College football keeps redrawing its borders, but Dan Lanning still wants one line left untouched: once a player goes pro, that’s it for college.
The Oregon coach pushed back hard this week as a Louisiana judge’s temporary restraining order created a path for some players who have signed professional contracts - including players currently on NFL rosters - to regain college eligibility. CBS Sports reported that the order blocks the NCAA, for now, from enforcing rules that would keep the athletes in the lawsuit from returning after signing those contracts.
The names in the case make the whole thing feel even stranger. Tampa Bay Buccaneers edge rusher Jack Pyburn and Cleveland Browns tight end Dae'Quan Wright are among the players involved, and Wright even entered the NCAA transfer portal while still on Cleveland's roster.
Lanning’s view was blunt.
"I think there are a lot of negatives involved around this," Lanning said.
His biggest objection is philosophical, but it’s also practical. In his mind, signing a pro deal should close the college chapter.
"One, once you go to the NFL, to me, you're in the NFL," Lanning said. "You don't get the opportunity to come back."
The legal fight in Louisiana comes on top of another recent Colorado case that opened the door for members of the 2022 high school recruiting class who had used up their eligibility after four straight seasons to potentially get a fifth year. Together, the cases point to an eligibility landscape that keeps getting messier.
CBS Sports reported that people around college football are already bracing for more lawsuits, especially from players who signed NFL contracts but could be cut as teams trim rosters before the regular season.
That’s where Lanning says the issue gets especially messy for programs trying to manage their own teams.
College rosters are capped at 105 players, and schools have spent the offseason building around that limit. If a player were allowed back from the NFL in late August, somebody else would have to make room. CBS Sports reported that the Louisiana order did not eliminate the 105-player roster restriction, leaving schools that want to add players to figure out where the space comes from.
For Lanning, that’s the part that crosses the line.
"Two, most of us have built our rosters, and you have a limited roster now," Lanning said. "So if you invited somebody back to your team, that means you're kicking somebody else off your team to match your roster limits. I don't think that's fair to the players who worked all summer, all spring and put themselves in position to be ready to work for a team."
There’s also an obvious football reason the idea has appeal. If an experienced player with NFL-caliber talent suddenly becomes available just before the season, championship contenders could see a quick upgrade. CBS Sports reported that some programs were already looking into possible additions, while others have held back because of roster space and locker-room chemistry.
Lanning, though, sees the move as taking opportunity from one player and handing it to another who had already moved on.
"To have somebody come back - ultimately, it used to be once you had an agent, or once you went and did the combine, or once you went to many of those things, all those things qualified as you are no longer an amateur," Lanning said. "You're a professional now once you declare for the draft."
College athletics has already changed dramatically with revenue sharing and NIL compensation, but Lanning still believes there needs to be a meaningful separation between college and the NFL.
"So to let any of those players come back, fair or unfair to them, it's unfair to the sport," Lanning said, "and I think it's unfair to the players who are on current teams for those guys to be coming back."
In Other News...
Dillon Thienemans NFL Learning Curve Suddenly Matters A Lot
Dillon Thienemans first NFL camp has become one of the more important development stories for Chicago, and not just because he entered as a rookie learning a new defensive language on the fly. The former Oregon safety has spent training camp getting up to speed with the Bears system and the faster processing demands that come with it, while also handling the usual growing pains that come with adjusting from college football to the pro game.
The timing has made the learning curve matter even more. With injuries thinning the secondary, Chicago needs Thieneman to keep trending in the right direction, and his progress has been noticeable in practice and preseason action, including an interception against the Bengals. The Bears are counting on him not just as depth, but as someone who can step into a larger role and help stabilize a safety group that has already been tested. [Read more 🡒]
Oregon's Backfield Future Just Got More Intriguing With This RB Commit
CaDarius McMiller keeps giving Oregon reasons to be excited about what comes next. The Ducks running back commit showed off his speed and athleticism during a preseason scrimmage at Tyler High School in Texas, and his track background only adds to the appeal. A 100-meter time of 10.59 seconds hints at the kind of burst that can change a backfield, especially for a program that keeps looking to reload with dynamic pieces.
For Oregon, the interesting part is not just the talent, but the timing. McMiller is expected to help shape the Ducks future in the backfield, and there is already some intrigue around whether he could enroll early and get a head start in spring practice. If that happens, it would give Oregon an even longer look at a runner who brings real speed to the table and seems built to fit the programs style. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Could Suddenly Have A Wild Roster Decision To Make
A Louisiana judges temporary injunction has cracked open a strange new lane in college football, allowing 30 former college athletes, including 16 football players now on NFL rosters, to return for one more season. For programs across the sport, the ruling has created an immediate gray area: do coaches treat it as a one-off legal wrinkle, or as a recruiting opportunity that could reshape a roster almost overnight?
Dan Lanning has already made clear where he stands, criticizing the decision as unfair to players who have earned their spots the hard way. But while Oregon is taking a principled line, other coaches such as North Carolinas Bill Belichick are weighing how to use the ruling, and some schools have already reached out to NFL players about the possibility of coming back. For the Ducks, it is another reminder that the transfer and eligibility landscape can change fast, even for teams trying to build stability from one season to the next. [Read more 🡒]