Jake Butt didn’t sugarcoat Michigan football’s offensive mess.
The former Wolverine and current Big Ten Network analyst, who played for Jim Harbaugh and remains firmly plugged into the program, gave The Athletic a blunt read on what he sees: the offense has no identity. And for a Michigan team that still has a defense playing at a championship level, that’s a pretty sharp indictment of the offensive staff.
“They don’t have an offensive identity,” Butt said to The Athletic. “They’re going in each week saying, ‘How can I protect my quarterback?’
Rather than saying, ‘What do we do best?’ Their best run plays are Bryce read-options.
In my opinion, Jordan Marshall is at his best as a downhill runner. I don’t understand his base run being him in Wildcat and doing fake jet sweeps with Bryce.”
Butt also pointed back to last season and gave credit to Chip Lindsey, saying the offense made more sense then even if it didn’t always get enough praise. His view is that Michigan leaned into what worked: a downhill run game, play-action off that foundation, and tight ends - a group he says has been missing this season.
“Last year, I give credit to (offensive coordinator) Chip Lindsey. We’d asked Sherrone, why aren’t you running Bryce more?
But we’re seeing that Bryce doesn’t consistently make good reads anywhere, not even on read-option. Last year, Michigan decided they were gonna run downhill with their running backs.
And get into play-action off of that, using the tight ends - who have been nonexistent this season.”
That’s where the frustration really sets in. Michigan had a clear formula last year, Butt said, rushing for 210 yards per game and 5.8 yards per attempt. Instead of building on that identity, the staff moved away from it, and Butt said that is difficult to understand.
He also took aim at the blocking concepts, saying the schemes “make no sense,” especially with so many players being left unblocked at the line of scrimmage.
As for solutions, Butt thinks Tommy Carr should get a look. Others are pointing the finger at Jason Beck, with a growing sense that the offense isn’t being coached well no matter how you feel about Bryce Underwood. Butt said Carr can read a defense, doesn’t have an elite arm, but throws it better and runs it better than he expected when he saw him in spring ball.
Still, Underwood needs a chance to steady things, and Beck does too. If Michigan has to bring Underwood along more slowly, Butt’s answer is simple: lean into the downhill run game and let the rest of the offense do what it does best.
Otherwise, he warned, the Wolverines could waste the season while it’s already hanging by a thread.
In Other News...
Penn State Faces A Bigger Problem Than Its Slow Start
Penn States slow start has been frustrating enough on the field, but the ripple effects are reaching well beyond the scoreboard. A program that usually relies on Beaver Stadiums size and noise as a weekly advantage is now dealing with empty seats, cheaper tickets and a fan base that looks more hesitant than hostile, all while the football operation remains the financial engine for much of the rest of the athletic department.
The timing makes the upcoming USC game feel especially significant, not just as a chance to steady the season but as a measure of whether the atmosphere around the program can rebound with it. Matt Campbell is already under scrutiny in his first stretch on the job, and if Penn State cannot generate momentum soon, the bigger concern may not be one loss or one bad month, but how quickly the strain starts to show everywhere else. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Faces A White Out Turning Point With Offense Under Pressure
Penn State heads into its third conference game of the 2026 season with USC arriving for the annual White Out, and the timing hardly could be more interesting. The Nittany Lions are trying to steady an offense that has not found enough rhythm on the ground, while the defense is still searching for sharper tackling as the schedule tightens and the stakes keep rising under the lights.
Matt Campbell has already settled on Rocco Becht as the starting quarterback for the stretch run, giving the offense a clear direction as the team tries to put more together in a matchup that always feels bigger than a single Saturday. The White Out has a way of exposing what a team is and what it still has to become, and for Penn State this one looks like a checkpoint for an offense under pressure and a defense that needs to clean up the little things fast. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State White Out Could Test Thin Spots Fans Are Watching
Penn States first Big Ten availability report of the week offered a familiar mix of good news and lingering uncertainty ahead of USCs visit, with the White Out spotlight already fixed on the Nittany Lions depth. Linebacker Alex Tatsch and defensive lineman Armstrong Nnodim were both listed as questionable because of prior injuries, while Cam Smith remains out and receiver Koby Howard is set to miss his third Big Ten game.
USC brings its own injury wrinkle into the matchup, with receiver Trent Mosley also marked questionable after sitting out previous games. For Penn State, the bigger issue is less about the headline names than the spots behind them, where absences have already started to stretch the rotation and could matter even more in a game with this kind of stage and pace. [Read more 🡒]