The Ottawa Senators are running into a good problem on the blue line, and it centers on Carter Yakemchuk.
With Tyler Kleven set to return to the lineup tonight after Wednesday night’s game in Buffalo with an illness, Ottawa’s defensive picture is getting clearer. That’s the upside. The wrinkle is that head coach Travis Green now has to sort out what to do with the 2024 first-round pick, who has been in and out of the lineup as the Senators try to settle their third pair.
Yakemchuk has sat in the press box for three of Ottawa’s last four games, with Nikolas Matinpalo drawing in instead. Earlier in the season, injuries to Artem Zub, Jake Sanderson and captain Thomas Chabot left enough room for both players.
That cushion is gone now. If Green keeps both Matinpalo and Yakemchuk in the mix with Kleven, one of them is likely to be the odd man out on any given night.
The case for Yakemchuk is obvious. In 14 games this season, he has a goal and two assists while averaging 17:55 of ice time. His goal came in the home opener, when his heavy shot on the power play broke a 1-1 tie and helped Ottawa beat the Philadelphia Flyers 2-1.
That kind of shot is exactly why the Senators have reason to be patient. Ottawa’s power play sits 31st in the league, and Yakemchuk’s right-handed blast gives them something they badly need from the blue line. Two of his three points have come with the man advantage, and if he can keep getting pucks through and creating looks from the point, he could become a real weapon there.
Not a bad time for your second NHL goal! Carter Yakemchuk gives the Sens a 2-1 lead late in the third. pic.twitter.com/TS0puQqlvh
- Andrew Wilimek (@AndrewWilimek) October 9, 2026
Still, the growing pains are real. Yakemchuk has had trouble with positioning and puck management, and those mistakes stand out fast at this level.
He has 15 giveaways and a -5 rating, and he has only been credited with one hit. For a 6’3” defender with his size and offensive upside, there’s clearly more physicality and cleaner decision-making to unlock.
Green’s choice tonight against the Utah Mammoth at Canadian Tire Centre says a lot about where Ottawa is with him right now. Yakemchuk is in over Matinpalo, and if that continues, he’ll keep learning on the NHL stage.
But Matinpalo has earned his own case. The Finnish Olympian has three assists in 15 games and is averaging 15:06 of ice time. There’s also a numbers problem for Ottawa when the pairings are broken down: Kleven and Matinpalo have a 53.2% expected goal percentage together, while Kleven and Yakemchuk sit at 29.2%.
That leaves Green with a few options. He can keep rotating the two young defensemen and split the minutes.
He can stick with Yakemchuk and let him keep taking his lumps. Or he can send him back to Belleville, which may not be the popular answer but could be the cleanest path if the goal is steady development and more confidence.
In Other News...
Senators Face An Early Test With Lineup Questions Still Lingering
The Senators get right back to work at Canadian Tire Centre with a matchup that should tell them a little more about where they stand this early in the season. Ottawa and Utah both enter at 10-6-1, and the Senators are trying to build on a tight 2-1 win over Buffalo while the Mammoth arrive after a 5-4 overtime loss to Montreal. Both clubs are dealing with injuries, but each has still put together projected lineups, which at this point of the schedule is often as revealing as the standings themselves.
For Ottawa, the bigger question is not just the opponent but how much certainty the lineup will actually have once puck drop gets closer. The Senators have been managing absences while trying to keep their recent momentum intact, and the game presents another chance to test their depth against a team with similar results so far. There is still some pregame uncertainty hanging over the group, and how the final lineup settles in could matter just as much as the result against a Mammoth team that has already shown it can push games deep into the night. [Read more 🡒]
MacKenzie Weegar Was Almost Headed Somewhere Else Before Calgary Dealt Him
MacKenzie Weegars path out of Calgary had a very different landing spot in mind before the Flames finally moved him. Ottawa was in the mix at one point, but the Senators never had the pieces needed to complete a deal, leaving the veteran defenseman to wait for another opening as the trade market kept shifting around him.
When the move finally came on March 4, 2024, it sent Weegar to Utah, where he quickly settled into a top-four role and later locked in his future with the Mammoth through the 2030-31 season. For Utah, it was a major add on the blue line. For Ottawa, it was another reminder of how close a team can get to a difference-making defenseman without quite having the assets to finish the job. [Read more 🡒]
Senators Face A Goalie Decision As Another Lineup Concern Grows
The Senators are heading into their matchup with the Utah Mammoth carrying a couple of lineup questions, and both sit in spots that matter. Ridly Greig is dealing with a lower-body injury, while Tyler Kleven has gotten back on the ice after missing the previous game with an illness, giving Ottawa at least one encouraging sign as it prepares to host Utah.
The bigger uncertainty is in net, where the club is still sorting through Linus Ullmarks status after he continued to progress in practice. Ottawa has not had much time to settle the crease situation with another game on deck, and with Greig likely unavailable, the Senators could be forced to adjust both up front and in goal before puck drop. [Read more 🡒]