Through five weeks, the Jason Beck-Bryce Underwood partnership at Michigan has not delivered the kind of offensive jolt the Wolverines were counting on.
This was supposed to be the fix. Beck arrived with a reputation for getting more out of an offense, and Underwood came in as the five-star quarterback talent Michigan flipped from LSU to become the centerpiece of the rebuild. Instead, the early returns have been uneven at best, and the problems around the offense have only made the growing pains more obvious.
The clearest issue is on the ground, where Michigan has gone from expecting a bruising identity to producing almost nothing consistent. Savion Hiter and Jordan Marshall were supposed to be major pieces of the attack, with Underwood adding another layer with his legs.
That hasn’t happened. Michigan is 100th in the country in rush yards per game, and the team has only one run of more than 20 yards this season.
None of those explosive plays have come from the backfield that was supposed to carry so much of the load.
Blake Frazier said this week that the Wolverines need to get back to what they are supposed to be.
"I would love that,” Frazier said about getting back to running downhill at defenses more often. “This is Michigan football.
You think Michigan football, you think downhill runs. I would love to see that implemented a little bit more."
That’s the identity Michigan still seems to be chasing. The defense, at least, is holding up its end of the bargain. It ranks sixth in the country and has been stout for most of the season, even while spending too much time on the field because the offense can’t stay on schedule.
The passing game has been no cleaner. Michigan is 111th in the country in pass yards per game after finishing 104th last season, which is exactly the kind of number that had fans turning on Chip Lindsey a year ago. Beck and Koy Detmer Jr. were brought in to get more out of Underwood as a passer, and the Wolverines even rebuilt the receiver room around him with Salesi Moa, Jaime Ffrench and JJ Buchanan.
Buchanan has lived up to the billing. Andrew Marsh has had his moments too. But Moa and Ffrench have not delivered much so far, and the offense still has long stretches where it looks cramped and easy to defend.
Underwood has flashed, including a week where he answered criticism by helping take down Oklahoma with 111 passing yards, 87 rushing yards and a rushing touchdown. He also connected with JJ Buchanan on a touchdown against Iowa when Michigan moved back in front, 19-14.
But those moments have been too rare. Too often, he has looked like the freshman quarterback he is, with shaky footwork, bad habits and a tendency to panic when pressure arrives.
He has turned the ball over at least once in every game except the 17-10 win over Oklahoma. Even in that game, he fumbled twice, though Michigan recovered both.
The structure around him hasn’t helped. Michigan’s tight ends drew attention this week after leaked messages led to an apology from Zack Marshall, and the position has been a weakness all season.
The group has not blocked well enough and has offered little as a receiving threat, leaving too many formations where Buchanan and Marsh are stacked on the same side with no real threat on the other. That makes life far too easy for opposing defenses.
That’s where the frustration comes from. Underwood was not brought in to be a caretaker, and Michigan did not hire Beck to watch the offense sputter this badly. With fans already talking about benching the quarterback or firing the coordinator, the first five weeks have left little room for optimism.
When the ball isn’t moving, the grades are going to be harsh. And right now, Michigan’s offense has earned them.
In Other News...
Penn States White Out Puts One USC Advantage Under Pressure
The White Out at Penn State is already looming as a major test for USC, but it also carries a familiar twist for Lincoln Riley. On the other side will be DAnton Lynn, now Penn States defensive coordinator, who spent last season on Rileys USC staff and helped stabilize a Trojans defense that had been searching for answers. Their shared background gives this matchup an unusual layer of familiarity, with both coaches knowing something about how the other thinks and prepares.
For Penn State, Lynns return to the opposite sideline adds intrigue to a game that will be driven as much by adjustments as by atmosphere. Riley has long been one of the sports sharper offensive minds, and Lynns recent success against that same environment gives the Nittany Lions a meaningful point of confidence. There is mutual respect between the two, but Saturday night is about more than that history. It is a chance to see which coach can turn familiarity into an edge when the crowd, the stakes and the pressure are all at their peak. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State White Out Just Got Bigger Than Anyone Wanted
Penn State is heading into Saturday nights White Out with a lot more on the line than usual, and not just because No. 19 USC is coming to Beaver Stadium for a 7:30 p.m. ET kickoff. The Nittany Lions have spent the past couple weeks trying to steady themselves after losses to Wisconsin and Northwestern, results that have put a spotlight on a season that was supposed to feel more settled by now.
USC arrives with the kind of profile that can make an already charged environment feel even heavier. Lincoln Rileys team is 5-1 and has flashed the offensive punch that has become its calling card, even if the defense has left room for concern. For Penn State, the White Out is no longer just about pageantry and atmosphere. Its a chance to halt the slide before the questions around Matt Campbells tenure grow any louder. [Read more 🡒]
Penn State Still Needs More From One Key Pass Rusher
Penn States defense came out of the Northwestern game with a few reminders of how thin the margin can be up front. The run defense gave up more ground than usual, the sack count stayed low, and the overall pressure package never quite found a steady rhythm. For a unit that has leaned on disruption to set the tone, it was the kind of afternoon that left the staff looking for a little more from the edge.
Yvan Kemajou has been part of that conversation because the flashes are there, but defensive coordinator DAnton Lynn made it clear the next step is consistency. Penn State likes the playmaking potential Kemajou brings, and the coaches know there is still room for the defense to tighten up as the season moves on. The upside remains obvious, but the Lions are still waiting for that pass-rushing spark to show up snap after snap. [Read more 🡒]