The Senators have a big decision to make after the summer exits of Brady Tkachuk and Daniel Alfredsson: who wears the “C” next?
That question sits right at the center of Ottawa’s next chapter, and it comes with a short list of possible answers if the club decides not to go without a captain at all. The idea of entering next season without one is on the table, just as it was for three years after Erik Karlsson was traded in 2018. But if the Senators want to name someone before opening night in October, the field narrows quickly.
Thomas Chabot is the first obvious name. He’s been around longer than any other active Senator and now leads the current roster with 569 games played, which ranks 11th in franchise history and puts him just three behind Tkachuk.
He has worn an “A” for years, carries plenty of respect inside the room, and has lived through both the darkest stretch of the rebuild and the team’s return to playoff hockey. The only real question is whether he fits into the organization’s long-term plans beyond his current contract, which still has two years left at roughly $8 million per season.
Claude Giroux is another strong option, even if he never wore the captain’s letter in Ottawa the way he did for a decade in Philadelphia. Nobody has questioned his leadership over four seasons with the Senators, and his re-signing on Tuesday gave the fan base a lift after a rough stretch. At 38, he could serve as a bridge captain while the team gets more clarity on Chabot and continues to sort through its younger options.
Then there are the two names that sit at the top of the list if the Senators want their captain to be their best player: Tim Stützle and Jake Sanderson. Both are 24, both were top-five picks, and both have grown into exactly what Ottawa hoped they would become.
Stützle brings elite skill, speed and compete, though his emotions can still get the better of him at times. Sanderson, meanwhile, has the same kind of skill, skating and work ethic, but with a steadier edge.
He rarely looks rattled, no matter the score, and the only real stumble that comes to mind is his post-game critique of goalie Leevi Merilainen this season.
There are also the concerns some fans may raise about Sanderson because he’s American, especially with the recent run of Team USA players moving on from places like Ottawa. But the broader point is bigger than nationality: elite players want good situations, and teams that stay competitive usually don’t have to worry as much about stars looking elsewhere. Sanderson also spent his teen years in Calgary, and both of his parents are Canadian.
If the call were mine, Sanderson would get the job. Chabot, Giroux and Stützle would all handle it well, but Sanderson already looks like a captain.
He leads by example, keeps an even keel and is the player Travis Green uses in every important situation. If Ottawa wants to settle the question before opening night, the answer feels pretty clear.
In Other News...
Wild Quietly Secured Important Right Side Blue Line Depth
Ottawas offseason roster churn has already started to ripple beyond the NHL level, and one of the more notable names in that mix is Arthur Kaliyev. After putting together a big AHL season with Belleville, the winger still found himself on the outside of Ottawas plans when the club chose not to tender a qualifying offer, leaving his future tied to the broader market rather than the Senators depth chart.
That uncertainty has only grown as interest has surfaced from multiple KHL clubs, a reminder that Ottawas decision could send a productive scorer overseas instead of back into its organization. For a team looking to keep its pipeline stocked and its options flexible, Kaliyevs next move is one more small but meaningful offseason thread to watch. [Read more 🡒]
Oilers Power Play Could Be Headed For A Risky New Direction
The Senators made one of their most important summer moves by keeping Claude Giroux in the fold on a one-year contract, a deal that gives Ottawa a familiar veteran presence while it continues to build around its younger core. Girouxs return fits the organizations broader approach of balancing development with reliability, and it keeps a steady two-way player in a room that still leans on experience in key moments.
The contract itself reflects that balance, with a modest base salary and the chance to earn more through performance bonuses. Ottawa wanted to preserve Girouxs leadership and on-ice stability without losing flexibility, and the timing of the agreement suggests both sides were motivated to get it done quickly once talks gained momentum. [Read more 🡒]