted the stop came too early.
That pressure helped push Michigan into a quarterback change, with Kyle Whittingham turning from Bryce Underwood to Tommy Carr to start the second half.
But Penn State’s defense could not survive every mistake from the offense. Michigan produced the two longest runs of its season in the second half: a 43-yard touchdown by Bryson Kuzdzal and a 41-yard burst from Savion Hiter that moved the Wolverines from their own end zone shadow to midfield.
Michigan didn’t score on the second drive, but it did flip the field, and Becht’s fumble on the next possession turned the momentum into points. Carr later finished the game with a 12-yard touchdown run.
There were bright spots all over the Penn State defense. Freshman cornerback Josiah Zayas made a remarkable interception.
Zion Tracy added a smart one. Tony Rojas was everywhere again, piling up 12 tackles with two for losses.
Punter Nathan Tiyce averaged 38 yards per kick, but he did pin Michigan inside its own 10-yard line twice. The coverage team also took a hit when Daryus Dixson was flagged for a block in the back on a punt, forcing Penn State to start one possession inside its own 10. Ryan Barker opened the game with another short field goal.
Campbell still insists the team is moving forward, even if the results keep landing the same way. He said this was not the same kind of failure as Wisconsin, Northwestern or USC. But the issue remains unchanged: Michigan did not look like the better team, yet it made the bigger plays when the game got messy.
That is where Penn State sits heading into the bye week - close enough to see improvement, still far enough away that the record does not budge. Campbell returned to the same theme afterward, pointing again to the major overhaul the program went through this offseason, even as the patience around that explanation starts to wear thin.
"I thought we were a lot closer tonight, and I think that’s really frustrating from our end that we weren’t able to put together the second half that we wanted to put together," he said. "From our end, we are doing everything in our power to get there as fast as we possibly can."
In Other News...
Penn State Fans Got A Court Decision They Will Have Strong Feelings About
A Centre County judge has declined to ease a parole restriction that keeps Braeden A. Phillips away from Penn State football games and wrestling matches, a decision that will resonate with plenty of fans who have followed the case. Judge Brian Marshall denied Phillips request to loosen the condition, which bars him from attending those events as part of the terms tied to his release.
Phillips pleaded guilty to making violent threats against State College Area High School and must stay at least 100 feet away from Penn State and other schools under his parole conditions. Marshall did leave the door open to a future request for a modification, but for now the restriction remains in place. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Fans Just Got A New Twist In The Kayne Clary Saga
Kayne Clarys legal fight with Penn State has come to an abrupt halt, at least for now. The former Nittany Lions basketball captain has discontinued his federal defamation and unjust enrichment lawsuit against the university, coach Mike Rhoades and others, ending a case that had accused the program of intimidation, retaliation, slander and illegal use of his Name, Image and Likeness.
The move comes during the discovery stage, before the case had reached a courtroom test of those claims. Clary was suspended and dismissed from the team before moving on to Mississippi State and then Oklahoma State, and the latest development leaves Penn State with one less off-court issue to navigate even as the circumstances around his departure still linger in the background. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Gets Encouraging Sign Before Tough Michigan Trip
Penn State heads into Ann Arbor with a familiar challenge in front of it, and the latest injury report at least gives both sides a clearer picture of who will be available for a game with real weight. The Nittany Lions are still dealing with several players sidelined, including some season-ending injuries, as they prepare for a matchup at the Big House, where their recent track record has not been kind.
Michigans report adds another layer of uncertainty, with two defensive ends listed as questionable ahead of kickoff. For Penn State, any edge matters on a trip that has not gone well lately, and the availability of a few key players could help shape whether this becomes another tough afternoon in Ann Arbor or a chance to finally change the feel of the series. [Read more 🡒]