Senators Strong Start Is Putting Their Depth Bets Under A Microscope

As the Ottawa Senators surprise the league with their best start in years, the team finds strength in unexpected places and players look to redefine their roles and futures.

With American Thanksgiving less than a week away, Ottawa is sitting in a good spot. The Senators are playing a strong team game, getting excellent goaltending on most nights, and holding a playoff position thanks not just to their stars, but to depth players who have stepped up when it mattered. It’s also the best record the club has had in more than 10 seasons, and that has opened the door for a few very different kinds of stories: second chances, surprise openings and players waiting for their moment.

Tyler Boucher has been one of the clearest examples of making the most of that chance.

For a long time, the conversation around Boucher centered on where Ottawa drafted him. Fans and pundits hammered the Senators for taking him in the top 10 when many draft projections had him going in the second round.

Then the injuries piled up. A knee injury in his draft year, a torn labrum in his final junior season with the 67s that required surgery, a groin injury in training camp as a rookie, and later a left shoulder injury that also needed surgery.

By the time he reached the pro level in 2023, he had already been through a brutal run of bad luck.

Still, he kept grinding. Through his entry-level contract, his game improved little by little, enough to earn a one-year extension from Staios and management last summer.

He has responded with a strong start in Belleville, where he has locked into the top six and become a more dangerous offensive player than he was a year ago. When Hayden Hodgson went down against Pittsburgh on Saturday, Boucher got the call, and he made it count right away by scoring the winning goal in his first NHL game on a heads up play.

With the way he’s developed, he looks like a bottom-six option who can bring more offense than most players in that lane, and he could end up replacing Hodgson as a full-time fourth-liner, especially alongside familiar Belleville names like Stephen Halliday and Sammy Blais.

Samuel Ersson has been a very different kind of case.

He arrived in Ottawa after four seasons with the Flyers, where his numbers got worse every year. Philadelphia moved him to the Toronto Maple Leafs in the offseason along with Emil Andrae and a third-round pick for Joseph Woll and Simon Benoit, then Toronto flipped him to Ottawa after only ten days in the organization for a 2027 fifth-round pick. That move drew plenty of criticism for Steve Staios, especially because the Leafs were not planning to offer Ersson a contract, which raised the obvious question of why Ottawa traded for his rights at all.

The bigger issue, though, was the performance history. Ersson finished with a goal saved above expected of -16.5 in 2025-26 and -19.9 in 2024-25, the worst two-year mark in the league.

Ottawa’s goalie coaches, Justin Peters and Maciej Szwoch, believed a change of scenery could help him rediscover his game. At first, it looked like a disaster, particularly when Linus Ullmark got hurt in the game against Florida.

But as Ersson played more, he started to settle in and even stole a game, showing he could still be a positive difference maker. Last night was a rough step backward, though, and it was the kind of outing that can shake confidence fast.

He’ll have to win back the trust of his coaches and teammates after singlehandedly costing them a point on Thursday night.

André Burakovsky has not followed that same path.

He came into the organization from Chicago on the same day as Ersson, and that move was met with heavy skepticism from the fan base. So far, that pessimism has been justified.

Burakovsky has battled injuries and, when he has been in the lineup, has not done much with the opportunity. He looked fine in preseason against weaker competition, but in eight regular-season games he has averaged 11 minutes of ice time and produced just three shots on goal.

For a player carrying a $5.5 million contract, that’s a problem. Elliotte Friedman reported that both sides are looking to move on, and there is a real chance Ottawa never sees Burakovsky in a Senators sweater again.

If the Senators want to move the contract, they may need to retain salary or attach picks to get a bottom-feeder to take it. The bigger question is whether he becomes part of a larger trade for a higher-profile scorer or gets dealt simply to clear cap space before another scoring move comes later.

Phil Tomasino has taken a much better turn.

He entered the season as something of an afterthought, joining Belleville as a top player alongside Ryan Suzuki and Christian Kyrou, but not really in the mix for an NHL job. Injuries to William Eklund and Warren Foegele changed that.

Tomasino got his chance, jumped on it, and never really looked back. After wearing out his welcome in Nashville and Pittsburgh, Ottawa has given him a real opening to establish himself in the top nine.

He has the skill to stick with the Senators, he adds another useful depth piece, and he has shown enough to suggest he could fit here longer term.

Then there’s Kasper Halttunen, who is still waiting for his first NHL game but keeps doing everything asked of him in Belleville.

He has 12 goals in 18 games and is being used in every situation. He’s on the power play, he’s in the defensive zone, and he’s throwing his body around when needed.

His skating still needs work, but the hands and the effort are there, and that combination keeps pushing him closer to a call-up. At this point, it’s just a matter of when the Senators decide he has earned it.

In Other News...

Senators Trade Push Suddenly Centers On A Familiar Name

The Senators search for help has taken an unexpected turn, with reports linking Ottawa to the Penguins as the trade market starts to take shape. General manager Steve Staios is believed to be looking for a top-six forward, and Pittsburgh has emerged as a possible partner, with Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust among the names being discussed.

What makes the idea especially intriguing is the possibility that Erik Karlsson could be part of the conversation. The defenseman, now a pending free agent with a no-movement clause, is reportedly open to a return to Ottawa, which would add a familiar and complicated layer to any deal involving the Penguins and a Senators team trying to strengthen its forward group. [Read more 🡒]

Senators Could Revisit A Costly Flyers Trade That Changes Their Top Six

The Senators search for top-six help could circle back to a familiar pair in Philadelphia, according to a rumor reported by The Fourth Period. Ottawa has reportedly shown past interest in Flyers forwards Owen Tippett and Travis Konecny, two players who would immediately change the look of the group if the Senators ever decided to push harder on the trade front.

Konecny stands out as the bigger swing, a two-time 30-goal scorer whose value comes with a significant cap hit and the kind of price tag that can reshape a deal before it even starts. Any serious pursuit would likely demand a first-round pick and high-end prospects, which is why this remains speculative for now, but it is the sort of conversation that can linger when a team is looking for offense and impact at the same time. [Read more 🡒]

Senators Fans Have Two Big Reasons To Watch Tonight

Samuel Ersson will get the start in goal for the Senators tonight when they host the Flyers, giving Ottawa another look at a goalie who has quietly become one of the more interesting stories on the roster. Ersson, who has also spent time with Philadelphia and Toronto, has been steady enough to help the Senators pick up points in his last five starts, and that kind of run tends to matter even more when the schedule tightens up and every home game starts to feel a little heavier.

Tyler Boucher adds another layer to the night, with the rookie forward set to play his second straight NHL game after recently scoring a game-winning goal. For a Senators team still sorting out its identity, those are the kinds of developments that can make a midseason matchup feel worth circling, especially when a familiar opponent is coming to town and a couple of younger names are suddenly in the spotlight. [Read more 🡒]