Todd McShay floated the kind of quarterback debate that can take over a draft cycle. On the Aug. 18 edition of the Brandon Walker College Football Show, the draft analyst drew a line between Dante Moore and Fernando Mendoza, saying Mendoza looked ready to play right away while Moore carried the higher ceiling.
Mendoza settled the question quickly in his own way. He left Indiana after a season that became one for the ages, turned a national championship and Heisman Trophy into the No. 1 overall pick, and is now taking snaps for the Las Vegas Raiders.
Moore, meanwhile, chose to return to the No. 2 Oregon Ducks for his senior season, keeping his own path pointed toward the 2027 NFL draft.
That decision puts Moore back in position to chase the kind of rise McShay was talking about. The challenge is clear: he has to turn talent into a season that looks less like promise and more like a top-overall selection.
Mendoza’s case was built on a breathtaking final year. He threw for 3,535 yards, completed 72 percent of his passes and led the nation with 41 touchdowns. For a Raiders team looking for stability, his accuracy, poise and ball security made him the safer bet.
Moore’s profile is different, and that’s what makes him so intriguing. In his first full year as Oregon’s starter against Power Four competition, he threw for 3,565 yards, 30 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. That gave him 30 more passing yards than Mendoza, but also 11 fewer touchdowns and four more interceptions.
The raw tools still jump off the page. Moore has the arm strength, athleticism and play-making ability that make scouts stop and pay attention. What he has to show now is that those traits can carry an entire season at the highest level.
The biggest hurdle is the big-game stage. Oregon went 13-2 in 2025 with Moore at the controls, but both losses came against Mendoza and eventual champion Indiana, once in the regular season and again in the CFP semifinal. Mendoza, the former Cal Bear, is 3-0 all-time against Moore going back to Moore’s freshman year at UCLA.
Now Moore has to do it with some turnover around him. Oregon is down three starters on the offensive line from last season, and tight end Kenyon Sadiq, who posted 560 yards and eight touchdowns, is now with the New York Jets.
That group has to be cleaned up before the Ducks’ Nov. 7 road game at No. 1 Ohio State.
Even with a roster full of elite talent, this is the part where Moore has to become the face of the team. Mendoza had four years to get to near perfection. Moore has the chance to match that level in just his second full season as Oregon’s signal caller.
He is not just chasing Oregon’s first national title or a Heisman Trophy. He’s trying to move from excellent to superstar, and that means producing the kind of plays people remember long after the season ends.
Mendoza had one of those moments in the title game, when he put his body on the line with an outstretched touchdown for the ages. Moore needs his own image like that - a national-stage play that makes the whole country hold its breath at once.
That’s the burden and the opportunity waiting for him in Eugene. Mendoza climbed to No. 1 on the strength of a Cinderella run that felt almost impossible.
Moore does not get that same underdog script. He has to create his own, with championship and Heisman expectations already hanging over him.
For now, he’s back at Oregon with a ceiling to punch through. The pressure would be different in an NFL camp, where the next quarterback off the board in the 2026 NFL draft was Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson, who went to the Los Angeles Rams at No. 13 overall. Moore’s road is still ahead of him.
In Other News...
Arch Manning Enters A Draft Race Texas Fans Need To Watch
The 2027 NFL Draft quarterback class is already drawing plenty of attention, and for fans around the Ducks, the names near the top will feel familiar. ESPNs Jordan Reid sees a deep group led by Arch Manning, CJ Carr, Dante Moore and Julian Sayin, with Moore projected to the Browns at No. 1 and Manning going next to the Cardinals.
Todd McShay, though, has been a little less bullish on Mannings placement, even while he still views Moore as the favorite to hear his name first. McShay has pointed to Moores overall season as the edge, despite some uneven moments in bigger games, which only adds to the early intrigue around a quarterback race that could shape the top of the draft. [Read more 🡒]
Tommy Tofis Oregon Start Says Plenty About This Program
Tommy Tofis arrival in Eugene says as much about Oregons recruiting and development model as it does about the freshman offensive lineman himself. The son of former UTEP basketball player and pro athlete John Tofi, Tommy came in as a highly rated prospect and has already turned heads with the way he handled Oregons spring game and carried that momentum into fall camp, where the Ducks have given him a setting that seems designed to bring young players along quickly.
For the Tofi family, the fit has been part of the appeal. Tommys older brother, John Jr., is a tight end at Cal, so football runs deep in the household, but Oregons welcoming atmosphere and emphasis on player development have stood out enough to make an impression. For a freshman lineman trying to carve out a role, that kind of environment can matter just as much as talent, and it helps explain why his start has drawn attention inside a program that continues to sell both opportunity and support. [Read more 🡒]
Oregon Faces Mario Cristobal In A Huge Recruiting Fight
Oregons 2028 recruiting board already has a headliner, and it starts with Chicago edge rusher Kameron McGee, widely viewed as the nations top overall player in the class. The Ducks have had McGee on campus and are working to stay firmly in the mix as they angle for one of the most coveted prospects in the country, with Texas and Georgia also pushing hard.
Miami adds another layer to the chase because the Hurricanes are led by Mario Cristobal, whose presence will be familiar to Oregon fans after his time in Eugene. For the Ducks, this is the kind of early heavyweight battle that can shape a recruiting class, and much of their pitch now will come from what they can show McGee during the upcoming season. [Read more 🡒]