The 2027 NFL draft quarterback picture is getting scrambled, and the latest update from Mel Kiper Jr. puts a former walk-on ahead of a name that has drawn plenty of attention in its own right.
Kiper’s refreshed Big Board on Thursday had Drew Mestemaker of Oklahoma State sitting at No. 2 overall and leading the quarterback group. Mestemaker, who began his college career as a walk-on at North Texas after playing high school safety, has turned himself into one of the season’s biggest stories.
Kiper praised the way he works the pocket, writing, "I love the way he scans the field and bides his time in the pocket," and added, "Mestemaker has the big arm to make all of the throws, with 44 completions going for 20-plus yards this season (most in FBS). But he also has the mobility to pick up nice chunks of yardage on the ground."
At 6-foot-3 and 215 pounds, Mestemaker’s rise has been anything but ordinary. In his second season with the Mean Green, he led all of FBS in passing with 4,379 yards, 34 touchdowns and nine interceptions.
Through eight games at Oklahoma State, he’s on pace to land in the neighborhood of 4,000 passing yards for a second straight season. His movement ability also stands out, though it comes more from necessity than design.
That shift at the top comes as the quarterback class has not quite matched the preseason buzz. Injuries have already changed the conversation, with Oregon’s Dante Moore serving as the clearest example. Moore had been viewed as a likely No. 2 overall pick for the New York Jets in the 2026 NFL draft, but after returning to the Ducks, he suffered a season-ending injury four games into the year.
Performance has also forced evaluators to rethink things. Arch Manning was excellent down the stretch in 2025, but his uneven play this season has raised questions after Texas invested heavily in improving the roster around him.
The broader trend has been clear: the top quarterbacks right now are not the usual blue-chip recruits who arrived in college as consensus five-stars. They’re the ones who transferred up from lower levels and forced their way into the conversation.
That includes Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss, who became a name to watch for 2027 after a strong 2026 season. But his stock has taken a hit this year. After nearly 4,000 passing yards and 22 touchdowns a season ago, his production has slipped, and scouts have taken notice.
Not all of that decline is on Chambliss. Running back Kewan Lacy, an AP All-American in 2025, has missed significant time in 2026 because of lingering injuries, leaving Chambliss with more on his plate than he had last season.
The turnover issue has also become harder to ignore. Chambliss threw only three interceptions all of last year, but he has already tossed eight through eight games in 2026, including a three-interception performance against Texas.
Even with that résumé, Chambliss does not offer the same physical profile as Mestemaker in the eyes of NFL teams. At 6 feet and 205 pounds, he’s built in the mold of Russell Wilson and Drew Brees, two quarterbacks who won Super Bowls but still fell out of the first round of their respective drafts.
In Other News...
Oklahoma State Gets An Early Test Its New-Look Rotation Must Pass
Oklahoma States season-opening win over Incarnate Word gave the Cowboys a first look at their new rotation, but the next step comes quickly with Queens visiting Gallagher-Iba Arena. The Royals arrive with momentum after a 2-0 start and the kind of profile that demands attention, having reached the NCAA Tournament last season before moving into Division I and becoming the ASUN favorite.
For the Cowboys, this is the sort of early measuring-stick game that can reveal how quickly the transfers and returning pieces are settling in. Queens has already shown it can score and compete against quality opponents, which should make for a useful test of Oklahoma States depth, pace and defensive edge before the schedule gets any more demanding. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State Faces A Season Defining Test In Manhattan
With four games left and a bowl berth still within reach, Oklahoma State heads to Manhattan knowing this one carries real weight. The Cowboys are trying to get to six wins after a close loss to Iowa State knocked them further off the pace in the Big 12 race, and the margin for error is getting thin as the season winds down.
Kansas State brings a balanced offense and a defense that can make life difficult, so Oklahoma State will need a cleaner showing on that side of the ball to keep its postseason path intact. Caleb Hawkins has given the Cowboys a needed lift lately, and his recent surge has become one of the brighter signs for a team that now has to answer a bigger question: can it turn those flashes into a result that keeps the season alive? [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State Faces An Early Test As New-Look Lineup Returns Home
Oklahoma State is back home for the second game of a three-game homestand, and the early read on this new-look lineup has been encouraging. The Cowgirls opened the season with a win over Southern, getting strong play from newcomers and key contributors alike as they settled into a fresh rotation under game conditions.
Morgan State brings a little more urgency to Stillwater after splitting its first two games, with a loss to Colorado followed by a win over Washington Adventist. For Oklahoma State, this is the kind of early-season test that can reveal how quickly the group is gelling, especially against a team that has already shown it can bounce back from a setback. [Read more 🡒]