Now that the Senators’ blue line is back together, Carter Yakemchuk is the one left waiting.
With Jake Sanderson, Artem Zub and Thomas Chabot all back in the lineup, Ottawa has finally reached a point where its defence depth chart is no longer being held together by injuries. That has pushed Yakemchuk, who is waivers-exempt, into the press box for three straight games. The Senators also placed and lost Cameron Crotty on waivers last week, and the result is a clearer picture of where Travis Green sees the 21-year-old right now: outside the top six.
That was on display again in Sunday night’s 6-3 loss to the Anaheim Ducks, which marked Yakemchuk’s third consecutive healthy scratch. At this point, there is no clear sign of when he’ll get back into the lineup barring another injury.
The numbers help explain why the coaching staff has gone this route. Yakemchuk was playing third-pair minutes, and that’s not the kind of usage that showcases the offensive upside that made him such an intriguing draft pick.
His game was always supposed to be about offence carrying the load and smoothing over the occasional defensive mistake. But when a defenceman is stuck on the third pair and the second power-play unit, the chances to make an impact shrink fast.
The mistakes, meanwhile, get louder.
That’s the tension here. Yakemchuk was drafted to be more than a depth piece, and right now he’s being used like one.
There’s also a roster-management angle that’s hard to ignore. In hindsight, Yakemchuk probably should have been the player sent to Belleville earlier, with Crotty staying on as the seventh defenceman.
Instead, Ottawa lost a depth option and now has Yakemchuk sitting when he should be playing. It’s the kind of call that can expose the difference between how coaches and general managers see the board.
Coaches want the best lineup every night. Managers want their draft picks and acquisitions to matter.
Steve Staios has only one defenceman on the roster that he personally brought in, Jordan Spence, and the situation suggests he expected Yakemchuk to be ready for this stage by now. Maybe he would be in another setup. In Ottawa, though, the path is blocked.
There’s no embarrassment in a 21-year-old being the odd man out on a team with this much quality on the back end. Nikolas Matinpalo may be the better fit for the minutes available, but that doesn’t mean he’s the better long-term player. It just means he matches the job in front of him.
And yes, the comparisons are there. Zayne Parekh, Sam Dickinson and Zeev Buium are all playing regularly after being drafted behind Yakemchuk. Even Artyom Levshunov, the second overall pick in 2024, isn’t facing nearly the same fight for ice time in Chicago, and his production has been modest.
Still, Ottawa’s situation is its own beast. The Senators’ top four is simply too strong to hand Yakemchuk a bigger role by default, and the idea that he’ll climb his way up from a third-pairing spot doesn’t look realistic. His defensive-zone starts were already being limited whenever possible.
So the question becomes simple: why is he in the press box instead of playing big minutes in Belleville?
The answer isn’t that Ottawa can’t use him later. It’s that they need to use him properly.
There will be injuries again. There will be chances to recall him.
For now, the Senators need to resist turning a top-four project into a third-pair placeholder.
If Yakemchuk is going to become what the Senators intended when they took him No. 7 in 2024, he needs reps - not nights spent watching from above.
In Other News...
Senators Give Two Depth Names A Big Chance In Buffalo
The Senators finish their five-game road trip in Buffalo with a lineup that looks a lot like the one they used in Anaheim, but there are still a couple of fresh wrinkles for a team trying to get through the stretch without much margin for error. Sammy Blais is set to make his regular-season debut for Ottawa, a chance earned in part by the injuries that have thinned the group and opened a door for depth players to step in and matter.
Carter Yakemchuk is also expected back in the lineup after missing the previous game, giving Ottawa another young option on the blue line as Nikolas Matinpalo sits out with illness. Samuel Ersson gets the start in goal, and with the road trip winding down, the Senators are again leaning on a mix of regulars and call-up energy to get through one more game before heading home. [Read more 🡒]
Sabres Catch A Break As Senators Face Another Goalie Issue
An optional skate offered a little hope, but it did not change the outlook for Ottawa in goal. Linus Ullmark took part in the session, yet he will not start against the Buffalo Sabres because of a lower-body injury, leaving the Senators to lean on Samuel Ersson again as they try to manage another night without their usual setup in net.
The lineup hit did not stop there, either. Defenseman Tyler Kleven will also miss the game because of illness, adding another absence for a Senators team already dealing with a thin margin for error as it faces Buffalo. [Read more 🡒]
Senators Power Play Problem Is Starting To Put Travis Green On Spot
The Senators power play has become one of the clearest trouble spots in the early part of the season, and it is starting to put Travis Green in an uncomfortable position. Ottawa has had chances to cash in with the extra man, but the unit has too often looked disjointed, with sluggish puck movement, sloppy passing and too little sustained pressure to make opponents pay.
For a team that needs every edge it can get, the lack of finishing touch on special teams has fed into the bigger scoring concerns around the roster. The encouraging part is that the fix does not seem mysterious, with more shooting and cleaner movement among the adjustments that could help, but until the Senators show they can turn those ideas into results, the spotlight on Green and his staff is only going to get brighter. [Read more 🡒]