Paolo Banchero has spent the offseason getting picked apart, and the criticism has not exactly been subtle.
His counting numbers were solid enough last season - 22.2 points per game, a career-high 8.4 rebounds per game and 45.9 percent shooting - but the Orlando Magic still finished 26-25 in the 51 games Franz Wagner essentially missed. After a seven-game win streak in March, the Magic slipped back into the Play-In. For a player whose value is supposed to show up in the win column, that left Banchero with more questions than answers.
That is the tension hanging over him now. He is not the kind of star who gets treated like a full-blown lightning rod, but he is absolutely the kind of player people bring up when the stats and the impact do not seem to line up. That has even led to chatter about whether Orlando would consider trading him to get ahead of the problem.
Instead, the pressure is squarely on Banchero to answer it on the floor. He appears to know it, too.
The hair is different this summer - back to the fade in workout videos and at his high school elite camp - and he also looks slimmer. Of course, workout videos can flatter anybody.
The real evaluation is still coming.
A lot of the pushback on Banchero has centered on the numbers that go beyond the box score. Critics have pointed to his on/off impact and efficiency for a high-usage player.
The Magic have never had a positive net rating with him on the floor, though DataBallr adjusts that -0.2 overall to +0.2 when low-leverage minutes are removed. That has fed the broader analytics-versus-eyeball debate around him.
Michael Pina of The Ringer put Banchero first in his “Jaylen Brown All-Stars” list of players whose production and perception do not quite match.
"At 23 years old, Banchero has mostly played on injury-depleted teams, in lineups that can’t space the floor, under a coach he didn’t vibe with," Pina wrote. "How can someone watch Game 5 of Orlando’s first-round series against the No. 1 seed Detroit Pistons and not see special qualities in the guy who needed 31 shots to score 45 points? Most of that series can be viewed as an instructive reminder of Banchero’s potential."
That playoff run is part of why the conversation is not so simple. Banchero’s 45-point Game 5 and 37-point Game 7 were hard to ignore, even if Game 6’s 4-for-20 night was sitting there in the background.
He has also drawn comparisons to Cade Cunningham, though Cunningham’s on/off numbers have been more favorable. Banchero, for his part, posted a better true shooting percentage than Cunningham this year, and Cunningham had his own rough early stretch.
There is still plenty of belief left in Banchero’s future, especially because he is only entering his age-24 season. Patience is still part of the equation. So is execution.
The Magic are entering a season that feels significant in its own right, with Sean Sweeney taking over as coach and the hope that a new voice can unlock more from the roster. Orlando is also hoping for better injury luck, because last season’s version of the team never got a clean look.
Banchero’s health matters here, too. Since tearing his oblique, he has not always looked fully like himself, and it has taken time for him to get back into rhythm. Still, the stretches when he takes over in big games show exactly why the upside remains real.
Zach Lowe summed up the challenge on The Zach Lowe Show:
"For him and the Magic to advance to the next level, he has to bottle more of the efficiency that defines those best nights which means probably taking fewer jump shots or getting better at shooting long 2s and 3s," Zach Lowe said on The Zach Lowe Show. "Because he takes too many of both and also getting more comfortable -- and th shooting is a part of this -- not playing the No. 1 option role all the time because you have anothe really good player in Franz Wagner. I think people are sleeping on teh Magic as a top-six team in the East next year."
To Banchero’s credit, he already cut down on long 2s and 3s in the 2026 season compared with 2025. The next step is bigger than shot selection, though. Orlando needs a real efficiency jump, not just a cleaner profile.
The signs that leap is possible are already there. In the five games before his oblique injury in 2025, Banchero averaged 29.0 points, 8.8 rebounds and 5.6 assists per game with a 55.2 percent effective field goal percentage. That stretch included his first career 50-point game and three 30-point games.
He also finished strongly after the All-Star break in 2025, averaging 29.0 points per game with a 58.3 percent true shooting percentage. During that run, the Magic posted a +4.8 net rating with him on the floor.
A year earlier after the All-Star break, Banchero averaged 23.6 points per game with a 57.7 percent true shooting percentage, and Orlando had a +3.1 net rating.
That is the version of Banchero the Magic are chasing now - the one who can tilt games more consistently, not just flash in them. The league has spent all summer questioning whether he is being overrated or underrated. The answer may come down to whether he can turn those bursts into something the Magic can count on.
In Other News...
Sean Sweeney Inherits A Costly Magic Lineup Full Of Tough Calls
The Magics roster for next season is almost locked in, and that leaves first-year head coach Sean Sweeney stepping into a situation with very little wiggle room. Orlando already has 13 of 14 contracts guaranteed, with Paolo Banchero, Franz Wagner and Jalen Suggs at the center of a group that is built to win now, not experiment later. With the club also expected to pay the luxury tax for the first time since 2010-11, every decision around the edges carries extra weight.
Jamal Cain is the lone player still on a non-guaranteed deal, but the bigger issue is how Sweeney sorts out a lineup and rotation that already looks crowded with talent. The projected starting five of Suggs, Bane, Banchero, Wagner and Carter gives the Magic plenty of size and scoring options, yet it also leaves the first-year coach with several tough calls about roles, minutes and how to keep a high-priced roster functioning cleanly. [Read more 🡒]
Magic Face One Defining Question About Paolo Banchero And Franz Wagner
The biggest question hanging over Orlando right now is not about talent, but fit. Paolo Banchero and Franz Wagner are both young enough and good enough to anchor the Magic for years, yet the real test will be whether they can function as a true leading duo when the games get tight and the postseason gets harder. Around the team, there is already a sense that the front office took a cautious approach this offseason, leaving the roster largely intact rather than making the kind of bold swing that might have shifted the conversation.
Don Strouble recently framed the issue in a way that matches what many around the league already suspect: Orlando is unlikely to part with either Banchero or Wagner, given their value and team-friendly contracts. If the Magic do eventually make a notable move, the focus may turn elsewhere on the roster, where Jalen Suggs has become the most plausible trade discussion point because of both his situation and how the backcourt is expected to function. For now, though, the central tension remains the same, whether Orlandos best players can mesh well enough to push the franchise beyond the first round. [Read more 🡒]
Nikola Vucevic Reunion Puts Magic Frontcourt Depth In Focus
The Magics offseason frontcourt shuffle has brought a familiar name back into the fold, with Nikola Vucevic returning on a one-year deal as Orlando continues to reshape its roster around more size and depth. Alongside additions like Jevon Carter and Jonathan Isaac, the move gives the team another veteran option in the middle and a player who knows the organization well from his earlier run in Orlando.
Vucevic arrives after a season that included stops with the Bulls and Celtics, and he still produced as a steady interior presence, averaging 15.1 points and 8.4 rebounds. For the Magic, the appeal is clear: he can help stabilize the bench unit and give the frontcourt another experienced body, but how much of a nightly role he claims will be one of the more interesting questions as the season takes shape. [Read more 🡒]