Oklahoma State’s 41-24 road win over West Virginia sent the Cowboys into the national conversation, and the reaction from prominent college football voices was quick to follow. Across several major podcasts, the same themes kept popping up: Oklahoma State looks real, Drew Mestemaker is turning heads, and the Big 12 race is starting to feel wide open.
Josh Pate put the Cowboys in his winners group and didn’t waste time getting to the point. He said, “Mestemaker did what he needed to do,” and added, “Caleb Hawkins did what he needed to do.
They are a legit Big 12 contender. Like, they’re loss - this is gonna be one of those weird things you say at the end of the year - their loss is to Tulsa.
So, that’s not a conference game, so they’re still undefeated there. …
“They got an NFL quarterback. They have some big-time players.”
Pate also flagged Texas Tech’s Nov. 14 trip to Stillwater as a game he’s already circling.
Brandon Walker and Liam Blutman also spent time on the Cowboys during their late-night Saturday recap. Walker leaned into the momentum around Oklahoma State, saying, “You want to talk about a who’s back?
I mean they already beat Oregon, but now Oklahoma State,” before praising the way the Cowboys handled an unbeaten West Virginia team on the road. He called Mestemaker’s early-season arc strange, noting, “it’s bizarre how little he showed in Week 1, and it’s bizarre how incredible he has been since.
Week 2, 3 and 4, he has been one of the five best quarterbacks in the country, and today he was no different.”
Blutman offered a different angle, suggesting the Tulsa loss may wind up being irrelevant if Oklahoma State ends up winning the Big 12.
On Cover 3, the discussion turned to where the Cowboys might land in the updated AP Poll, and Chip Patterson said the ranking made sense. “Oklahoma State, into the Top 25,” Patterson said.
“Maybe should’ve been already, but you’ve got a win against Oregon. Loss against Tulsa is gonna be an anchor, but good job in an impressive win, pulling away in the second half.
A good second-half performance from that Oklahoma State offense.”
The conversation on Bussin’ With The Boys centered on the Big 12 looking more like a full-blown fight at the top than expected. Will Compton and Taylor Lewan also made clear they still view West Virginia as a solid team, but Lewan shifted quickly to Oklahoma State.
“But Oklahoma State, man, I’ll tell you what, that quarterback, he nice,” Lewan said. “This is a nice little ball club out there.
Their defensive line is good, too. They’re older, they’re more established, they know what they’re doing, like Stillwater’s got themselves a little ball club right now.”
Lewan said Oklahoma State’s Oct. 17 trip to Houston should tell everyone plenty about this team, and Compton pointed to the offense’s recent production. “Over their last three games, they are close to averaging 600 yards of total offense,” Compton said.
“Like, they are tough, man. Oklahoma State is playing some tough ball out there in the Big 12.”
Andy and Ari from On3 also weighed in on whether the Cowboys belong in the Big 12 title picture. Wasserman said they could, and he tied that conversation to Oregon’s win over USC in Los Angeles. “Obviously as this season progresses, if what we saw out of Oregon is an indication of what the Ducks are gonna be moving forward that, that game and that win is going to age like fine wine,” Wasserman said.
In Other News...
Oregon State Is Getting Respect But This Road Test Still Feels Tricky
Oregon State heads into Week 4 of the 2026-27 college football season with a little more outside confidence than it might have expected on the road, as multiple betting models and national projections lean in the Beavers favor against Colorado State. The range of forecasts is broad enough to leave room for caution, but it still speaks to a team getting real respect from the market as it prepares for a tricky trip.
Even so, the matchup does not read like a runaway. The numbers suggest a competitive game, and the expectation is that Oregon State will need to lean on its passing attack to create separation against a Colorado State team capable of making things uncomfortable at home. For the Beavers, the question is less about whether they belong in the conversation and more about how cleanly they can translate that edge into a road win. [Read more 🡒]
Oregon States Freshman Receiver Is Raising Expectations Fast
Jesse Legree has gone from little-known newcomer to one of the most intriguing young pass catchers in the Pac-12 almost immediately. The true freshman at Oregon State has piled up 22 catches for 585 yards and six touchdowns, while earning Pac-12 freshman of the week honors each of the first four weeks and landing freshman All-American recognition along the way.
What has made the start especially notable is how quickly Legree has forced his way into the national conversation at his position. Entering Pac-12 play, he ranked second among freshmen in receiving yards and was tied for fourth in touchdown catches, all while continuing to raise the bar for what a first-year receiver can do in Corvallis. [Read more 🡒]