Senators Face A Captaincy Choice That Will Define The Next Era

As the Ottawa Senators weigh their options for the next team captain, anticipation builds around their crucial leadership choice.

The Ottawa Senators are still weighing their next captain, and they’re not rushing the call.

While a number of NHL teams were handing out leadership letters on Monday ahead of training camp, Ottawa stayed put on its decision after Brady Tkachuk was traded to the Florida Panthers in June for four draft picks. The Senators now sit among a group of teams still without a captain, including the Anaheim Ducks, Boston Bruins, Chicago Blackhawks, Columbus Blue Jackets, Detroit Red Wings, Los Angeles Kings, San Jose Sharks and Vancouver Canucks.

Around the league, the movement started quickly. The New York Islanders made Bo Horvat the 16th captain in franchise history, filling the spot left by Anders Lee after he signed with the Utah Mammoth as an unrestricted free agent on July 1. The Montreal Canadiens also settled part of their leadership group, naming Josh Anderson an alternate captain alongside Nick Suzuki and Mike Matheson.

Ottawa, though, is taking its time. That much was clear from what Steve Staios said last Tuesday at the club’s charity golf tournament.

“I don’t think that’s anything that we want to rush into. It’s an important decision,” Staios said.

“Yet, when I look at our group and the potential players that could be our next captain here for the Ottawa Senators, it just comes naturally to all these players that we’re talking about.”

The leading names in the mix are Thomas Chabot, Jake Sanderson and Tim Stutzle. Sanderson is viewed as the frontrunner, Chabot as the player many around the team see as the most deserving, and Stutzle as someone who should be part of the conversation because he’s ready for a bigger leadership role.

The Senators have already met with the three of them, and the word circulating in league circles is that each was told the organization would let them know soon which direction it plans to go.

There’s also been discussion about Claude Giroux potentially wearing the “C” for a year, though that idea is viewed as unlikely. At 38, Giroux is seen as the kind of veteran who leads whether or not he has a letter on his sweater.

And while Tkachuk was the emotional face of the team during his run as captain, Chabot’s influence behind the scenes has not gone unnoticed. Several people around the club believe he helped keep things steady and kept the focus on improvement where it belonged.

That showed up last year when Ottawa moved training camp to Quebec City. Chabot, whose off-season home is in Saint-Marie, organized a golf outing for teammates and hosted a dinner at his home during an off day.

In Other News...

Senators Blue Line Suddenly Has A Prospect Fans Can't Ignore

Carter Yakemchuks rise has reached the point where Ottawa no longer looks at him as just a future piece. The 20-year-old defenseman, taken seventh overall in the 2024 NHL draft, is skipping the Senators 2026 rookie camp and heading straight to main camp next week, a sign that his development has moved past the introductory stage. After spending time in the AHL and then getting his first taste of the NHL in March 2026, Yakemchuk has given the organization enough to keep him squarely in the conversation for a regular job.

His brief NHL debut came with a goal and an assist, and his playoff work only added to the intrigue around where he fits on Ottawas blue line. For a Senators team that is still sorting out its defense for 2026-27, the timing matters: Yakemchuk is no longer being discussed as a long-range project, but as someone who could force the issue in camp. Whether he leaves with an opening-night roster spot is still undecided, but the path to that outcome has become much clearer. [Read more 🡒]

Tim Sttzle Is Forcing A Bigger Senators Debate Than Ever

Tim Sttzle keeps making the Senators hierarchy harder to sort out. He was once again the top name in an annual summer ranking, holding off Jake Sanderson in a close race, and the debate around him now feels bigger than simple point totals. At this stage, Ottawa is looking at a player whose skating, puck possession and ability to draw penalties already drive so much of the offense that he has become the standard by which other core pieces are measured.

The case for Sttzle goes beyond production, even if that remains the loudest part of it after a strong season in which he piled up 34 goals and 49 assists in 80 games. He is also viewed as a strong penalty killer and backchecker, which gives the Senators plenty to like on the defensive side even if some teammates grade out better there. The real question is how high his ceiling goes from here, because the possibility of him developing into a top-five center is no longer the kind of thought Ottawa can treat as wishful thinking. [Read more 🡒]

Jaxon Cover Just Gave Senators Fans A Reason To Pay Attention

Jaxon Cover spent the rookie tournament in Gatineau making himself hard to ignore, and for Senators fans looking for an early glimpse of the next wave, he delivered one. The Ottawa prospect was involved in seven of the teams eight goals across two games, turning heads with a mix of finishing and playmaking that stood out even in a setting built for evaluation.

He capped the stretch with a game-winning goal in overtime against the Toronto Maple Leafs and followed that with a four-point outing against the Montreal Canadiens, giving Ottawa plenty to like about his offensive instincts. Coach Andrew Campbell and teammate Kasper Halttunen both singled out Covers dynamic game, and after a weekend like that, the bigger question is how much more of that upside he can show once the real tests begin. [Read more 🡒]