A federal appeals court’s decision to pause the NCAA’s latest eligibility ruling has thrown two Penn State athletes back into uncertainty.
For Josh Reed, it could affect whether he gets another season with the Nittany Lions. For Levi Haines, it could determine whether a fifth year in wrestling is even on the table.
The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals granted the NCAA’s request for a stay on Friday while the organization continues its appeal of a July ruling out of Colorado. That earlier decision had extended a fifth year of eligibility to athletes in the 2022 recruiting class who played four years of college sports without redshirting. With the stay now in place, those athletes are once again waiting to find out what comes next.
The case grows out of the NCAA’s “five-for-five” legislation, which gives current and future athletes five years to compete in five seasons and eliminates the redshirt option. But the NCAA did not apply that fifth year to athletes who started college in 2022 and completed their fourth seasons last year. Reed and Haines fall into that group, and Friday’s ruling pushes their situations back into limbo.
Among the athletes directly affected is Reed, who had already won legal ground in Ohio and again in July when the Colorado judge ruled the NCAA had to include Class of 2022 athletes in the five-for-five framework. Penn State moved quickly after that ruling, announcing in early August that Reed would be back for a fifth season.
That return would have mattered a lot. Reed became one of Penn State’s most important players down the stretch last season, averaging 13.8 points and hitting 47.1 percent from 3-point range over the final 18 games. With Penn State bringing in eight new players and still waiting on two international transfers, Reed’s presence would have offered coach Mike Rhoades and his staff some badly needed stability and familiarity.
“I will say how everybody knows how much I love Josh Reed,” Rhoades said this summer. “He had a great year for us.
His best year in college basketball is at Penn State. He also got his MBA.
He's an impressive young man. He's a great example of what we want our guys to be.”
Now, Reed’s status is unsettled again, and the court fight is likely far from over.
The same ruling also reopened the door for Haines, and in his case the possibilities are even more striking. A two-time NCAA champion, Haines went 99-4 across four seasons at Penn State, won four Big Ten titles and finished third or better at the NCAA Championships every year. He claimed national titles at 157 pounds in 2024 and 174 pounds last season.
A fifth year would give Haines a chance at a third NCAA title while still staying on pace for the 2028 Olympics. It could also create an opportunity for a major NIL deal if he chose to return.
Haines has not spoken publicly about the option, but Penn State coach Cael Sanderson made it clear he’d welcome him back.
“Obviously we'd love to have Levi back another year, so I'm going to learn into that,” Sanderson told FloWrestling. “Like yeah, let's go.
It's just tough to penalize somebody. You're making a rule change mdistream in kids' careers, so i think that's tough to do.”
If Haines is cleared to return, Penn State could again roll out a lineup that looks downright stacked. The Nittany Lions, five-time defending NCAA champions, would bring back four NCAA gold medalists and seven wrestlers who went undefeated during the 2025-26 regular season.
Haines is also set to represent the U.S. at the 2026 Senior World Wrestling Championships in late October in Kazakhstan. He is among the favorites at 79 kg in men’s freestyle, the same weight class where he finished second last year.
In Other News...
Former Penn State Standout Sees Strong Eagles Camp Cut Short
Tariq Castro-Fields had been trying to carve out a place for himself in Philadelphia training camp, but the former Penn State cornerbacks push for a roster spot has been halted by a heel injury. The Eagles placed him on injured reserve, ending his participation in camp and putting his likely 2026 season in doubt after he had been working back while competing for a spot.
Philadelphia also moved on from wide receiver Johnny Wilson with a waived/injured designation and added center Zeke Correll and wide receiver Brandon Hayes. For Penn State fans, Castro-Fields latest setback is a frustrating one, since his NFL path had been gaining traction before the injury stopped it in its tracks. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Fans Just Got A Stark Beaver Stadium Price Reality
Penn State fans are getting a first real look at what life inside the renovated Beaver Stadium will cost when the 2027 season arrives. The university has announced its ticket prices for that year, and the new numbers mark a clear jump from the 2026 season, adding another layer to the anticipation around the stadium project.
The latest pricing also invites an apples-to-apples look across the Big Ten, with Penn States 2027 figures stacked against other schools 2026 season ticket costs, leaving out certain premium contributions. For now, the comparison offers an early sense of where the Nittany Lions may land in the conferences pricing landscape, even as some programs still have not released their 2027 ticket details. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Wrestling Just Took A Major Levi Haines Eligibility Blow
Penn State wrestling is dealing with another jolt in the aftermath of the NCAAs ongoing eligibility battles, as the Tenth Circuit granted the associations stay request in Winse v. NCAA. The ruling leaves Levi Haines, who graduated high school in 2022 and has already used all four years of eligibility, currently ineligible to compete while the case continues to play out.
Haines still has a possible path to keep fighting the decision through a temporary restraining order, but for now the uncertainty hangs over one of Penn States most decorated recent wrestlers. No matter how the legal process unfolds ahead of the 2026-27 season, Haines already has a rsum built around two national titles and four All-America honors in Happy Valley. [Read more 🡒]