The Orlando Magic’s biggest offseason question has nothing to do with Anthony Black’s play. It has everything to do with the bill.
Black’s breakout season made the case for a serious payday. He averaged 15.0 points per game and helped carry the team through December and January, which is why his next contract has become such a complicated piece of business for Orlando.
On talent alone, he looks like a player the Magic would want to lock in. On the cap sheet, he’s running straight into a wall.
That’s the reality now. Under the old system, this would have been a straightforward extension conversation.
The new NBA rules have turned every decision into a balancing act, and Orlando is feeling the squeeze more than most. The Magic have already loaded up on major deals, and that approach has left the front office with very little room to maneuver.
Jeff Weltman had warned that the future would be more expensive, but Orlando still operated for a while like a team living in the previous era. The Magic handed out big extensions to the players they drafted, then added more big money for Jonathan Isaac and Wendell Carter.
Their two max contracts came with little effort or fanfare, and that drew criticism around the league at the time. Now the consequences are showing up in real time.
Black sits right in the middle of that mess. His value has been discussed anywhere from the optimistically low $20 million annual average value to a number closer to what Jalen Suggs received.
That gap matters, because it points toward a deal that may not happen until next summer, when Black could reach restricted free agency. Jake Fischer said on his livestream show on Bleacher/Report that the Magic have to figure out how to fit Jalen Suggs and Anthony Black together on their cap sheet, though there is some optimism a deal can still get done.
The broader problem is the way the league works now. The NBA’s old soft cap came with tax penalties, but contenders could usually pay to keep their own.
The aprons changed that. Being too far over the tax line now brings roster-building restrictions, plus the financial hit.
That has made homegrown players more expensive faster than teams are used to, and it has forced front offices to think in a different language.
Orlando built itself the old way. The Magic drafted well, paid their own, and treated that as the point of success.
Weltman earned a reputation for taking care of his players, and when he finally pushed in on a major trade for Desmond Bane, he knew he was diving headfirst into the luxury tax. Now that approach is coming due, and Black may be the one caught in the middle.
As Sam Vecenie put it on Game Theory: "If I am the Magic, I really want to keep Anthony Black. But my cap sheet is an absolute mess.
There is just not another way to put it," Sam Vecenie noted on Game Theory. "I have three guys making over $40 million in 2027-28.
I have Jalen Suggs making about $30 million. I have Wendell Carter making about $20 million.
And no one else on the books outside of Tristan da Silva, Jase Richardson and Noah Penda. They only have, against the tax, $18 million in tax space already for next year with like eight guys on the roster.
And not including Anthony Black, who is going to make more than $18 million next year."
That is the bind Orlando created for itself. The Magic did what rebuilding teams are supposed to do: draft quality players and invest in them.
In the old NBA, maybe that was enough. In this one, every commitment narrows the next one.
It’s why Jalen Duren is stuck in a contract standoff with the Detroit Pistons. It’s why Victor Wembanyama did not take the full Rose Rule max contract that Paolo Banchero took. It’s why Amen Thompson is the only other player from that draft class to sign an extension, with few others expected to land new deals.
Everyone is trying to save money now. Orlando is no exception.
None of this changes Black’s value, and it doesn’t make him the problem. If he feels a little singled out while the Magic play hardball, that would make sense. But the team has to live with the consequences of not adjusting sooner to the new cap world.
Somebody on this roster is going to pay for it, whether that comes through a trade to trim payroll or through some other move to clean up the books. Orlando simply cannot keep Black without cutting somewhere else first.
For now, the Magic will spend this season trying to figure out exactly what this group is. They brought a lot of players back to gather more information, and they should have enough time to make smarter decisions after that.
The most likely outcome is still a clean relationship with Black and a resolution that doesn’t turn ugly. Orlando has usually been good about taking care of its own, so this probably won’t become the kind of drawn-out situation other teams dealt with this summer.
But the number has to make sense. Black should be aiming for an average annual value in the $23-25 million range, and the Magic need to hold their line while also deciding what else has to move to make the math work.
That’s the new world Orlando has stepped into. And now the tough calls are unavoidable.
In Other News...
Sean Sweeney Faces Early Pressure With A Playoff-Ready Magic Team
Sean Sweeneys first months on the job have come with the kind of expectations that usually follow a coach who inherits a roster already built to win. Named the Orlando Magics head coach several months ago after a long run as an assistant, Sweeney steps into his first top job with a team that looks playoff-ready and eager to make the next jump. The resume that got him here is rooted in the details of assistant work, but the task now is broader: steer a group with real ambitions and shape it into something more polished on both ends of the floor.
For the Magic, the early emphasis will be on sharpening a defensive identity that already matters to them while creating better offensive spacing to support the rest of the roster. Those are familiar themes for a team trying to move from promising to dangerous, and they also explain why the learning curve around a first-time head coach will matter right away. Sweeney brings philosophies that helped earn him the chance, but the next phase will be about how quickly those ideas translate once the games start carrying real weight. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks Are Showing What The Magic Still Need To Prove
The Magic have spent this season measuring themselves against a familiar standard, and the Knicks keep showing up as the cleanest one. Orlandos rise has been built on size, length and the idea that those traits can travel in big games, but New York has a way of testing whether that blueprint is ready for the hardest stage. With Paolo Banchero and Franz Wagner leading the way, the Magic have shown enough to belong in the conversation, and their work in the NBA Cup has only reinforced that this group is no longer just trying to get there.
What still separates Orlando from the leagues more established contenders is the part that only shows up in repeated matchups and playoff pressure. The recent games and series against the Knicks have served as a useful measuring stick, because New York has answered with the kind of consistency the Magic are still trying to prove they can match. For Orlando, the lesson is less about one result than about how far the team has to go before its own identity stops being a promising theory and starts looking like a finished product. [Read more 🡒]
Magic Face A Risky Win-Now Choice That Could Change Everything
The early-season tone around Orlando could determine whether the front office stays patient with its young core or starts chasing something much bigger. Jalen Suggs has become part of the defensive backbone that gives the Magic their identity, but the idea floating around the league is whether the team would ever consider moving him for Kyrie Irving, a proven scorer with championship experience and a very different kind of ceiling.
For a team trying to take the next step, the appeal is obvious. Irving brings shot-making and late-game juice that can change a playoff series, but a deal like that would also ask Orlando to sacrifice the kind of edge and versatility it has spent years building. It is the sort of win-now swing that only comes into focus if the Magic stumble early, and even then it would force a hard conversation about what kind of team they want to be. [Read more 🡒]