Paul Finebaum didn’t hold back Sunday after a wild SEC weekend, putting Arch Manning and Trinidad Chambliss in the same bucket of costly quarterback mistakes.
Speaking on “The Matt Barrie Show,” the ESPN analyst ripped into late-game blunders around college football while reacting to No. 11 Tennessee’s 27-24 loss at South Carolina. In that game, George MacIntyre’s shaky finish helped turn a promising Volunteers lead into a Gamecocks win.
“I’ve never seen more teams screw up in the last two minutes in my life,” Finebaum said. “Tennessee gave that game away.
“I’m not a psychiatrist, but the human emotion, there’s so much pressure. We’ve seen Arch Manning and Trinidad Chambliss both make idiotic mistakes, and they’re two of the very best. You get down to the level of a George MacIntyre of Tennessee, who is good and was on the verge of a really big win, and he manages to give it away.”
Tennessee led 24-17 and went for it on fourth-and-1 at the South Carolina 38 with less than four minutes to play. MacIntyre kept the ball rather than handing it to tight end DaSaahn Brame, and coach Josh Heupel later said it was “just missteps by George on that one.”
The Gamecocks erased the deficit by tying the score with 1:17 left, then got the decisive break when Dylan Stewart strip-sacked MacIntyre with 33 seconds remaining. Malik Orsan finished the comeback with a 48-yard walk-off field goal.
Manning’s night was no better for Texas in a 34-27 win over Ole Miss. The Longhorns built enough of a cushion to survive, but the quarterback’s turnovers kept the Rebels alive after Texas led 24-3 at halftime.
Manning threw a first-quarter interception, then lost a third-quarter fumble that Kam Franklin returned into the end zone. Ole Miss picked him off again after the score was tied 24-24 early in the fourth quarter.
He did bounce back with the go-ahead touchdown, a 1-yard run, but the stat line still told the story: his minus-0.57 expected points added per dropback ranked in the second percentile of single-game performances this season.
This wasn’t even Finebaum’s first swing at Manning. After Texas’ 27-24 loss to Oklahoma on Oct. 10, he called him “downright stupid.” And before Saturday’s game, he said Texas coach Steve Sarkisian, not Manning, would take the biggest hit if the Longhorns lost again.
Chambliss entered the Texas game with a big endorsement from ESPN’s Kirk Herbstreit, who named him the best quarterback in the country before kickoff. But the Ole Miss starter had a rougher night than his reputation suggested, throwing a career-high three interceptions after never having thrown more than one in a game for the Rebels.
One of those picks came on the snap after Manning’s first interception, when Texas’ Justin Cryer came up with the turnover. Another came on fourth-and-goal from the Texas 2 with 1:41 left in the first half.
Chambliss still dragged Ole Miss back into the fight by throwing two second-half touchdown passes to Horatio Fields to tie the game. After an onside kick, he pushed the Rebels into Texas territory, but Jelani McDonald intercepted his Hail Mary on the final play.
Texas snapped a two-game losing streak and improved to 5-2. Ole Miss dropped to 5-2.
In Other News...
Arch Manning Added One More Twist To Ole Miss Loss
Texas win over Ole Miss came with a little postgame theater, thanks to Arch Manning and a sideline conversation that added another layer to an already notable night. The game was carried by ABCs top broadcast crew, with Holly Rowe on the sideline, and Manning used the moment after the final whistle to make a lighthearted pitch that she ought to be around more often when Texas takes the field.
It was a playful line, but it also carried a bit of history behind it, since Rowe, Manning and coach Steve Sarkisian were all part of a previous dustup that had already been smoothed over. Against Ole Miss, the whole exchange served as a reminder that even after the game ends, there can still be a little extra edge and a little extra entertainment attached to Texas football. [Read more 🡒]
Ole Miss Showed Fight At Texas But One Problem Just Got Bigger
Ole Miss left Austin with a loss, but not without evidence that the seasons bigger questions are still alive. After trailing 24-3 at halftime, the Rebels regrouped and turned a rough afternoon into a game that mattered deep into the second half, even if Texas eventually escaped with a 34-27 win. The first half was the problem area, with the offense stuck in neutral and quarterback Chambliss throwing an interception as the Rebels struggled to get anything going.
The second-half response was the encouraging part, because Ole Miss showed the kind of fight that can keep a season from slipping away after an early deficit. Still, the loss comes with real weight, especially with important games ahead that could shape the Rebels playoff position. The comeback effort bought some credibility, but it also left one lingering concern: the margin for error is getting smaller. [Read more 🡒]
Kirk Herbstreit Had The Perfect Reaction To Ole Miss Wild Finish
Ole Miss made one of the most dramatic pushes of Week 8 against Texas, storming back to tie the game before the Longhorns answered with a late touchdown to finish it off. The Rebels rally included a recovered onside kick that instantly became one of the nights biggest moments, and Kirk Herbstreit was right there to capture the chaos from his seat.
Herbstreit later shared a video of his reaction, making clear he was rooting for the spectacle more than for either sideline. It was the kind of candid, live-on-the-spot moment that college football fans love from him, and it came with Herbstreit set to be back on College GameDay in Bloomington for Minnesota-Indiana in Week 9. [Read more 🡒]