The Calgary Flames’ Dustin Wolf problem isn’t really about whether he’s good enough to stay. It’s about whether his timeline still makes sense.
That’s the awkward part of a rebuild: a goalie can be exactly what a team wants and still not fit where the organization is headed. Wolf is already five years older than Zayne Parekh and Matvei Gridin, six years older than Cole Reschny and Ethan Wyttenbach, and seven years older than Carson Carels. By next April, he’ll turn 26, which could put him as many as eight years ahead of whoever Calgary takes in the 2027 NHL draft.
Wolf was drafted seven years ago, back in the 2019 class that included Jack Hughes, Bowen Byram, Cole Caufield and Moritz Seider. Those are players who are now established NHLers in their prime. Calgary, meanwhile, is staring at a rebuild that looks like it could stretch well beyond the short term.
The hard truth is that most successful NHL rebuilds take about seven to 10 years to go from the basement to contender status. For the Flames, that likely means a couple more seasons near the bottom of the standings and picking in the top 10, maybe even the top five.
That isn’t a criticism of Craig Conroy or the organization. It’s just where the club is right now.
There are some young pieces already in the mix, including Matthew Coronato and Hunter Brzustewicz, but the next true contention group is expected to be built around the newer wave of draftees. That starts with Parekh and Gridin, both taken in 2024. Calgary still doesn’t appear to have its franchise forward in the pipeline yet, though that kind of player is supposed to arrive next summer.
Wolf’s seven-year, $52.5-million US contract, which begins this coming season, runs him through age 33. So the issue isn’t that Calgary can’t keep him. It’s that the team could end up spending his best years waiting for the rest of the roster to catch up.
That puts Wolf in an uncomfortable middle ground between the Brad Treliving era and the Conroy rebuild. He was too young to help push the previous core over the top, and now he may be too old for the next one.
He could still be a starting goalie for a long time. But the longer Calgary lingers in the desert, the more that risk grows.
So what does the club do with that?
One path is to speed things up and try to make the rebuild shorter. That’s the ideal outcome, but it’s a lot easier to say than to pull off.
The Sharks offer a useful reminder. San Jose drafted William Eklund seventh overall in 2021, then got Macklin Celebrini with the top pick in 2023.
They also added prospects such as Will Smith, Sam Dickinson and Michael Misa. Even with Celebrini turning into a superstar before age 20, the Sharks still finished 24th last season with 86 points, five years into their rebuild.
Ivar Stenberg, taken second overall in June, might help, but they still look like they’re at least two seasons from competing.
Anaheim’s path has been longer. The Ducks started stocking up on top-10 picks with Trevor Zegras in 2019, then spent six straight seasons near the bottom before finally reaching the playoffs in 2025-26 with 92 points.
Leo Carlsson and Beckett Sennecke helped drive that climb. They’re on the rise, but they’re not there yet.
The Canadiens might be the best model for Calgary, at least in theory. Montreal blended older holdovers from earlier eras like Caufield, Nick Suzuki and Kaiden Guhle with younger additions from the newer rebuild in Juraj Slafkovsky, Lane Hutson and Ivan Demidov.
But there’s an obvious difference. Suzuki and Caufield are true stars, and Calgary doesn’t have that kind of prime-aged centerpiece. Hutson and Demidov also made an immediate impact as rookies, and that’s still something the Flames are waiting to see from their own young group.
For Wolf’s sake, the Flames probably need to be competitive again within the next three seasons. Right now, that doesn’t look likely unless a Celebrini, or a Hutson and Demidov type of arrival, shows up sooner than expected.
And if the rebuild drags on long enough, there’s one more possibility to keep in mind: trading Wolf. It’s not a move Calgary needs to make now, but if the contention window still looks five or more years away by the start of 2027, moving him could become the practical choice, even if it’s a tough one to swallow.
In Other News...
Drake Batherson Just Became Ottawas Biggest Contract Decision
Drake Batherson is back on the Senators contract radar as Ottawa and the winger have begun extension talks heading into the final year of his current deal. It is a familiar kind of summer business for a team trying to keep its core intact, especially for a player who has given the club strong value relative to his contract and remains open to staying in Ottawa.
Batherson has said he would like to get something done this summer, which is exactly why the situation carries more weight than a routine negotiation. The Senators would like to avoid letting the matter drift into the season, but for now the sides are still feeling out where the fit is on a new deal, and the longer it goes, the more this one starts to look like a defining decision for the franchise. [Read more 🡒]
Travis Green Thinks Ottawa Took A Real Step Toward Contending
After the Senators were swept out of the first round by Carolina, Travis Green did not sound like a coach trying to spin a disappointing finish into something shiny. He talked instead about a team that spent the season building something sturdier, leaning on its identity, handling injuries and other adversity, and finding ways to stay together long enough to earn a playoff berth. Ottawas season ended sooner than anyone in the room wanted, but Green framed the year as a meaningful step for a club that finished ninth in the league and still showed real growth.
Greens bigger point was about where this group sits on the long road back to true contention. He said the Senators are closer to winning a Stanley Cup now than they were when he first arrived, a sign that progress is being measured not just by results, but by how the team has learned to respond when things get difficult. For a fan base that has waited through plenty of false starts, the challenge now is turning that confidence and identity into something that lasts well beyond one encouraging season. [Read more 🡒]