As we approach the final stretch of the 2025-26 NHL regular season, the playoff picture remains tantalizingly unclear. With numerous teams still battling for those coveted Wildcard spots, the question arises: which of these bubble teams could pose the biggest threat to higher seeds in the first round?
Columbus Blue Jackets: A Dark Horse Threat
Matt Larkin points to the Columbus Blue Jackets as a formidable contender. Since Rick Bowness took over in January, the Jackets have surged, boasting the sixth-best expected goals share in the league at 5-on-5.
Anchored by the dynamic defenseman Zach Werenski and rising star goaltender Jet Greaves, Columbus has both the defensive grit and offensive depth to challenge any opponent. Add in Kirill Marchenko, one of the league’s premier two-way players, and you have a team ready to make waves in the wide-open Eastern Conference.
Ottawa Senators: Riding a Wave of Confidence
Paul Pidutti highlights the Ottawa Senators, who have found their stride under Travis Green. With strong underlying metrics all season, the Sens are now coupling that with NHL-caliber goaltending.
This isn’t a team content with just making the playoffs; they're driven by the need to prove themselves after being underestimated. Ottawa brings a perfect blend of underdog spirit and determination, making them a team to watch as they push for a playoff spot.
New York Islanders: Surpassing Expectations
Steven Ellis throws the New York Islanders into the mix. Despite lacking high-end scoring, the Islanders have been one of the NHL’s best teams over the past two months.
Matthew Schaefer has been a revelation, while Mathew Barzal and Bo Horvat are playing peak hockey. With Ilya Sorokin’s ability to deliver clutch performances, the Islanders could channel their early 2020s shutdown style to become a formidable playoff opponent.
Utah Mammoth: A New Contender on the Rise
Anthony Trudeau brings attention to the Utah Mammoth, who have quietly assembled one of the league’s most balanced defensive units with the acquisition of Mackenzie Weegar. Clayton Keller and Dylan Guenther lead a potent offense, while Karel Vejmelka provides stability in goal.
Positioned to potentially face a weaker Pacific Division, the Mammoth could capitalize on matchups against teams like the struggling Vegas Golden Knights or the defensively challenged Anaheim Ducks. With the right breaks, Utah could make a surprising run to the Western Conference Final.
As the regular season winds down, these bubble teams are primed to shake up the playoffs, each bringing their unique strengths and stories to the ice. Keep an eye on them as they look to turn potential into postseason success.