James Franklin’s own explanation for why things went sideways at Penn State - that he got “too comfortable” - sounds tidy enough on the surface. But it misses the bigger issue.
Franklin has never really struggled when he’s been building. He’s struggled when the bar gets raised and the job stops being about steady progress.
That’s the part that matters in the story of his Penn State tenure. From 2014 until his exit in the middle of the 2025 season, Franklin pushed the Nittany Lions back into the national conversation.
The results were real: a 104-45 record, a Big Ten Championship, multiple double-digit win seasons, and the program’s first College Football Playoff appearance. Even with the rough ending, that’s a coach who delivered exactly what he’s known for - he rebuilt.
Franklin told The Athletic’s Ralph D. Russo that when the 2025 season began, he didn’t hold the entire staff to the same standard he had before.
In his view, the group lacked a spark, drifted into complacency, and that helped sink the season. But calling it comfort doesn’t quite capture the full picture.
The easier fit for Franklin is the one he’s stepping into now. Virginia Tech, as Russo suggested, was “ the candidate” for him once the opening came up.
That’s not a bad thing for either side. It’s a setup that plays directly to what Franklin does best.
“Heck, in a way, if he did bring the exact same Penn State model here, I wouldn’t mind playing in the final four and the [CFP],” outgoing Virginia Tech athletic director Whit Babcock said.
That’s the appeal. Franklin doesn’t need to reinvent himself.
He doesn’t need to match wits with Ohio State’s Ryan Day, Notre Dame’s Marcus Freeman, Oregon’s Dan Lanning or Indiana’s Curt Cignetti. He doesn’t need to chase a national championship every week.
He can bring the same model, apply it in a less demanding conference than the Big Ten, and let the results build from there.
In that sense, comfort is almost Franklin’s sweet spot. The trouble starts when the situation changes and the expectations climb beyond the structure he’s built.
He has shown he can coach freely when the mission is to lift a program up. He did it at Penn State.
He did it at Vanderbilt.
“There’s always pressure, and he’s always got to win, and one day, maybe here, hopefully, it’s if you don’t win the national championship, it’s a disappointment,” Babcock added.
That’s where Franklin’s track record gets more complicated. When the job asks for more than his model can naturally supply, the wheels can come off.
It isn’t just about dropping a big game or running into a better roster. The source of the collapse can be much uglier - losses to UCLA, losses to Northwestern, and a season that falls apart when the team is supposed to be peaking.
If comfort was the whole issue at Penn State, the 2025 team wouldn’t have opened 0-3 in Big Ten play. It would have simply hit the usual ceiling. Instead, expectations rose, Franklin found himself in a place that no longer fit the way he coaches, and the season unraveled.
Now he’s in a spot where his approach can work again until it doesn’t. Franklin said coaching in the ACC is a very different challenge than coaching for a national title. And that may be the clearest thing of all: he’s back where his style has room to breathe, at a program trying to take the next step without demanding that he become something else to do it.
In Other News...
James Franklin Just Reopened Penn States Messiest Breakup Debate
James Franklins first public reflections on his 2025 firing at Penn State have only added another layer to a breakup that already felt complicated. After nearly 12 years in State College, he is moving quickly into the next chapter at Virginia Tech, where he says he plans to take the lessons from his Penn State run and apply them in Blacksburg. For a fan base that watched the relationship unravel over time, the timing of his comments only sharpens the sense that this was more than a simple end to a tenure.
Penn State athletic director Pat Kraft has already framed the decision as one driven by the programs broader trajectory, not just a short losing stretch, which matters because it suggests the split was about bigger concerns than one bad week. Franklins new landing spot has come with plenty of support, too, giving this story a very different feel on the other side of the breakup. Even so, the way he is talking now makes it clear the Penn State chapter is still being processed, and maybe not quite finished. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Just Got A Crucial Max Granville Development
Max Granvilles path back has quietly become one of the more encouraging developments around Penn States defensive front. The defensive end has added good weight to his frame, now listed at 252 pounds, and the early signs point to him being ready to matter in a big way when the Nittany Lions build toward 2026. For a program that always needs disruptive edge play, getting a young lineman trending the right way after a long rehab is the kind of update that can change the outlook of a position group.
Penn States strength and conditioning staff has noticed the work, too, with director Reid Kagy praising Granvilles effort and the progress he has made along the way. The bigger question now is how quickly that growth turns into production once the season arrives, because the expectation inside the program is that Granville can step into a starting role and become a significant piece of the defensive line rotation. [Read more 🡒]
James Armstrong Could Change How Penn State Fans See Campbell
James Bobo Armstrongs commitment gives Penn State a jolt at a position that always carries outsized weight in the fan base, and it arrives at a useful time for a program trying to steady its recruiting momentum. The Hopewell, Pennsylvania, quarterback is a four-star prospect, and his decision adds a local name with real buzz to a class that needed a lift.
For Matt Campbell, landing Armstrong is about more than one pledge. Penn State has spent recent weeks dealing with a few recruiting setbacks, and this one offers a chance to show the staff can still close on elite talent and keep building belief around the programs future. Whether it becomes the kind of domino that changes the tone of the cycle is the next question, but it is the sort of commitment the Nittany Lions have been waiting for. [Read more 🡒]