Brady Tkachuk Just Reignited A Trade Debate Senators Fans Can't Ignore

Brady Tkachuk breaks his scoring drought in dramatic fashion, aided by brother Matthew, as the pair set a new NHL record together.

Brady Tkachuk ended a quiet stretch in a hurry Tuesday night, and he did it in a way that made NHL history.

Against the Columbus Blue Jackets, Tkachuk snapped a 10-game point drought by scoring three times in the second period, ripping off a natural hat trick over 8:03. Every one of those goals came with help from his brother, Matthew, who assisted on all three.

Per the NHL, that made them the first brothers to ever do that.

Afterward, Brady acknowledged the dry spell had gotten to him since joining the Panthers. He said he felt like he wasn’t doing his job, but he never lost faith that the scoring would come. Getting that kind of support from Matthew, he said, was “pretty special,” and now it’s on him to start “returning the favor.”

"For sure felt that pressure. … Felt like I wasn't doing my job and wasn't good enough but knew eventually it was going to come."

-Brady Tkachuk after notching a hat trick in his new Panthers threads 🗣️ pic.twitter.com/oNMtROx8En

  • ESPN (@espn) October 14, 2026

It was one of those nights that can reset the conversation fast. Ten straight games without a point had started to look like a real concern, but three goals in a single period changes that instantly. Brady has the kind of skill and stubborn edge that makes a scoring burst feel inevitable sooner or later - and Tuesday, sooner arrived.

The result also keeps the Ottawa side of the story impossible to ignore. The Senators are 5-2 to open the season without their former captain, and they’ve done it while scoring 21 goals and allowing 19.

That margin suggests some good fortune, but the record still stands as a strong opening seven games. Ottawa used to lean heavily on Brady for offense and leadership, and now it’s operating more as a committee effort.

That doesn’t mean the Senators won’t feel his absence over the course of the season. His scoring and physical game will matter at times. Still, the front office made the move, and at least in the short term, the results are hard to knock.

The bigger answer on the deal won’t come for a while. Brady has rediscovered the score sheet with Matthew feeding him pucks, while Ottawa has started the year well without him. The real judgment comes later, once the schedule tightens and the Panthers need the move to hold up across a full season.

Florida had extra incentive for Tkachuk to find his game quickly. With Aleksander Barkov and Brad Marchand injured, the Panthers needed him to deliver. If he keeps producing, they’ll be glad they made the trade when they did.

In Other News...

Senators Rough Night At Home Just Raised A Bigger Concern

A three-game winning streak disappeared in a hurry at home Tuesday night, and the Senators never found much of a foothold in a 7-2 loss to the St. Louis Blues. Ottawas offense was limited to goals from Claude Giroux and Fabian Zetterlund, part of a night in which the club generated only 17 shots and spent too much time chasing the game.

The bigger concern, though, was at the other end, where Samuel Ersson made his first home start for Ottawa and was quickly overwhelmed. The backup goaltender gave up seven goals on 26 shots, leaving the Senators with an unsettling result that went well beyond a single bad outing and into the kind of performance that can start asking harder questions about the overall direction of the team. [Read more 🡒]

Ottawa Letting Leevi Merilainen Go Looks Tougher By The Week

Leevi Merilainen keeps giving Vancouver a reason to lean on him, and the latest example came in a game against the New York Islanders. With Thatcher Demko sidelined, the young goaltender stepped into a bigger role and helped keep the Canucks competitive even after they gave up two quick goals late in the first period.

Merilainen finished with 35 saves as Vancouver clawed back to tie it in the second period before the Islanders pulled away in the third. For Ottawa, which let Merilainen get away, the early returns keep making that decision look harder to justify each time he gets a meaningful chance to play. [Read more 🡒]

Flyers Blue Line Still Has A Problem As Injuries Keep Lingering

In a stretch where injuries keep reshaping lineups across the Atlantic Division, the Senators are watching their own health picture closely after Ridly Greig exited a recent game with a strain. Ottawa has not offered a firm update on his status, which adds another layer of uncertainty at a time when the club is already tracking absences elsewhere around the division, including Buffalo being without Rasmus Dahlin, Tyson Kozak and Alex Lyon for its next game against Toronto.

For Ottawa, Greigs availability matters because he has been a regular part of the mix this season, taking on meaningful minutes and contributing in a supporting role. The concern now is less about one game than about whether the Senators will be able to keep their forward group intact as Philadelphia continues to deal with blue-line injuries and the ripple effects of these lineup holes keep growing. [Read more 🡒]