Last season’s Heisman race had a clean winner in Indiana quarterback Fernando Mendoza, but the case for Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss is stronger than the final voting line suggests.
Mendoza took home the trophy after leading Indiana to the program’s first national championship, and the source material makes clear he earned it. Still, Chambliss landed eighth in the Heisman voting despite starting two fewer games, and that’s where the debate starts to get interesting. If he had been the starter for Ole Miss all year, the argument goes, he would have won it.
The biggest wrinkle is timing. The Heisman is handed out before the playoffs, so postseason numbers don’t count.
Through the regular season, Mendoza finished with 2,980 passing yards and 39 total touchdowns. Chambliss, in fewer starts, put up 3,016 passing yards and 24 total touchdowns.
There’s also the matter of those two games Chambliss didn’t start. Austin Simmons opened against Georgia State and Kentucky, throwing for 341 yards against Georgia State and 235 against Kentucky, with 4 total touchdowns in those two games. If Chambliss had started both and produced the same output, his season would have jumped to 3,592 passing yards and 28 touchdowns.
That would still leave Mendoza ahead in touchdowns, but Chambliss would be sitting on more than 600 additional passing yards. On raw numbers, Mendoza would still have the edge in some areas. But the Heisman has never been a pure stat award.
Voters also weigh team success and how much a player drives it. Indiana went undefeated in the regular season and won the Big 10 championship.
Mendoza was central to that run, though he also had the second-best defense in the country backing him up. Ole Miss finished 11-1, and Chambliss went 9-1 as a starter.
The Rebels’ defense ranked 29th nationally in points per game, which makes Chambliss’ footprint on their season look even bigger.
Then there’s the Heisman moment, that one signature snapshot voters love to remember. Mendoza’s came in Happy Valley, where he beat Penn State on a last-second touchdown. Chambliss had a pair of moments that fit the award just as well, if not better: a 314-yard performance in a win over fourth-ranked LSU in Mississippi, or the road victory over 13th-ranked Oklahoma, when he threw for 315 yards to keep Ole Miss’ playoff hopes alive.
Mendoza also had a road win over number three Oregon, throwing for 215 yards in that game. But the source material argues Chambliss’ biggest performances carried more weight because they were more directly tied to Ole Miss’ biggest wins. He helped knock off the fourth-ranked team in the country and then went into a hostile setting against one of the nation’s best defenses and topped 300 passing yards.
The comparison even tilts further when you look at Mendoza’s ranked-road production. He threw for 100 fewer yards in that win over a ranked opponent away from home.
So while Mendoza had the trophy, the story here is that Chambliss may have had the stronger Heisman case if he’d been given the full season as Ole Miss’ starter. The season Mendoza put together was historic, but Chambliss’ impact on his team’s success was bigger, and that’s what keeps this debate alive.
In Other News...
Ole Miss Is Finally Pushing Back In A Bitter LSU Dispute
Ole Miss is still waiting on buyout payments tied to two former players who signed revenue-sharing contracts before leaving for LSU, a situation that has lingered for roughly six months and now has athletic director Keith Carter talking openly about the next step. In this case, the usual expectation is that the new school covers those fees, but that has not happened yet, leaving the Rebels to decide how long to keep waiting on the other side to make it right.
Carter said the school is considering legal action to collect the money rather than simply letting the issue sit, a sign the dispute has moved beyond routine paperwork and into something more contentious. Off the field, Ole Miss has already locked in a football field sponsorship for the coming season and should announce it soon, though a jersey patch deal is still not finalized as the Rebels keep working through their business side heading into the fall. [Read more 🡒]
Ole Miss Just Got A Tense New Twist In Five-Star RB Race
Five-star running back David Gabriel Georges is still working through one of the most closely watched recruiting decisions on the board, with his announcement set for July 22 and Ole Miss still in the mix alongside Tennessee and Ohio State. The Rebels have stayed involved in a race that has drawn plenty of attention because of the level of talent involved and the possibility that this recruitment could end up setting a new market for elite backs.
What makes the situation even more intriguing is that the public messaging around Georges has not lined up cleanly. His uncle had previously suggested a private decision was already in place, but Georges pushed back on that idea, leaving the sense that this one is still very much alive as the clock ticks toward his announcement. For Ole Miss, that kind of uncertainty at least keeps the door open in a race where every signal seems to matter. [Read more 🡒]
Ole Miss May Have Found A Portal Defender NFL Scouts Love
Ole Miss added another intriguing piece through the portal for the 2026 season in Keaton Thomas, a versatile defender whose profile has already started to draw NFL attention. Thomas arrives with production at Baylor and West Virginia, along with the kind of physical traits and college rsum that scouts tend to circle when they are looking for a player who might still be climbing.
The Rebels could be a useful stage for that rise. Pete Goldings aggressive scheme should give Thomas chances to make plays, and the jump to SEC competition brings the sort of weekly test that can sharpen a draft case fast. If he settles in next to Suntarine Perkins, Ole Miss may have a defender who can thrive without always drawing the full weight of an opponents game plan, which is exactly the kind of setup that can change how a player is viewed nationally. [Read more 🡒]