The first College Football Playoff rankings of the season are out, and they already have the sport buzzing because they do not line up neatly with the AP Top 25.
Miami sits at No. 1 in the AP poll, and that part is hard to argue with. In a season where there are so few undefeated teams this deep into the year, the Hurricanes have earned the spot by looking every bit the part. Whether this is finally Mario’s moment remains to be seen, but for now Miami has the top line all to itself.
The AP’s other unbeaten teams are Utah at No. 3 and UCLA at No. 5.
That kind of placement has long been a sore spot for anyone who thinks undefeated Power 4 teams ought to be sitting at the top of the board without much debate. The usual arguments about strength of schedule and quality wins never seem to end, but the basic case is simple enough: if those teams are undefeated, why not rank them higher and let the games sort it out?
Georgia leads the one-loss group at No. 3, which feels right. Behind the Bulldogs in that category are Notre Dame at No.
4, Indiana at No. 6, BYU at No. 7, and Kentucky at No.
- Farther down the list are the rest of the one-loss teams: Texas Tech, Wake Forest, Boise State, and New Mexico.
The AP also has a cluster of two-loss teams from the SEC near the top, with Alabama at No. 9, Texas at No. 10, and Ole Miss at No. 12, plus a two-loss Ohio State team mixed in there as well.
Alabama’s losses came against Georgia and Tennessee. Texas fell to unranked Oklahoma and unranked No.
25 Florida. Ole Miss lost to Florida and Texas.
Alabama at No. 9 is one thing, but the rest of that group being ranked ahead of one-loss teams like Texas Tech, Wake Forest, and Boise State is where the skepticism comes in.
The AP also includes two three-loss SEC teams in No. 23 South Carolina and No. 25 Florida, which only adds to the sense that preseason reputation continues to carry weight long after the season starts.
The CFP rankings, though, tell a slightly different story.
Notre Dame’s fall stands out immediately. Even with a built-in skepticism toward the Irish, the drop is still striking. The committee clearly sees something it wants to challenge there, and the result is a much steeper slide than the AP gave them.
The SEC, meanwhile, appears to be climbing in the committee’s eyes, while B1G teams like Ohio State, UCLA, and USC were pushed down. That alone is enough to make the first playoff ranking feel familiar in all the usual ways.
But the most interesting name on the board is Oregon.
The Ducks are the ranking that really stops you. An Oregon team that looks, in this view, like it “clearly sucks” is still in the mix, and the committee’s decision makes more sense when you remember how this first ranking usually works.
The playoff committee has been consistent over the past two seasons in using the opening set of rankings to show what remains possible, not just to reward what has already happened. There is always some first-week oddity, and there is always some built-in bias, but the bigger message is about the road still available.
That is the point with Oregon. The Ducks are being told they still have a path, however slim.
Win out, and they are alive. It sounds simple because it is simple.
So for now, the first ranking is more of a map than a verdict. And if Oregon beats Ohio State on Saturday, then the conversation gets a lot more interesting.
In Other News...
Oregon Faces A Dangerous New Ohio State Quarterback Test
Ohio State is turning to freshman quarterback Luke Fahey for his first home start, and the timing could hardly be more interesting for Oregon. Fahey already got a taste of the job on the road against USC after an injury pushed him into the lineup, and he responded by completing 21 of 38 passes for 260 yards and a touchdown. Now the No. 23 Ducks are headed into a different kind of test, with a young quarterback who has already shown he can handle pressure in a big setting.
Both Ryan Day and Dan Lanning have weighed in on Faheys performance and upside, which says plenty about how closely this matchup is being watched. For Oregon, the challenge is not just facing a new starter, but facing one with a live arm, a little confidence and the benefit of home field behind him. The Ducks will have to sort out quickly whether Faheys first impression was a one-off spark or the start of something more dangerous. [Read more 🡒]
Dan Lanning Explains Why Oregons O-Line Suddenly Looks More Settled
Oregons offensive line finally looked like a group that had spent some time together, and the timing mattered in a 34-26 win over Northwestern. For the first time this season, the Ducks rolled out the same starting five in back-to-back games, and the result was a cleaner operation up front, with strong yardage production and no penalties from the unit.
Dan Lanning said the line is still a work in progress because injuries and competition have kept the group in flux, but he liked the steadiness and attention to fundamentals from the current mix. The Ducks have had to adapt around the absences of Trent Ferguson and Immanuel Iheanacho, and that flexibility remains part of the equation even as the line starts to settle into a more dependable shape. [Read more 🡒]
Oregon Faces Early Recruiting Test For Priority Receiver Target
The early recruiting calendar is already putting Hayden Koo on the road, and Oregon is right in the middle of it. The four-star Class of 2028 wide receiver has lined up November visits to Washington, Oregon, Cal and Ohio State, giving the Ducks a chance to make an impression before the process gets much deeper.
Oregon will get Koo on campus Nov. 14 for the Michigan game, while Ohio State will host him later in the month. For the Ducks, the timing matters, since Koo is viewed as a priority target and Oregon has leaned on its track record of playing young receivers to help sell the program to elite pass catchers. [Read more 🡒]