Penn State’s 2025 season came apart so fast it almost feels like a bad dream, and for a lot of fans, it starts with one throw.
Two interceptions from Drew Allar, separated by about 8.5 months, ended up bookending the collapse. One came in the Orange Bowl against Notre Dame.
The other arrived in the White Out against Oregon. And if either one goes the other way, the whole story around James Franklin’s final season probably changes.
The first gut punch came against Notre Dame. Penn State led 10-3 at halftime and still had control deep into the game.
The Nittany Lions went back in front 24-17 after the Fighting Irish had taken their first lead, then watched a 54-yard touchdown knot things at 24-24. With less than a minute left in regulation, Allar got the ball back and Penn State chose aggression.
It cost them immediately. With 35 seconds left, Allar tried to hit Omari Evans, but Christian Gray stepped in front of it at Penn State’s 42-yard-line. Notre Dame then marched to the game-winning field goal, and Penn State was left on the doorstep of a national championship appearance.
That’s the moment fans have replayed over and over: no interception, Penn State kicks the field goal, and the Nittany Lions head to the title game against Ohio State. The source of the alternate-reality argument is simple, even if the likely result isn’t.
The Buckeyes, realistically, would have beaten Penn State. But just getting there would have mattered for Franklin, and it likely would have changed the decision-making around the roster, too.
His starters would have likely opted out of the 2025 NFL Draft and still returned for their last NCAA season.
Then came Week 5, the White Out against Oregon, and another interception that sent everything sliding downhill.
That game had plenty riding on it already. Franklin had a lot to prove in a setting built for statements.
Could he handle the biggest stage? Could Allar handle it too?
The answer, in the end, was no. When the Ducks walked it off with a pick on Allar in 2OT, Penn State’s season started to snowball in the wrong direction.
Had that pass not been intercepted, Penn State would have scored in double overtime, kicked the extra point, and won 31-30. That would have been a massive victory for Franklin, and the playoff path would still have been open. Instead, the loss to Oregon bled into more losses, including defeats to UCLA and Northwestern, and the confidence drain from that moment mattered just as much as the result itself.
From there, the path gets easier to picture. The Iowa-Ohio State-Indiana stretch would still have been a problem, and Penn State likely would have lost to the Buckeyes and Hoosiers. But even with that, a season finished at 10-2 with a win over Oregon, or 11-1 if you want to stretch it, would have kept the Nittany Lions ranked and in the College Football Playoff mix.
That alternate ending would have meant another shot at a national title. It also would have probably given Franklin another year. At the very least, he would have cleared the minimum, leaving Pat Kraft to decide whether “third time’s a charm.”
In Other News...
Penn State Camp Buzz Is Building Around Two Key Position Battles
Penn States 2026 camp is barely underway, but the first 11-on-11 work has already given the staff a clearer look at a few players trying to carve out roles before the opener against Marshall. Among the early standouts are Iowa State transfer receiver Eskildsen, defensive lineman Ikenna Ezeogu, quarterback Alex Manske and versatile option Rappleyea, each of whom has flashed enough in camp to draw attention from coaches as the roster starts to take shape.
The most interesting early camp developments have come in the places where Penn State still needs answers, especially on offense, where receiver depth and quarterback depth are always under the microscope. Eskildsens transition has been one of the louder storylines, while Manskes return after missing spring practice has added another layer to the quarterback picture, and both players are part of a group that appears to be pushing for bigger responsibilities as camp continues. [Read more 🡒]
Penn States Kalani Sitake Pursuit Looks Different After BYUs Costly Bet
Kalani Sitakes new deal at BYU has changed the way any outside pursuit would have to be viewed, even if Penn States interest in him predated the Nittany Lions hiring Matt Campbell. BYU did not just reward its coach with an extension, it made a major financial commitment by pushing his annual salary from $4 million to $10 million while also spending more on assistants and the roster, a clear sign it intends to keep pace in a sport where money increasingly shapes the coaching market.
Still, Sitake has not sounded entirely comfortable with the gap he sees around him, pointing to the financial limits BYU faces compared with other programs in the Big 12 and across the power conferences. For Penn State, that matters because the school was part of the conversation once upon a time, and the bigger question now is how a program with its own deep resources would have framed the chase if it had pressed harder before Campbell took the job. [Read more 🡒]