Saturday’s game between Oklahoma State and Arizona State looks even enough on the surface, but the Cowboys have one clear path they need to own if they want to walk out with a win: Caleb Hawkins has to win his battle with the Sun Devils’ front four.
Both teams enter at 6-4 overall and 4-3 in Big 12 play, and both are already headed to a bowl. The difference now is how high Oklahoma State can climb.
The Cowboys are coming off a 52-27 loss to Texas Tech, but this season they’ve answered each of their previous three losses with a win. A victory here would strengthen their case for the best possible bowl destination.
The quarterback situation adds another layer. Drew Mestemaker is questionable with a shoulder injury he has described as a stinger, though ESPN’s Pete Thamel reported Saturday that it is more of a strain.
Mestemaker is with the team in Arizona and is a game-time decision. If he can’t go, true freshman Broderick Vehrs should start.
That uncertainty only makes Hawkins more important.
He’s been one of the most dangerous backs in the country all season, and Oklahoma State has leaned into that in a big way. Hawkins has 1,172 rushing yards and seven touchdowns on the ground, plus 45 catches for 476 yards as a receiver.
Over his last five games, he has piled up nearly 1,000 yards from scrimmage. He ranks second nationally in all-purpose yards per game and yards from scrimmage per game at 164.8.
The Cowboys have already shown how much more dangerous he becomes when they move him around. Against Houston on Oct.
17, Hawkins caught seven passes for 125 yards and a touchdown. He later said he was told he would be getting more receptions, and that shift opened up the middle of the field for Oklahoma State’s other receivers.
When Hawkins was split out wide, a safety had to account for him.
Since then, he’s been used both as a receiver out of the backfield and as a split-out target. The results have followed.
After that Houston game, he ripped off three straight 100-yard rushing performances before Texas Tech managed to slow him down last Saturday. Even then, he still finished with 143 yards.
Eric Morris is using Hawkins wherever he can, and with Mestemaker banged up, that usage figures to matter even more. The offensive line obviously has to do its part, but Hawkins’ versatility is what can create problems for Arizona State.
The Sun Devils’ defense allows 117.8 rushing yards per game, which ranks No. 30 in FBS. Kenny Dillingham likely studied the Texas Tech tape and saw the best blueprint yet for slowing Oklahoma State’s outside zone run game. That gives Arizona State something to work with.
The challenge for the Cowboys is that the Sun Devils bring a front built to absorb punishment. They use the same 4-2-5 scheme that Skyler Cassity runs for Oklahoma State, but Arizona State may have more depth up front. The Sun Devils list six projected starters across their four defensive line spots, plus a “RUSH” player who can function as an extra pass rusher or linebacker depending on how Brian Ward wants to deploy him.
Inside, the size is real. C.J.
Fite is a 310-pound nose tackle with three years of experience, and beside him will be either Blazen Lono-Wong at 305 pounds or Zac Swanson at 295. Both are fifth-year players whose job is to clog the middle.
Oklahoma State has had some success with inside zone read this season, but that kind of mass in the middle makes life difficult. At the same time, it can also create opportunities for the outside zone read the Cowboys like to lean on.
On the edge, Arizona State has more problems for an offense to solve. Jalen Thompson, a 265-pound senior, is their best pass rusher and also does a strong job setting the edge against the run. On the other side, Roman Pitre or Emar'rion Winston will be lined up there, and all three have at least four years of college experience.
The Sun Devils also rotate heavily, with a dozen backups across those four spots, much like Oklahoma State does to keep players fresh.
That’s why the Cowboys may need to be patient early and accept shorter gains while they probe for weak spots in the front four. Hawkins could take some hits at the start. But the outside zone read is built around one cut and go: follow the blocks, find the crease, and take what’s there.
If Oklahoma State can keep chipping away, those 2-yard gains can turn into 4-yard gains, and eventually 10-yard plays later in the game. The Cowboys need their line to grind early, and Morris needs to keep feeding Hawkins while also getting him into space in the passing game at the right moments to force Arizona State to adjust.
If Oklahoma State wins that matchup, it likely wins the game. Given the way Hawkins has been rolling over the last month, 175 total yards and two touchdowns would probably be enough.
In Other News...
Oklahoma State Heads To Tempe With One Huge Drew Mestemaker Concern
Oklahoma State heads to Tempe for a Big 12 matchup that suddenly feels like a hinge point for both programs, with the Cowboys and Arizona State carrying identical records into the weekend. The Cowboys have leaned on quarterback Drew Mestemaker and running back Caleb Hawkins to keep the offense moving, while the Sun Devils have gotten meaningful production from freshmen Cardae Mack and Jake Fette as they continue to round into form on both sides of the ball.
The bigger concern for Oklahoma State is Mestemakers status after he was banged up in the previous game, and that uncertainty hangs over everything the Cowboys want to do offensively. Arizona State, meanwhile, comes in with some momentum after clinching bowl eligibility at UCF, so the stage is set for a game where health, depth and execution could matter just as much as the matchup itself. [Read more 🡒]
Bedlam Could Return For Oklahoma State In The Most Unexpected Spot
A familiar rivalry could find an unfamiliar stage this winter, with Oklahoma and Oklahoma State athletic directors both leaving the door open to a postseason meeting. Instead of the regular-season Bedlam setup fans knew for generations, the two schools could wind up sharing a bowl spotlight if the right selection process breaks their way.
Both teams are bowl-eligible, and Oklahoma State has put itself in position to play beyond the regular season again after a long wait. The rest now depends on bowl committees and conference selections, which makes the possibility intriguing but far from certain, even as the idea of a Bedlam rematch in December or January starts to feel more real than it has in years. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State Still Has One Big Recruiting Question After Latest Commitment
Oklahoma State added another piece to its 2027 recruiting class with the commitment of Markius Woods, a three-star defensive lineman from The Lawrenceville School in New Jersey. Woods gives the Cowboys another body up front and adds to a class that already stretches coast-to-coast, with pledges spread across defensive line, linebacker, secondary, quarterback, running back, tight end, wide receiver and offensive line.
The commitment helps reinforce one area, but the class still has some obvious spots to fill before it starts looking complete. Even with the latest addition, the Cowboys are still chasing help in several places, and the next wave of recruiting will go a long way toward showing how balanced this group can become. [Read more 🡒]
