Penn State Faces Another Evanston Test After That Wisconsin Collapse

Penn State aims to defy historical volatility in upcoming Big Ten road opener against Northwestern.

Penn State’s first Big Ten road game of the season has been a roller coaster ever since the Nittany Lions joined the conference in 1993, and Friday night at Northwestern brings another test with a familiar kind of tension.

The setup is already messy enough. Penn State is coming off a 24-20 loss to Wisconsin in its conference opener, a game in which the Nittany Lions built a 17-0 lead before the Badgers ripped off the final 17 points. Now they head to Evanston for the first game at the rebuilt Ryan Field, looking to keep one of their more reliable trends intact.

Since entering the Big Ten, Penn State is 20-13 in its first league road game of a season. That record has been built on everything from runaway wins to last-second escapes, with a few outright disasters mixed in for good measure.

The early years set the tone. Penn State’s first Big Ten road trip after joining the conference in 1993 ended with a 31-0 win at Iowa.

A year later, the 1994 team rolled into Minnesota and left with a 56-3 victory, part of an undefeated season. For a long time, that 53-point margin stood as the standard for Penn State’s most lopsided Big Ten road opener until James Franklin’s 2019 team went to Maryland and blew the doors off the Terrapins, 59-0.

That night in College Park was one of the most complete road performances in program history. Sean Clifford threw for 398 yards and three touchdowns in less than three quarters, KJ Hamler posted 108 receiving yards, and Penn State piled up 619 yards of offense. The Nittany Lions were already up 38-0 at halftime, and the 59-point margin remains the largest in a Big Ten road opener in school history.

Some of the most memorable wins, though, were anything but comfortable.

The 2005 trip to Northwestern became a turning point for Joe Paterno’s team. Penn State was down 29-27 and staring at fourth-and-15 from its own 15 with a little more than a minute left.

Michael Robinson hit Isaac Smolko for 20 yards to keep the drive alive, then found freshman Derrick Williams for a 36-yard touchdown with 51 seconds left to seal a 34-29 win. Robinson finished with 271 passing yards, three passing touchdowns, 60 rushing yards and another score.

Penn State rode that season all the way to a Big Ten title and an Orange Bowl win, finishing 11-1.

Twelve years later, Penn State pulled off another nerve-jangling escape in its first conference road game. In 2017, the No. 4 Nittany Lions went to Iowa and won 21-19 when Trace McSorley connected with Juwan Johnson for a seven-yard touchdown as time expired.

The 2021 opener at Wisconsin followed a different script, but the result was just as important. Penn State had just gone 4-5 the year before, then opened at No.

12 Wisconsin and came away with a 16-10 win. It was a defensive fight from start to finish, with multiple red-zone stands and Jaquan Brisker’s late interception helping close it out.

A year later, Penn State needed another late answer, beating Purdue 35-31 on a Thursday night when Sean Clifford found Keyvone Lee on a wheel route for the winning touchdown with under a minute remaining.

Penn State’s 2024 trip to USC wasn’t technically a Big Ten opener, but it was the team’s first conference road game of the season, and it belongs near the top of the list. The Nittany Lions trailed 20-6 at halftime before rallying for a 33-30 overtime win at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum.

Tyler Warren turned in one of the great individual performances in school history with 17 catches for 224 yards and a touchdown. Drew Allar threw for 391 yards, Penn State converted two fourth downs on the game-tying fourth-quarter drive, and Ryan Barker finished it off with a 36-yard field goal in overtime.

Not every trip has ended that way. Some of the losses have been brutal.

Ohio State beat Penn State 45-6 in Columbus in 2000, a 39-point loss that fit a 5-7 season. Michigan matched that margin in 2016, when injuries at linebacker left Penn State exposed in a 49-10 defeat in Ann Arbor.

Michigan led 28-0 at halftime and ran for 329 yards and six touchdowns. Even so, that Penn State team rebounded, beat Ohio State three weeks later and went on to win the Big Ten championship.

The 2020 opener at Indiana was painful in a different way. Penn State thought it had won in overtime before Indiana quarterback Michael Penix Jr. stretched for the pylon on a two-point conversion that held up after review, giving the Hoosiers a 36-35 win and sending Penn State into an 0-5 start.

Then came last season’s shocker at UCLA. Penn State entered ranked No. 7 while the Bruins were 0-4, but UCLA jumped out to a 27-7 halftime lead and hung on for a 42-37 upset despite Penn State’s second-half push.

That’s the backdrop for Friday night in Evanston. Penn State has not lost consecutive Big Ten road openers since 2015 and 2016, and it has won seven of its last nine first conference road games. Northwestern has played a part in some of the biggest moments in this stretch, and Penn State is 7-3 on the road against the Wildcats.

With that history behind them, getting to 21-13 in these games may be anything but routine.

In Other News...

Penn State Fans Just Got A New Beaver Stadium Comparison

Northwesterns new Ryan Field made its debut during Penn States visit, giving Nittany Lions fans a fresh point of comparison for what a modern college football venue can look like. The 35,000-seat on-campus stadium, built at a cost of $870 million, puts a premium on closeness to the action, with premium seating, a standing-only student section and a layout that brings the crowd right up to the playing surface.

Penn State broadcaster Steve Jones also took note of the new setup, including the location of the visiting radio booth, while the game added another layer to the conversation with the strong Peacock/NBC production. For Penn State observers, the contrast with Beaver Stadium was hard to miss, especially on a night when the sideline environment again underscored how crowded things can feel in Happy Valley. [Read more 🡒]

Penn States Northwestern Prep Just Took A Surprising Turn

Penn States trip to Northwestern now comes with a little more clarity on the injury front for both sides. The Wildcats will be without tight end Luke Dehnicke and defensive back Braden Turner, while defensive back Damon Walters and receiver Hayden Eligon are listed as game-time decisions. There is confidence that Eligon will suit up, which gives Northwestern at least a chance to keep one more piece available as it tries to sort through a thin week of preparation.

For the Nittany Lions, the injury picture is familiar in a less welcome way. Defensive end Max Granville is out for the season, and receiver Koby Howard is sidelined for an extended stretch, leaving Penn State to keep adjusting its depth as the schedule rolls on. Even with Northwestern dealing with its own absences, this is the sort of matchup where availability can shape both game planning and in-game flexibility before either side ever settles into a rhythm. [Read more 🡒]

Former Penn State QB Is Watching One Big Test For This New Era

Drew Allar is keeping a close eye on Penn States next chapter, and he sounds encouraged by the direction the program is headed under new head coach Matt Campbell. The former quarterback said he respects Campbell even though he never played for him, a small but telling sign that the transition has already earned some buy-in from one of the most recognizable players of the previous era.

Allar also pointed to Virginia Techs strong start under James Franklin as another reminder of how quickly new coaching situations can take shape. From his vantage point, both programs have a chance to keep growing beyond his time in college football, and the real test now is whether Penn State can turn that optimism into sustained success in Campbells new era. [Read more 🡒]