Oklahoma State Survived Its Worst Half And Still Found A Road Win

Oklahoma State's remarkable second-half surge overpowers Arizona State in an overtime thriller, spotlighting a resilient defense and strategic adjustments.

Drew Mestemaker was supposed to be the question mark for Oklahoma State on Saturday. Instead, he became the steady hand that carried the Cowboys through a wild 30-27 overtime win over Arizona State.

Oklahoma State had to survive the same old script first, though: a sluggish start, a long climb back, and a finish that came down to the smallest of margins. The Cowboys trailed 24-7 at halftime, then rallied all the way back before Sam Keltner’s field goal forced overtime. From there, OSU got the break it needed when Arizona State’s final possession ended with safety Quinton Hammonds picking off Jake Fette after Cardae Mack’s direct snap and toss to Fette in motion.

Mestemaker’s availability had been a storyline all week. He was questionable on the player availability report, and Dave Hunziker had even leaned toward him not playing on the Cowboys Radio Network pre-game show because Mestemaker was “very limited” in practice.

Oklahoma State kept everyone guessing right up to kickoff, with both Mestemaker and Broderick Vehrs throwing on the sideline before the game. In the end, Mestemaker played the whole way and didn’t look limited at all.

He finished with 294 passing yards and nol touchdowns - seriously, no touchdowns. But the first half was rough for the offense, and Arizona State deserves plenty of credit for that. The Sun Devils were outstanding against the run early, which squeezed Oklahoma State’s options and helped force the Cowboys into an uneven opening 30 minutes.

The second quarter, in particular, was brutal for OSU. Terrence Lewis had a catch stripped away by Martell Hughes, and Arizona State turned that into a 60-yard touchdown pass from Jake Fette to Reed Harris.

Cowboys cornerback LaDainian Fields got a hand on the ball, but it still ended up in Harris’ hands. Then on the next drive, Mestemaker was trying to move the chains on 3rd-and-1 when Jalen Thompson sacked him by catching his ankle with his hand, and that sequence ended in a field goal instead of a much-needed answer.

That left Oklahoma State staring at a 24-7 deficit at the break, and the numbers told the story of a team that just didn’t have much edge early. The Cowboys punted on four of five drives after their opening touchdown drive, which is exactly the kind of thing Eric Morris hates. He said at halftime there was plenty to fix.

And fix it they did.

Oklahoma State has made a habit of turning on the second-half switch, and Saturday was no different. The Cowboys lead the country with more than 21 second-half points per game, and they looked like that team again after the break.

Arizona State opened the third quarter with a punt, and the defense started making true freshman quarterback Jake Fette look like a true freshman. OSU got more pressure, forced him into tougher throws, and nearly came up with a pick when Fette let one fly while being chased down.

The offensive line was the real engine of the comeback. On the first play of the half, an inside zone run gave Caleb Hawkins room to work, and the tone never really changed after that.

Mestemaker had cleaner pockets, Hawkins found bigger lanes, and the receivers had more space to operate. The Cowboys started to wear down Arizona State until they finally tied the game.

One of the smartest plays of the night came on Hawkins’ second touchdown run, when he checked out of a full-house blitz look from Arizona State. That kind of processing is exactly what Morris keeps talking about.

Then came the late-game test. Arizona State bled clock after Oklahoma State tied it, but the Cowboys got the stop they needed and forced the Sun Devils to settle for a field goal with 3:12 left, putting ASU ahead 27-24. That sent Mestemaker back out with one timeout and a two-minute drill in his hands.

Oklahoma State had not produced a game-winning drive in that situation this season, and the march got complicated quickly. Justin Bowick was lost when a defender rolled up on his leg, but Wyatt Young kept the drive alive. Young hauled in a 12-yard catch in traffic, then two plays later Mestemaker hit him on the sideline for a 22-yard gain to the Arizona State 31 before the two-minute timeout.

The drive stalled from there, though the Cowboys still had enough to force overtime. Keltner, who had missed only one field goal all year, stepped in from 43 yards and tied it at 27-27.

In overtime, Oklahoma State settled for a field goal after Mestemaker couldn’t connect with Young on back-to-back throws. That left the door open for Arizona State, and Hammonds slammed it shut with the interception to end the game.

In Other News...

Arizona State Faces A Dangerous Oklahoma State Test At The Worst Time

With both Oklahoma State and Arizona State sitting at 6-4, their Week 12 meeting arrives with plenty still hanging in the balance. The Cowboys have spent enough of the season showing they can be efficient on offense, while Arizona State has leaned on a defense that has generally held up well enough to keep games within reach. It is the kind of late-season matchup that can say a lot about where each program is headed, especially when records are this close and the margin for error is gone.

The wrinkle for Arizona State is that Oklahoma State brings a more dangerous overall profile than the Sun Devils may want this time of year, particularly against a defense that has had some vulnerable spots in the back end. The betting lean points toward the Cowboys not just winning, but doing enough to separate from the spread, which makes this feel less like a coin flip than the records suggest. For Oklahoma State, it is another chance to turn efficiency into a statement. [Read more 🡒]

Oklahoma State Showed Promise In Charleston Before One Problem Took Over

Oklahoma State had stretches in the Shriners Childrens Charleston Classic that suggested there was something to build on, but the Cowboys could not sustain it in an 85-70 loss to Minnesota. Kashie Natt gave them a needed lift with 22 points and nine rebounds, while Isaac Asuma paced Minnesota with 17 points as the game gradually tilted away from the Cowboys.

The bigger issue was the perimeter, where Oklahoma State never found a rhythm and kept coming up empty from deep. The Cowboys finished 6-of-27 from three-point range overall, and the second half offered no relief as the outside shots stopped falling just when they needed a push to get back into it. [Read more 🡒]

Oklahoma State Needed Drew Mestemaker To Gut Through A Real Concern

Drew Mestemakers status was already a concern before Oklahoma State ever kicked off against Arizona State, with the quarterback a game-time decision because of a shoulder injury. Even so, he took the start and gave the Cowboys what they needed early, keeping his streak of 200-yard passing games alive while adding to a season that had already put him in the conversation for the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm award.

The injury never really disappeared from the picture, though, and Mestemaker kept playing through it before eventually coming out in the fourth quarter. He finished with 277 passing yards, a touchdown and two interceptions, a line that reflected both his toughness and the strain Oklahoma State had to manage as the game wore on. [Read more 🡒]