The first AP Top 25 after Week 1 should have been the moment preseason assumptions started to crack. Instead, Joel Klatt saw one result in particular and came away thinking the poll had barely budged at all.
His biggest issue centered on Ole Miss and Louisville, the only ranked matchup of the opening weekend. The Rebels edged the Cardinals 41-38 at Nissan Stadium on Lucas Carneiro’s 48-yard field goal as time expired, but the AP still left them 15 spots apart.
Ole Miss checked in at No. 9, while Louisville stayed at No. 24.
Klatt unloaded on that gap on "The Joel Klatt Show," arguing the ranking made no sense after the teams spent four quarters proving how close they were.
"But you're telling me that there are 15 spots between Louisville and Ole Miss?" Klatt said.
"Did I not just see them play a game to the buzzer? Ole Miss is going to move up and they're nine, and Louisville just stays at 24?"
He went a step further, calling the separation "patently absurd" and saying the poll still felt tied to a rigid formula rather than what actually happened on the field.
"If you win, you stay. If you lose, you drop," Klatt said.
"If you win, you move up a little bit. If you lose, you drop.
And there's just no common sense."
The game itself gave him plenty to point to. Louisville erased a 14-point deficit in the fourth quarter and tied it with 1:10 left before Trinidad Chambliss helped push Ole Miss into range for the winning kick. Klatt’s view was simple: nothing about that finish suggested a 15-slot canyon between the teams.
He wasn’t complaining about every AP decision, though. Klatt said Michigan dropping out after scraping past Western Michigan 13-12 on a disputed final-second play and a Hail Mary was the right call. He also had no problem with Louisville remaining in the Top 25 after the loss.
His frustration was less about the Cardinals being ranked at all and more about where voters put them compared with the team that beat them. In his eyes, the AP protected the winner’s preseason place while keeping the loser stuck near the bottom.
That theme showed up again in Klatt’s own Week 1 rankings. He pushed LSU from No. 8 in his preseason ballot all the way up to No. 3 after the Tigers crushed Clemson 51-10.
The AP moved LSU only three spots, from No. 11 to No. 8.
Miami was another place where Klatt and the AP split. The Hurricanes rolled Stanford 45-6 behind 400 passing yards from Darian Mensah and a defense that controlled the game.
Klatt put Miami at No. 4, three spots higher than the AP’s No. 7.
"Miami at seven. Seven?
Seven?" Klatt said.
"Did we not watch that? Did we not see their defensive line play so great?
LSU at eight. Can we not adjust?"
Even with those disagreements, Klatt lined up with voters at the very top. He had Ohio State No. 1 after the Buckeyes beat Ball State 56-3. The larger point for him was what Week 1 is supposed to do: force real movement when the games finally start counting.
Klatt’s argument was not that every voter has to see the sport the same way. It was that the results should matter more than the preseason order.
In Other News...
Ole Miss Fans Need To Know These New Vaught-Hemingway Game Day Changes
Ole Miss is set for a late start at Vaught-Hemingway Stadium on Saturday, Sept. 12, 2026, when Charlotte comes to Oxford for a 6:45 p.m. CT kickoff. For fans headed to the stadium, the important part is not just the matchup itself but the full game day setup around it, from ticketing and arrival times to the policies in place once they get inside.
The Rebels are also rolling out updated traffic flow arrangements designed to keep the crowds moving more smoothly around the stadium, and officials are urging fans to use NFC-enabled mobile tickets to avoid delays. With the full slate of gameday schedules and stadium rules in play, the message is clear: a little planning ahead should make for a safer, more organized night in Oxford. [Read more 🡒]
Ole Miss Has A Real Stake In LSUs Latest SEC Fight
The SECs next round of meetings is set for Sept. 10, and LSU will be one of the leagues most closely watched topics. The Tigers already filled their 105-player roster without the former NFL players at the center of the dispute, while the conference has backed away from seriously considering the most extreme penalty, including expulsion. Still, the issue is far from settled, and it has now moved into a legal lane as much as a football one.
For Ole Miss, the stakes are obvious because whatever happens to LSU could help shape how the league handles roster rules and enforcement going forward. A hearing on the SECs request for an injunction against LSU has already been postponed, and the conference has filed suit claiming a First Amendment right to expressive association. The Rebels are watching the fight with more than casual interest, since the outcome could influence how much room SEC schools have to build their rosters under the leagues changing standards. [Read more 🡒]
Ole Miss Has A Consistency Problem Golding Wants Fixed Fast
Pete Golding did not need a long film session to spot the issue after Ole Miss opened the season against Louisville. The Rebels showed one version of themselves in the first half, when the defense held firm, then another after halftime when the offense had to play with more urgency to keep things moving. For Golding, the takeaway was less about the scoreboard than the rhythm of the performance, and how far the team still has to go before it can put together four clean quarters.
Now the focus shifts to Charlotte, and Golding is pushing for a much tighter blend of offense and defense. He sees the ability in the roster, but also the kind of mistakes that can snowball when a team is not playing in sync. For Ole Miss, the next step is not simply being good in stretches. It is doing it together, long enough to avoid the trouble that inconsistency can bring. [Read more 🡒]