Alabama’s quarterback room is loaded enough to make a top-10 omission look flat-out strange.
Kalen DeBoer still doesn’t have a locked-in starter for the 2026 season, but the battle is shaping up to be a two-man race between redshirt freshman Keelon Russell and redshirt junior Austin Mack. Russell has picked up plenty of momentum in the conversation and even has some dark-horse Heisman Trophy buzz attached to his name, but Mack is still right there and will keep pushing him through fall camp.
The bigger picture is hard to miss: Alabama looks set up well at the most important spot on the field, no matter how the competition shakes out. Both quarterbacks bring real ability, and the ceiling for each is high. Add in the fact that 5-star true freshman Jett Thomalla is sitting further down the depth chart, and the room has the kind of star power most programs can only dream about.
That’s what made CBS Sports’ latest ranking so surprising. Blake Brockermeyer put together his top 10 quarterback rooms in college football this week, and Alabama didn’t make the cut at all.
Here’s how Brockermeyer stacked the list:
Oregon
Texas
Utah
Ole Miss
Ohio State
LSU
USC
Miami
Houston
Notre Dame
The omission is hard to square when you look at the talent in Tuscaloosa. Mack came out of high school as a 4-star recruit and a top 100 overall player.
Russell was a 5-star and the No. 2 overall player in his class. Thomalla adds another elite piece behind them, giving Alabama depth that stands out even among the sport’s best rooms.
Brockermeyer didn’t explain why Alabama was left out, but the list clearly leaned toward rooms with a proven starter already in place. That makes some sense if the goal is to rank the most established quarterbacks. It’s a different conversation, though, when the topic is the best quarterback room overall.
If Utah’s Devon Dampier is more proven than Mack or Russell, that’s fair. But saying Utah has a better quarterback room top to bottom than Alabama is a much tougher sell.
And the funniest part of all this might be how it looks once the season plays out. If Russell or Mack wins the job and becomes one of the nation’s better quarterbacks, this ranking will age badly in a hurry.
Whoever comes out on top will leave Alabama with a strong starter, and the loser could still be one of the best backup quarterbacks in the country. Thomalla, meanwhile, gives DeBoer a third-string option that few teams can match.
Alabama has its questions heading into 2026, but quarterback isn’t one of them. The Crimson Tide have too much talent, too much depth, and too much upside in that room to be left out of a list like this.
In Other News...
Penn State Just Took Another Painful In-State Recruiting Hit At Receiver
Penn States push to keep elite in-state talent close to home took another hit in the 2028 cycle, and this one stings in a way the Nittany Lions know all too well. Jett Harrison, one of Pennsylvanias premier wide receiver prospects, had been a major name to watch as the program tried to build around its homegrown pipeline, but the Buckeyes won out despite the obvious pull of family ties and the chance to stay within reach of State College.
The timing only adds to the frustration because Penn State is still waiting on another important receiver decision in the 2027 class, with Khalil Taylor trending elsewhere as well. That leaves the staff trying to steady the position in other ways, from transfer additions to coaching tweaks, while the bigger recruiting question lingers: how much more in-state receiver talent can Penn State afford to let slip away before the pattern starts to matter on the field? [Read more 🡒]
Penn States New Strength Staff Is Setting A Clear Tone
A new tone is already taking shape around Penn States strength program as Reid Kagy settles into his role as director of strength and conditioning and looks ahead to the 2026 football season. With summer workout time limited, the staff is zeroing in on the traits that matter most in the weight room and on the field: power, speed and durability, while also putting a premium on building real connections with the players.
Kagys approach goes beyond the physical work, especially with so many new faces in the building, because the staff wants the roster to move as one and understand the standards that came before them. Technology is part of the process too, with Catapult vests helping track player metrics and improvement, but the bigger message is about identity, accountability and carrying forward the programs strength-and-conditioning history. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Made Its Quarterback Choice After A Recruiting Twist
Penn States quarterback board took a notable turn this week, and the move ultimately left the Nittany Lions in a stronger spot at the position. Four-star James Armstrong, one of the top-ranked prospects in Pennsylvania, committed to Penn State after making multiple visits and building a clear comfort level with the program and its staff.
The timing mattered, too, because the path to Armstrongs pledge opened up after another highly regarded quarterback in the class changed course elsewhere. Armstrong had already signaled confidence in how Penn State viewed his future role, and his commitment gives the Nittany Lions a homegrown answer at a position they continue to prioritize in recruiting. [Read more 🡒]